14 ms·
Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy?
- f_allwein 11y agoPretty interesting, and pointed me to the "powers of 10" film visualizing changes in order of magnitude: http://youtu.be/0fKBhvDjuy0 http://youtu.be/0fKBhvDjuy0
- meric 11y agoCould an intelligent species embark on an effort to build a self-replicating machine as big as a galaxy?
- drieddust 11y agoThis idea is explored by Robert Charles Wilson in his Sci-Fi trilogy. He calls these being Hypotheticals and they operate over time frame and distances uncomprehensible to human mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin_(novel)
- vatotemking 11y agoIs it possible that galaxies are actually atoms of gigantic beings?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- noonespecial 11y agoOr atoms galaxies? It's turtles all the way down. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turtles_all_the_way_down https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turtles_all_the_way_down
- vatotemking 11y agoYeah. When you look at it everything is just a sphere rotating on something.
- zardo 11y agoIt is, in the same way its possible that a waterfall might produce intelligent thought.
- lazaroclapp 11y agoThe article makes the argument that intelligent life a couple orders of magnitude larger than human would think very slowly, since the time for a single message to cross a brain 10 times the size is 10 times longer. This necessitates that every thought traverses the entire brain. But, taking not too much poetic license, we can argue that human society at a whole is a 10^6m scale intelligence (well, more like 10^3 if we are only counting the pile of human brains, but the distances are still in the 10^6 scale). It furthermore has incredibly slow thought transmission outside of very small "fast" nodes. Yet it solves the problem by not requiring most signals to propagate very far. Only a few ideas need to be globally known by humankind, the intermediate filtering is still mostly local. So, a galaxy-sized "brain" can exist, it just needs to be very hierarchical, since any global consensus would take hundreds of thousands of years to formulate, even at the speed of light. In computing / distributed system terms: locality matters.
- millstone 11y agoYes, and also, who cares how long it takes to think? The article points out: > If our brains grew enormously to say, the size of our solar system, and featured speed-of-light signaling, the same number of message crossings would require more than the entire current age of the universe, leaving no time for evolution to work its course. but this argues that stellar-scale life doesn't exist yet, not that it can't exist. The universe is extremely young, ~10^10 years. Stars will continue to form for 10^14 years - ten thousand times longer than the universe has existed so far. And the universe will continue to evolve for many many orders of magnitude after that. There is plenty of time.
- vidarh 11y agoThat argument also assumes that such an intelligence must evolve. If you were to build it out of individual cells, that seems reasonable. But such an intelligence could also be an emergent property of civilizations of intelligent beings, for example. We know too little of what sentience involves to be able to rule out such hive minds.
- 11y ago
- millstone 11y ago> Progress in the theory of computation suggests that sentience and intelligence likely require quadrillions of primitive “circuit” elements. Can anyone elaborate? What is the evidence that sentience and intelligence requires this?
- oafitupa 11y agoIntelligence maybe, but sentience? We haven't made any progress in that. We don't even know if science will ever be able to figure that out. See: the hard problem of consciousness.
- staticelf 11y agoIs there any reason to think that there exist a limit on how large or small things can be?
- tom-lord 11y agoNo one really knows for sure, but.... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_length https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_length
- oafitupa 11y agoThe Universe is expanding, and some parts will never interact with other parts, because not even light could make the trip. One could say they are now in separate universes. So that's one limit I can think of.
- staticelf 11y agoYeah but that doesn't mean they don't exist? Our universe could be a drop in an ocean of a real multiverse.
- miloszf 11y agoIf you find this topic interesting to think about I strongly recommend the book Star Maker by Olaf Stapledon. It was written in 1930's, but in some ways it's still incredibly refreshing and thought provoking.
- ilamparithi 11y agoI read somewhere that there is a universe in each scale. For example, there is a whole world in the atomic scale. Similarly there are billions of bacteria in our mouth alone. They couldn't make sense of their host. Sometimes I think it is possible that the entire universe is some body part of a giant organism which we couldn't comprehend.
- justsaysmthng 11y agoGiven the fractal nature of the Universe (almost everything in nature is a fractal at some scale), then it's quite possible. Every particle contains the whole Universe and the Universe contains all particles. But there's an interesting property of fractals (please correct me if I'm wrong) - at every level, a fractal is self-similar but not an exact copy of itself. If we connect the two ideas, then every particle contains a similar but not identical Universe - a "parallel Universe".. So then every particle is a gateway towards a parallel Universe in which there might be parallel versions of us, but slightly different. And every Universe contains every other parallel Universe inside itself. Mind bending indeed.
- mbil 11y agoWhenever I hear something similar I think of this Simpson's opening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9OiRk56pNEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9OiRk56pNEk
- carlob 11y agoThis reminds me of Look to Windward, a Culture novel which features behemotaurs, creatures much larger than whales which are near immortal and have a very very slow metabolism.
- ajuc 11y agoAlso Algebraist by the same author Ian Banks - there is a species living so slowly, that star travel is practical for them, so they are ubiquitus in the whole known universe.
- tfgg 11y agoAlso one of the intelligences encountered in Diaspora by Greg Egan. Actually, they just meet a localised handling agent that explains that they work for a star-spanning sentience - which is something the characters had been considering as a way of making themselves robust against civilisation-destroying gamma ray bursts, but dismissed on the grounds that it made everything so slow - though that links into the other theme in that book of simulated beings existing on very different timescales.
- KineticLensman 11y agoIt depends on how you define life, which the article doesn't cover. If by life you mean 'demonstrates complex emergent behaviours', the answer might be 'perhaps, although it would take a very long time for anything to happen'. However, if 'living' means 'self organised, maintains its integrity and can reproduce', then the answer is more likely to be 'probably not'
- nxzero 11y agoAgree, looked into is before, reproduction is often the most common conflict in attempting to find "life" in the wild.
- alanwatts 11y ago>'living' means 'self organised, maintains its integrity and can reproduce' I like the definition of life being something that can reproduce. But self organized, I'm not sure. All life depends on non-biological environmental factors for its organization and reproduction.
- amelius 11y ago> Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? If you consider your brain as the brain of the galaxy, and the rest of the galaxy as its limbs, then certainly :) The fact that the brain has only little control over its limbs (through very weak forces of gravity and electromagnetics) doesn't really matter.
- saalweachter 11y agoLack of interstellar travel / stellar engineering == locked in syndrome?
- JohnDoe365 11y agoA galaxy is a living creature. See it that way?
- travelbyphone 11y agoAbsolutely. Even more if you think that life isn't but a slow transfer of the Suns energy between organisms. Even our thoughts are just energy.
- titzer 11y agoA lot of research suggests that the human brain has about an 80ms time window within which events are roughly considered "simultaneous". Interestingly, that's about the same amount of time for nerve signals to travel from your furthest extremities to your brain. If we were to scale up our brains and bodies with upgraded speed-of-light transmitters, then 80 light-milliseconds is about 24,000 kilometers, or almost exactly twice the diameter of Earth. Thus a similarly time-scaled fully integrated conscious experience is probably limited to that volume. Obviously, brains have lots of localized computation and subsystems that are smaller and have lower cycle times. Planetary brains could have very fast local regions but the integration time across subsystems is probably what contributes to the perception of time in consciousness.
- agumonkey 11y agoIn a book by Bertalanffy (50s System Theory) they also measure frequency limits (my blub) in animals. Anything faster than that wasn't registered by said animal. Like waving a a stick 20 times per second would be invisible to him. While at 15 "fps" it would runaway.
- gonvaled 11y agoWhen discussing these issues I have always the impression that we have a too strong anthropomorphic view. For example, we assume that life needs a liquid for support, but maybe it can work with other substance (gas, plasma, ...). We think that watter has magic properties, but maybe another material works better - we simply do not known about it. Why? Because Earth does not contain enough material to produce and study the compound, or because Earth simply does not have the conditions which make the substance perform at its optimum level (maybe millions of degrees, or extremely high pressures). I think we barely know anything about chemistry: the universe offers so many options, that restricting outserlves to life as we know it is bound to make us miss most of the real alternatives.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoI agree that we have too strong an anthropomorphic view, but disagree that water and carbon are bad assumptions. There are only a finite number of elements, and these elements are prouduced in similar ways due to radioactive decay and stellar processes. Of these, a simple study shows that carbon is best. Also, life requires some kind of chemistry to reproduce - this is easiest in a liquid, and water is the best, most abundant liquid for the process. Perhaps a complex molecule is superior to carbon in some way. Or perhaps something could exist and reproduce as a plasma. These materials and conditions may exist somewhere in the universe, but are not nearly as likely as carbon and water.
- gonvaled 11y ago> There are only a finite number of elements, and these elements are prouduced in similar ways due to radioactive decay and stellar processes. Of these, a simple study shows that carbon is best. Maybe another element (or compound) performs better in certain conditions or in the presence of certain catalizators than carbon. We have not detected this because we do not have the conditions to perform the experiments, or maybe we haven't found the right proportions of catalizator to compound, or maybe we have not even tried that specific combination. There are maybe other stables elements that we have not yet discovered, with >1000 protons in the nucleus: another isle of stability which we do not know about because the stars do not easily reach it when going supernova. Maybe there are other organization structures (not atoms) for matter that do not occur in this part of the universe. "Chemistry" would be very different then. There are too many variables: humankind is very young, science is in its infancy, we have a very limited spectrum of the possible conditions / materials at our disposal, and anyway the possibilities that the universe offers are way too big for us to make any final statement. The universe has been running for a long time, in a massive parallelized manner: it sure has found possibilities that we do not even dare of dreaming about. > These materials and conditions may exist somewhere in the universe, but are not nearly as likely as carbon and water. You can be right there, but what is more likely: carbon and water or "the rest of possible alternatives"? It could be that carbon+water is the most common option, but still most life in the universe is based in lots of different alternatives.
- abledon 11y agoReminds me of Peter F Hamilton's Void series
- paulpauper 11y agoIssac Asmimov's the Final Question ends with a sentience that spans the universe
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fit2rule 11y agoAt some scale, Earth itself could be considered a single life-form.
- FooNull 11y agoAnd the sun, and the solar system
- Qwertious 11y ago>It’s likely that the first true artificial intelligences will occupy volumes that are not so different from the size of our own bodies, despite being based on fundamentally different materials and architectures, again suggesting that there is something special about the meter scale. That's circular, it's begging the question. Assuming that there's something special about the meter scale, then using that to reinforce the notion that there is something special about the meter scale.
- awinter-py 11y agoif materialism is true, the united states is probably conscious http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/USAconscious-140130a.htm http://www.faculty.ucr.edu/~eschwitz/SchwitzPapers/USAconsci...
- gonvaled 11y agoSure. Another level of conscience. Materialism accepts that things are neither white nor black, but gray; the world is more complex than what we want it to be; simplifications take you only so far. Rabits are more conscious that amoebas, and less than men. The consciousness of the US is probably not comparable to the consciousness of men - they are basically different things, with some common properties. So yes, the US is conscious, for some definition of consciousness.
- awinter-py 11y agoI think the author of that paper is leaning more on the 'phenomenological consciousness isn't true' case than the 'united states is conscious' case. I land in the max tegmark 'information probably is the same as consciousness' camp. It makes sense that a guy who studies simultaneity would ascribe magical properties to information that is partitioned like spacetime. But I can't argue with the critics -- we don't yet have a measurable physical quantity for consciousness, much less a definition. Dave Chalmers says the 'hard problem' is why we have qualia. I think the hard problem is even more fundamental -- it's really hard to formulate questions about consciousness in a way that communciates the problem to someone who hasn't already thought of it. You can say the behavioral evidence (i.e. measurable quantity) for consciousness is that we're having a conversation about it, but that feels like a copout.
- ThomPete 11y agoSpeed isn't a problem if everyone else at your scale are equally slow. If you are at the size of a galaxy you aren't being affected by humans ability to be faster just as little as individual cells mostly aren't affecting humans even though their ability to deal quickly with things at the cellular level react way faster than your entire body do. In fact most studies about the human mind seems to suggest that we are actually more like tourists than captains on our own ship. So the update frequency of the whole system can vary. The most important part is that it's a pattern-recognizing feedback loop which can store past cycles.
- mcguire 11y agoUntil those pesky infestations start building Dyson spheres around your ganglia.
- craftandhustle 11y agoAfter recently finishing The Three-Body Problem by Liu Cixin, the sci-fi trope of life at different magnitudes is fascinating to think about. Without spoiling too much, there's a chapter where an entire universe rich with intelligent life is discovered as scientists "unfold" a single proton.
- Confusion 11y agoI liked the book very much, until those kinds of things started happening. The last third of the book ruined it for me
- hyperliner 11y agoWho cares about how long it takes for the thing to think? It seems such large thing would have no predators, therefore it is not in a hurry to decide whether to fight or fly.
- runn1ng 11y agoGalactus must feed.
- justsaysmthng 11y ago> Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? This can be followed up by an even "crazier" question: If so, is our Galaxy a living creature ? Going in the other direction, are cells in our bodies "living creatures" ? They sure do exhibit all the qualities of the larger organisms. If that's true, then our body is a conglomerate of 100 trillion living beings locked together in a biological ecosystem, each individual cell or collection of cells having probably no concept of the larger system they are part of. So then we (our bodies and other animals) could also be locked together in a biological ecosystem (The Earth) and we would be oblivious of the fact by default. Is Earth a "living creature" ? The "overview effect" that astronauts report upon seeing the Earth from orbit seems to be related to exactly this realization - that the planet is one big living organism. There's a fantastic short documentary about this - https://vimeo.com/55073825 https://vimeo.com/55073825 We are just beginning to see the complex interconnection of things and beings in the biosphere so there's a lot of circumstantial evidence that the planet might be a huge living organism - not quite fits in our definition of "organism", but then it might mean that our definition is a bit too narrow. Ancient shamans and the modern day "psychonauts" repot the same "overview effect" after tripping on various psychedelic plants and fungi - that everything is alive, including the planet, the stars and so on. The idea of a "soul" - as the differentiating property of living things - has been around since .. forever. And if we touch the idea of soul, then we're entering the realm of the Holy and the idea of God. If all living beings have "souls" and if the Galaxy is a living being that it results that it too has soul. Interestingly that it's the "soul" that allows us to "grasp" the "being part of" thing.. So if cells have souls, they feel Us with it, if the Planet has soul, we feel it with our souls and so on... Oh well, this is a infinitely long discussion, so I'll just pause here and contemplate on some C++ code :)
- LordKano 11y agoThis can be followed up by an even "crazier" question: If so, is our Galaxy a living creature ? I like this, a galaxy-scale Gaia Hypothesis. Why not? Our perspective is so small and our life span is so limited, would we be able to recognize or even comprehend the thought processes of a galaxy sized organism?
- 11y ago
- Sommer 11y agoMaybe it's worth thinking about it the other way around: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7ojSW5pODk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7ojSW5pODk
- gumby 11y agoThe article is compelling that you can't have an organism like a human but why should it look that way? A loosely coupled system with lots of local computation could just as well "think", just not like us. Ants and termites are extreme examples of this though we don't typically think of them as a single organism (except in The Sword in the Stone) but they have collective behavior. Bacterial biofilms too. And in fact all parts of our brain do not communicate with all others; there are specialized subprocessing in the early visual system (cf Letvin) much less the various specialized cortices. So one could construct a computational agent on the scale of a galaxy -- this ignores the question of evolution. I've long presumed that we're unlikely to even recognize an intelligent alien (and that an alien encountering human interstellar travelers might not recognize the humans as intelligent). It's a fundamental hermeneutic question.
- zodPod 11y agoI've always had thoughts about this too. I understand that our definition of "living" might be that it requires water and air or something like that but honestly I think that's a little short-sighted.
- numbsafari 11y agoYes, I have met your mother.
- netcan 11y agoJust the title has two big semantic questions: (1) what counts as life and (2) what counts as intelligence. Like lazaroclapp commented, it's not that big a stretch to think of humanity (as a whole) as meeting the definitions of both. Also (or alternatively), the earth. Interesting questions.
- known 11y agoInteresting concept.
- habosa 11y agoThis reminds me of the book "Spin" by Robert Charles Wilson (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0016IXMWI/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?ie=UTF8&btkr=1 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0016IXMWI/ref=dp-kindle-re...). While I don't want to spoil too much for the HN crowd (more than I have already by posting it under this link) it's a great SciFi book that hints at some really cool theoretical questions about life, space travel, and inter-species communication.
- wavesum 11y agoThis makes sense if you make the assumption that Big Bang theory is correct. In my opinion the theory has quite a few leaps of faith. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-scientific-criticism-of-the-Big-Bang-theory https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-scientific-criticism-of-th... If we consider the possibility of infinitely old universe with no beginning or end, the answer is yes, most likely, but it's unlikely we ever know. Those strange blobs of light could very well be living, thinking things or parts of them, but everything that happens on their physical scale is so slow that we can only observe a mere snapshot of their state.
- ZeroFries 11y agoDepends on how you define "organism", I think. If you mean an entity possessing some sort of unitary consciousness, then yes, thoughts would become slower the larger you scale the brain. If you mean distributed information processing system, I think you can classify the entire universe as one, and there's no such thing as a "thought".
- joshdick 11y agoThe classic essay on this topic is "On Being the Right Size" by biologist J.B.S. Haldane in 1926. It's really worth a read: http://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html http://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html I'll never forget: "You can drop a mouse down a thousand-yard mine shaft; and, on arriving at the bottom, it gets a slight shock and walks away, provided that the ground is fairly soft. A rat is killed, a man is broken, a horse splashes."
- outworlder 11y agoI came here expecting to find a discussion of the Foundation series...
- mchahn 11y ago> The height of the tallest redwoods is limited by their inability to pump water more than 100 meters into the sky, Actually they grow higher than that limit. They absorb dew in their leaves so they can grow taller. There is a reason there are redwoods only in a certain climate.
- vorg 11y agoSo, to an accuracy of a factor of 10: smallest theoretical scale is 10^-35 m, i.e. Planck length smallest observed scale is 10^-19 m, i.e. quark interactions smallest life scale is 10^-6 m, i.e. bacteria and viruses size of vessel of consciousness is 10^-1 m, i.e. human brain largest life scale is 10^3 m, i.e. Blue Mountain honey fungus largest observed scale 10^26 m, i.e. the cosmic horizon largest theoretical scale is unknown Looking at this sequence of orders of magnitude, i.e. (-35, -19, -6, -1, 3, 26, ???) makes me wonder: * is there a theory that encompasses General Relativity and defines a theoretical largest possible distance/time? * perhaps consciousness, being in the middle, will never, via mathematics, unite such a theory with Quantum Mechanics
- contravariant 11y ago>is there a theory that encompasses General Relativity and defines a theoretical largest possible distance/time? It's possible to define a universe of nearly any possible shape, but most aren't really compatible with our observations. One that fits reasonably well would be the de Sitter space, which fits most important criteria, and has a finite size at each moment in time.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoFor those that wanted a visualization 10^-35 - Planck length 10^-34 10^-33 10^-32 10^-31 10^-30 10^-29 10^-28 10^-27 10^-26 10^-25 10^-24 10^-23 10^-22 10^-21 10^-20 10^-19 - quark interactions 10^-18 10^-17 10^-16 10^-15 10^-14 10^-13 10^-12 10^-11 - hydrogen atom 10^-10 10^-9 10^-8 10^-7 10^-6 - bacteria and viruses 10^-5 10^-4 10^-3 10^-2 10^-1 - human brain 10^0 10^1 10^2 10^3 - Blue Mountain honey fungus 10^4 10^5 10^6 10^7 10^8 - Diameter of our sun 10^9 10^10 10^11 10^12 10^13 10^14 10^15 10^16 - Oort cloud 10^17 10^18 10^19 10^20 - Our Galaxy 10^21 10^22 10^23 10^24 10^25 10^26 - the cosmic horizon
- am185 11y agoapril fools?