7 ms·
With Oracle's Java lawsuits wondering if Microsoft has a chance to make a move and try to displace Java. It won't happen completely because it is the new COBOL
by rdtsc 11y ago
With Oracle's Java lawsuits wondering if Microsoft has a chance to make a move and try to displace Java. It won't happen completely because it is the new COBOL but if they can deliver on performance and stability on Linux and other platform there might be a chance.
Go is making progress there, but those that want a more mature type system will probably appreciate C# more.
- barrkel 11y agoC# is not different enough to Java to warrant the effort. There would need to be a killer differentiator, something only C# can do, and Java can't. Cross-platform including iOS might be it, but it's a bit of a stretch. I don't see C# displacing Java where Java is currently used in server-side development.
- heartsucker 11y agoLicensing could be enough alone. We're auditing everything we use for license issues because we don't have to get bit by the GPL and have to opensource all our proprietary software. Even if C# was noticeably worse (for some arbitrary definition or worse), if it had a more permissible license, that alone could draw people to it. (Note: I don't know anything about the Java / C# licenses. This is just talking in general.)
- jimktrains2 11y ago> get bit by the GPL and have to opensource all our proprietary software The tone here sounds very angry. You aren't "bit" by the GPL, you choose to participate in the usage of the license and the community of code that comes with it. It's not some unknown, nasty thing you need to constantly defend yourself against (as implied by "being bit" like it's a dog you need to watch out for everywhere). "We're auditing everything we use for license issues because we activly choose not to participate in the GPL community and would rather abuse and profit from other people's good will" is closer to realitiy
- coldtea 11y ago>The tone here sounds very angry. You aren't "bit" by the GPL, you choose to participate in the usage of the license and the community of code that comes with it. It's not like you had a _choice_ if there's software you want to use and it's only available as GPL. You'd have only chosen if there were 3-4 license options for the same software, and you went with GPL willingly.
- pdonis 11y ago> It's not like you had a _choice_ if there's software you want to use and it's only available as GPL. Sure you do; if you don't want to accept the GPL license terms, you can write your own software that fulfills whatever function you wanted the GPL code for.
- nsgi 11y agoYou also have the option to not use the software, if it's software you want, not need.
- st3v3r 11y ago"It's not like you had a _choice_ if there's software you want to use and it's only available as GPL." Sure you do. Write it yourself.
- coldtea 11y agoNot much of a choice, if one involves: 1) begrudgingly adopting a licence you don't like or want over: 2) re-creating man years (or decades) of effort to reproduce a certain project Especially if you lack the programming skills or money, it's not a choice at all -- you only have one option. So in those cases you "don't chose GPL" -- you chose the project you want to use, AND have to necessarily suffer GPL too because of that choice.
- cyphar 11y agoHave you considered why the original authors chose the GPL? It's so people who use their code will never take away the freedom of users of the code. If you're complaining about not being able to take their code and make it proprietary, you're missing the point that THAT'S WHY THEY CHOSE THE GPL.
- st3v3r 11y agoThat would only affect you if you were making your own JVM/.NET runtime.
- TelAviv 11y agoWhy don't you learn C# and then come back and see if you feel the same way. It's a MUCH better language and environment than Java.
- barrkel 11y agoI first started using C# professionally in 2003, after starting out with the betas. I helped implement some key .NET support for the Delphi compiler when I worked at Borland. I'm quite familiar with the evolution since then too. For example, back in 2006, I advocated implementing a CPS transformation to make better use of async code in .NET: http://blog.barrkel.com/2006/07/fun-with-asynchronous-methods-and.html http://blog.barrkel.com/2006/07/fun-with-asynchronous-method... It only took 7 years for async methods to come out, but they're there now; and I understand their utility in no small part because I was one of the people asking for them.
- yulaow 11y agoWhy? The license problem is only related to the oracle java implementation. The OpenJDK implementation has not any related problem, and, honestly, performs already far better than the oracle one (and I think it will improve even faster now that Google will use it for Android).
- coldtea 11y ago>The license problem is only related to the oracle java implementation. The OpenJDK implementation has not any related problem Including the APIs?
- teh64 11y agoOracleJDK is just OpenJDK plus a few propriety bits like Web Start and Web Plugins, (and I think Java Flight Recorder). OpenJDK is the reference implementation since Java 7. Source: http://openjdk.java.net/faq/ http://openjdk.java.net/faq/ >Is Oracle JDK based on OpenJDK? >Yes. Oracle JDK is based on the OpenJDK source code. In addition, it contains closed-source components. The final result is licensed under a Binary Code License.
- rdtsc 11y agoExcept the problems is many projects I ended up building would recommend and claim support only for Oracle downloaded JDK packages. Some explicitly claimed they do not supposed OpenJDK, claiming stuff would crash or be slow in that case.
- leonardinius 11y agoNot to sound arrogant. However I think Go (golang) is still in the hype wagon / cargo cult phase. It's popular as in the "popular latest javascript UI/UX" sense. Not to diminish Go _extraordinary_ achievements, however it's still to early to say. E.g. Ruby - used to be _mega_ popular, everything was Ruby at some point. Hype is over and it doesn't look too promising. Niche is taken and it stays there.
- duaneb 11y ago> Not to sound arrogant. However I think Go (golang) is still in the hype wagon / cargo cult phase. Well, you came off sounding kind of arrogant. I'm not sure what this has to do with the discussion. There are many valid uses of java that can be done in go, regardless of its popularity. There are many valid uses of java that can not be replicated in go, regardless of its popularity. You can swap out that criticism with pretty much any language built in or after the 90s and it's still just as valid. I mean, feel free to critique—it could very well be at its peak popularity and cannot take ANY MORE java marketshare—but this still requires argument.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cyphar 11y ago> Not to sound arrogant. However I think Go (golang) is still in the hype wagon / cargo cult phase. I'm not going to comment on the "hype" point, since your probably right. I just wanted to mention that I found out the other day that the Go garbage collector doesn't free memory. So your process will never shrink in memory usage (on Linux it uses MADV_DONTNEED and on BSD&Solaris it used MADV_FREE -- which means that essentially the page of memory becomes an overcommitted page that doesn't exist anymore). But that still won't stop your kernel from killing it. > It's popular as in the "popular latest javascript UI/UX" sense. Not to diminish Go _extraordinary_ achievements, however it's still to early to say. > E.g. Ruby - used to be _mega_ popular, everything was Ruby at some point. Hype is over and it doesn't look too promising. Niche is taken and it stays there.
- olavgg 11y agoJava is far far from the next COBOL. It is still my first choice when I want to choose a technology that will run for the next 20 years with minimal amount of code maintenance.
- kbenson 11y agoIs that a joke? I can easily imagine that having been said about COBOL at some point. It's an honest instance of Poe's law.
- e12e 11y agoActually, while unorthodox, I think one could read that sentence so that it refers to COBOL; as in "COBOL is still my first choice..." -- implying java will never be as good/stable... ;-) (No, I do not think that's what gp meant -- unless you're right and it's meant as irony).
- jakub_h 11y agoSeriously? That sounds like the perfect job for Common Lisp (which appears more or less set in stone in 2016, albeit without the usual concomitant stagnation, given its malleability). Plus, in fact, I get the distinct impression that your second sentence describes what COBOL actually did for companies decades ago, so the first one makes it sound like a contradiction.
- rdtsc 11y ago> It is still my first choice when I want to choose a technology that will run for the next 20 years with minimal amount of code maintenance. So it is basically the next COBOL ;-)
- shrugger 11y agoC# has a much better shot at defeating Java then Go does. Which is odd, because Go would be a nice replacement for Java, and would alleviate some of the more structural problems. But, C# isn't so shabby either nowadays, lots of new features, multiple implementations, FOSS-ness. Can't wait to find out!
- tomcam 11y agoHow is it the new COBOL?
- rdtsc 11y agoIt is the entrenched, default back-end business language. It will be running on servers for the next 30 years. 30 years from now, there will be job posts wanting "Java developers to maintain microservice/agile/tdd-based services" because all the Java devs will be retired and everything will be programming by thinking about algorithms and transmit it directly to the compiler via a brain implant.
- tomcam 11y agoAgreed. Somehow I thought you meant C# :0