3 ms·
What is left to say about this? Does anyone have any new insights? I want encryption so I can perform online transactions safely. Or at least safe enough that
by TheSpiceIsLife 11y ago
What is left to say about this? Does anyone have any new insights?
I want encryption so I can perform online transactions safely. Or at least safe enough that the financial services I use online can ensure the movement of my money.
If I want encryption to communicate online then it all comes down to who you trust. Who do you trust? Certainly not any provider of encrypted messaging services, since we can't audit their code, can't guarantee there isn't a TLA (Three Letter Acronym) plant working there, can't guarantee it's not a TLA front, can't guarantee the service provider isn't subject to a NSL etc etc.
I'm not sure I'm convinced this is a human rights issue. How would we enforce the right? Rights that aren't enforceable aren't much use. Negative Rights[2] and all that.
The UN's 'The Universal Declaration of Human Rights'[1] is a nice document, but it's existence hasn't made those things real. Adding another article, or interpreting the right to encryption in to an existing article, does not, and can not, ensure that right.
What am I trying to say? Probably something like: if there are people who are inclined to, and have the power to, infringe your right to privacy, you're probably pretty screwed.
1. http://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/ http://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights (... rights are ranked by degree of importance, and violations of lesser ones are accepted in the course of preventing violations of greater ones ...)
- guard-of-terra 11y ago"If I want encryption to communicate online then it all comes down to who you trust. Who do you trust?" You trust your own SSH key pairs, for example.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoDo you trust your Operating System? Anything you encrypt has to be in cleat text at some point in time.
- jensen123 11y ago> What is left to say about this? Does anyone have any new insights? There is one thing that I'm really, really wondering about. Are large cities like London and New York basically screwed? Let me explain: One large city with 10-20 million people is obviously far more vulnerable to terrorism than 10 smaller cities of 1-2 million each. Obviously Amnesty is correct that encryption is good for freedom of speech, human rights etc. Also, encryption is necessary for business/banking in a modern world. But let's not kid ourselves, terrorists can also hide behind encryption. Terrorism is nothing new, and there will probably be more of it in the future. I'm not a law expert, but my impression is that the countries in Europe with the worst laws for privacy is the UK and France. Probably because that is where you find the largest cities: London and Paris. These people are scared/worried. I can see no other reason why they would enact laws like these. So in the future, when there are more terrorism attacks, knee-jerk politicians (and their voters!) will probably want even more laws restricting encryption. This will make these places even worse for both human rights and business. The industrial revolution basically created mega-cities. Is modern computer technology making them impractical?
- marcosdumay 11y agoThey were always impractical, technology is just starting to make the alternatives viable. But This point isn't correct. Those privacy breaking laws do not help fighting terrorism.
- stegosaurus 11y agoThe thing is that even these cities aren't that vulnerable. Imagine you're a terrorist. Where are you going to attack for maximum impact? Piccadilly Circus? Heathrow? Gatwick? Or a random suburb out at the end of a line somewhere?
- jensen123 11y agoI see your point. Much of this vulnerability is psychological, though. If you look at how many people have died from terrorism in the past, it's not many, at least compared to things like cancer, heart disease or traffic accidents. Still, I remember how most Americans were more than happy to give up their freedoms and human rights after September 11, in order to fight terrorism. Never mind that those freedoms and human rights were probably much of the reason why the US became great (compare it to say Argentina or Russia). Ironically, I think in order to preserve freedom during periods of terrorism, we would have to do away with democracy, since most voters are such morons.