9 ms·
> As to why the desktop is such a hard nut to crack—there are multiple reasons, but one of the big ones is simply user inertia. Being a Windows user having tri
by cm2187 11y ago
> As to why the desktop is such a hard nut to crack—there are multiple reasons, but one of the big ones is simply user inertia.
Being a Windows user having tried to get into linux, there is a lot more than user inertia. A few reasons:
The desktop is almost dead, what we call desktop today is really laptops, with custom hardware for which the drivers are rarely all available for linux. Try telling my mum: "you need to compile your own drivers".
The UI is extremely limited and you end up having to type command lines almost immediatly, to install a software or change a configuration. First if command lines had even a remote chance to go mainstream, DOS would still be around and Apple would have gone bust. Then, there are many distributions of linux that take a different syntax so it's not even trivial to find help on the web. And again, try shouting "RTFM!" to my mum.
Linux developers seem to be in love with cryptic acronyms which means nothing is intuitive or simple.
For Linux to take over it needs not only to match but to surpass its competition (MacOS, Windows) in term of simplicity and ease of use. And right now it is far far far behind.
I am sure we can make the list longer. But blaming user inertia for linux not going mainstream is exactly what Microsoft was objecting when they were told that the new Windows 8 UI was a piece of shit.
- embik 11y ago> Linux developers seem to be in love with cryptic acronyms which means nothing is intuitive or simple. To add to that point: Linux exposes a lot of information in general. That's great for me as an experienced user, but is certainly overwhelming for the "normal" computer user. GNOME is trying to de-mystify the Linux desktop and I think they're on the right track, but they don't have widespread support among the Linux community. A lot of people use and/or like it, but a very vocal group (is it a minority? I don't know) is opposing their approach. They (this certain group that's well represented on e.g. /r/linux) sometimes seem to dismiss any work on UI or UX as not relevant or limiting their freedom.
- cm2187 11y agoI am not an advanced enough linux user to compile a long list, but a couple of examples from the top of my head: Windows:"Scheduled tasks" Linux: "CRON" Windows: "windows Firewall" Linux:"iptable" or "UFW" Windows: "Windows Update" Linux: "apt-get update" These are not really the internal guts of linux, but rather relatively basic features. Using plain words is the first step of making things intuitive.
- Svip 11y agoActually, `apt update` has a GUI application called 'software updater' and `apt` has a 'software centre' on Ubuntu these days. I'll grant you the other two.
- onli 11y ago> I'll grant you the other two. I don't. Ubuntu does not come with a firewall, but if you want one you search in the software center for firewall, not for an acronym. Scheduled tasks finds a gnome app for managing automatic jobs (which are cron jobs). cm2187 is either a troll or completely clueless of what a current linux desktop actually is. Worrying about things like automated tasks and being put off by the differences between Windows and Linux in specialised areas like this no normal user would ever touch is rather common for Windows power users though. For them, any change means losing a big part of their abilities, and that hurts. It's exactly what Linus mentions: Many people don't like change for their desktop environment (in the broad sense, not only KDE/Gnome). This is a perfect example of user inertia.
- Svip 11y agoYou are right; I should have rephrased that sentence. I merely meant that I have never looked into those. And when I use scheduled tasks I refer to them as `cron`. Even on Windows.
- cyphar 11y agoOpenSUSE does come with a firewall which has a graphical manager. So there's that. Ubuntu isn't the only Linux distribution.
- majewsky 11y ago> with custom hardware for which the drivers are rarely all available for linux Over the last 10 years, I have never encountered a notebook that didn't work at all in Linux. Sure, you'd have the occasional brightness switch or WiFi toggle not working perfectly, but it would always be usable. And that experience includes an Asus Zenbook which, at the time of installation, had been released only three days ago, so it was definitely not all old hardware. Might have been my luck, though. > you end up having to type command lines almost immediatly, to install a software or change a configuration The world is not just Gentoo. Have you actually used a mainstream distribution in the last few years?
- cm2187 11y ago> The world is not just Gentoo. Have you actually used a mainstream distribution in the last few years? If you call ubuntu mainstream. I ended up buying a laptop with linux pre-installed but before that I was considering switching a Dell and Sony laptop and was a bit put off by comments of people doing it before me on forums listing the features that would work and that would not work.
- mr_sturd 11y ago> Try telling my mum: "you need to compile your own drivers". > was a bit put off by comments of people doing it before me on forums listing the features that would work and that would not work. I have known wifi to be a problem, upon install. But that's more down to a licensing issue, rather than the inability of the OS to cope. Plugging in an ethernet cable and installing any non-free drivers -- via a friendly GUI -- have always fixed any such problem for me.
- zdkl 11y agoWell yes Ubuntu is very much mainstream. I experience the whole problem more as a consequence of the documentation fragmentation. It seems it's expected of the user to be willing to RTFM to various degrees depending on distro. That seems to be most practical way to ensure the continued confifurability of each component, so I guess the question comes down to How much modularity do you really want to be maintaining? What worked for me is to pick a set of tools after trying different combinations and learn those well. Really happy with arch+xfce as clean and fast Dev machine. Now if only X would behave...
- varjag 11y agoSounds like it's written in 2001. There's been a lot of progress. Pretty sure I didn't have to compile a Linux desktop driver in last 10 years, and there are "app stores" with major consumer oriented distributions. OEM/component driver situation became a lot better ever since Linux kernel started running on majority of world's telephones and tablets. The usability of modern Linux distributions is as good or better than Windows desktops. It's really the time to put the "linux not ready for desktop" line aside, somewhere along with VAX jokes.
- Pxtl 11y agoMy Ubuntu box was the recommended drive layout at the time. About once a year /boot fills up and I have to execute cryptic commands to purge old kernels. I also had to execute cryptic commands to get wifi to work. That is not good, particularly since both of those processes looked automateable. That is not grandma friendly.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoWindows forgetting it has wifi or bluetooth isn't very grandma friendly either. She call me and asks why she can't check her email. Very frustrating. Yes, there are "solutions" but they all have not stuck. Windows just forgets stuff.
- Pxtl 11y agoYeah, but 90% of the time that can be fixed by just having grandma reset her machine. It's stupid, but it generally works.
- nisa 11y agoIt's still buggy as hell. Ubuntu 15.10 or 14.04 has a lot more annoying quirks than Windows. Lot's of desktop tools are full of memory leaks and crash-prone. KDE is somewhat more stable but needs a usability overhaul. Let's be at least honest. It's mostly usable but a far cry from "better than Windows" Someone more patient than me made a sourced list: http://itvision.altervista.org/why.linux.is.not.ready.for.the.desktop.current.html http://itvision.altervista.org/why.linux.is.not.ready.for.th... - I tend to wholly agree. There is something seriously wrong when I remember the KDE 3.x days as the better desktop.
- danmaz74 11y ago> you end up having to type command lines almost immediatly, to install a software or change a configuration That's only true if you have unsupported hardware. Otherwise, for example on Ubuntu, you can use tons of software without having to touch the command line.
- stinos 11y agoYou make some valid points (sometimes compile drivers, sometimes cryptic, seems unavoidable to not once end up on the commandline anyway or having to revert to configuration files - my last anecdote: create bootable USB with latest Linux Mint Live and there's no network. Serisously, wtf, why did eth0 not make it into /etc/network/interfaces on a live cd nota bene) but are also exaggerating, or lacking experience with the many many distributions out there, like when it comes to the UI being limited: seems like all big players got it covered pretty well, at least I always try a variety of them and the last years I wouldn't call them extremely limited, no way.
- soundwave106 11y agoOne of your statements is what I feel is more of an obstacle to mainstream Linux adoption than anything technical. There's a lot of distros out there with a lot of churn. Not a bad thing if you are a geek and have the time to try out a variety of distros, but Grandma is just going to want something that Works. Similarly (possibly because of this churn?), I feel Macintosh and Windows are ahead of the game compared to Linux for providing more usable documentation. Linux forums likewise tend to be very techie oriented; the general consensus I get outside of the computer world is that this heavy technical nature is very off-putting ("arrogance" and "snobbery" are a common complaint). Linux still has some problems technically (has audio gotten any better, for instance? ALSA / Pulseaudio was messy compared to Windows / Mac last I looked) but I think a lot of the obstacles to adoption are more non-technical at this stage. Google after all made a Linux kernel OS mainstream.
- stinos 11y agoGood points. Although I do have the impression that, because of the rise of less tech-savy people using Linux, there also is a rise in forums/documentation which is more aimed towards those users and hence easier to digest in most cases. I mean, basically I am one of those users since I don't use linux daily and apparently not enough to get solutions to common problems wrong stuck in my head, and I do have the impression that if I have problems these days the answer is in one of the first search results encountered. (alternative explanation is that search just got way better :) Unfortunately that also means sooner or later we might find ourselves in the too-many-unrelated-crap-answers situation which exist now already for a myriad of Windows/Mac problems. Distilling the correct answer for your specific problem where the OS tells you 'error C0000005' or so seems to get harder every year. Add 100 different distros to that and it won't get any better. Though sites like stackexchange seem to do a pretty good job of keeping it to the point. re: Audio: I actually asked the same question here last year or so and IIRC the answer was 'still the same mess'
- diskcat 11y ago>The desktop is almost dead I disagree. -sent from my desktop ps. try running 4K VR on your tablet
- distrill 11y ago>For Linux to take over it needs not only to match but to surpass its competition (MacOS, Windows) in term of simplicity and ease of use. And right now it is far far far behind. This should be your entire point. While I am far from a linux expert, I have been using linux as my daily driver for a few years now. I have never even had to think about even potentially 'compiling my own drivers'. The UI is only as limited as the UI you happen to have chosen. And there are very few differences in syntax you'll find between the different distributions, mainly surrounding package management and (with decreasing frequency) init options (which a beginner won't be touching anyway). To be sure, there are many things getting in the way of linux becoming a friendly desktop option for the family. But good lord you picked the few things that AREN'T wrong with it to complain about.
- 0xcde4c3db 11y ago> I have never even had to think about even potentially 'compiling my own drivers'. You got lucky. In the past several years I've had to do this for two laptops that I've owned: one for the Wi-Fi (RTL8723AU in a Lenovo Yoga 11s; this eventually made it into staging, but it's in staging for a reason: the code sucks), one for the touchpad (in an Acer C720).
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoThe C720 is a Chromebook. Hardly a fair argument, yes?
- pavanky 11y agoOr use Archlinux and let AUR take care of it (it is still compiling them under the hood, but it is automated).
- phkahler 11y agoYou really should verify that your chosen Linux distribution fully supports the hardware you want to buy. Seriously. You're putting two things together without checking compatibility. This step is done for you when Windows or OSX is preloaded on a machine. Do more research and less compiling drivers ;-)
- vacri 11y ago> Try telling my mum: "you need to compile your own drivers". What decade are you in? I haven't compiled a wifi driver for linux this decade. One of the problems desktop linux faces is outdated FUD like this. Is it perfect? Of course not. But it's not the phone-home privacy invader that is modern Windows (which also has it's own usability issues) or the elitist the-poor-can-go-get-stuffed OSX (where you have to buy a pricey computer in order to use it).
- m_sahaf 11y agoTo add to you, I present my mere anecdote: I have an uncle who, somehow, manages to get all kinds of adware and whatnot on his computer no matter what antivirus/internet security/voltron PC protection suit. Then comes me periodically cleaning up all that, often backup his stuff and refresh the installation. Eventually I convinced him to let me install Ubuntu, since he needs a browser and whatever PDF reader. Yes, now he doesn't have those malwares anymore, but my recurrent task has become running "apt-get autoremove; apt-get autoclean". If Linux wants to target "desktop", then those trouble should be transparent to the users.
- joosters 11y agoAs a long-time Linux user, I can appreciate that anecdote. I've a few home servers that are pretty stock Ubuntu with most of the default partitioning / settings, because nowadays I 'just want stuff to work' rather than spend hours tweaking & optimising. After a few rounds of apt-get update & apt-get upgrade, the update process broke (with pages & pages of error messages), because /boot got full of all the myriad kernel point releases that had collected there and Ubuntu just left them hanging around. apt-get autoremove clears away all this old gunk and will let the update process work again. But a 'simple' (I don't mean that in a bad way) desktop user will not know what the problem is and will not be able to make sense of any of the errors. Even if they spot a 'disk full' somewhere in the output (do they even see the output with a GUI-based update?), it won't help. "Disk full? But it shows I've got gigabytes of space here in my documents folder?" It's these and all the other 'thousand paper cuts' that are still blocking every day desktop Linux use.
- distances 11y agoI encounter this same thing periodically myself. I found out how to fix this, but a "normal" user will never, ever manage to get around this issue by themselves. Most of the time it seems that desktop Linux would be completely ready for mainstream, but then you encounter something like this and remember why you don't recommend Linux for your non-technical friends and relatives.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago
- clw8 11y agoI actually had a great experience setting my mom up with Linux (past tense because I bought her a Chromebit when the hardware died). The pain point comes with users who have enough computer literacy to want to install things. My mom is happy as long as she can click to open Chrome, and I'm happy because I don't have to clean up .exe malware hell.
- perakojotgenije 11y agoWhen was the last time you've tried Linux? Linux Mint is my main OS and in the last 6 years I've changed 3 laptops and two desktops and everything worked out of the box. The only thing I needed to install were proprietary display drivers and even for that there is an app called 'Drivers'.
- conceit 11y ago> Being a Windows user having tried to get into linux, there is a lot more than user inertia There's a specific friction coefficient?
- kbart 11y agoI find many people switching to simple distributions (Mint, Ubuntu) easier than to Windows 8/10 from earlier versions. So no, I still blame user inertia and OEM push of Windows.
- ekianjo 11y agoObviously written by someone who has never used Linux. Classic.
- sliekasbekelniu 11y agoMy grandfather (85 Years Old) is using linux for 5 years now. Never got a call to fix or do something.. (Installed KDE based distro) My Parents (55) share a laptop at home (about 1 year now), installed Fedora (default GNOME) - never got a call. My Youger Brother (18, finishing High-School this year) uses Ubuntu, for 4 years I think, I've convinced him that he could still play games there if wanted.. I get calls from him only when he wants to run some game that needs some advanced Wine tweaking and it involves command like (otherwise he is just using Play On Linux I think or whatever - I just don't game). None of them is computer savvy or computer literate... They all use different major Linux DE.. And they all seem to just be fine! My Wife (27) currently uses Elementary OS (With Pantheon DE, which is not a major DE as we call them) - she's also nor computer literate nor savvy, and also using the Linux just fine! The only problem I see, which rises from my wifes experience, there is no simple Paint alternative, were you'd have very basic options (cropping, rotating and maybe some brush/text) with a decent UI to make changes to a photo/image.. Same goes for easy PDF editing, but I already made her master Inkscape, but still - something easier and more straightforward would be awesome. So the lack of software is still true for linux in 2016 in certain areas. I could convert a lot of audio/video editing people to linux, but there is just not enough professional grade software for them on linux.. In the end - apparently average Joe can use Linux today for browsing internet, viewing pdfs and doing Libre Office stuff just as well as on any other operating system (Windows, OS X)..
- pbhjpbhj 11y agohttp://alternativeto.net/software/microsoft-paint/?platform=linux http://alternativeto.net/software/microsoft-paint/?platform=... might help? If you're happy to use KDE projects then ShowFoto (the editor of Digikam) or Krita might work for your image editing needs. Or maybe one of the online tools like Pixlr? For PDF editing I open docs in LibreOffice or Inkscape depending on my needs (both cross-platform).
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "The only problem I see, which rises from my wifes experience, there is no simple Paint alternative, were you'd have very basic options (cropping, rotating and maybe some brush/text) with a decent UI to make changes to a photo/image" How about Krita? It's more powerful than a basic Paint app but the UI looks just as intuitive. https://krita.org/features/highlights/ https://krita.org/features/highlights/
- threatofrain 11y ago* I don't think the desktop is almost dead, and I don't think the conclusion of a trend of growing laptop popularity is that the desktop will wither to death anytime soon. The laptop is a great form factor, and I think that it's simply getting the share of the pie that it's always deserved, but I don't think it deserves the lion's share of the pie. * One reason I think so is that I believe that desktops will have, for the foreseeable future, a better profile of costs over time (serviceability / upgradeability) than laptops, because laptops are basically desktops with a severe constraint for portability. I also liberally speculate that the future maximum potential wealth per individual should decline due to increasing population and a finiteness of materials mined from the earth. * I think the desktop driver situation is fine, but I acknowledge that laptop drivers are a severe issue that isn't easily resolved. Possible solutions would be, instead of installing a Linux distro on a laptop being an avenue to Linux, people may instead buy devices with Linux already installed on it. Even if the driver solution were magically solved, most people don't install a new OS (however easy that might be) as an avenue to a new OS. Another possibility involves more liberal speculation of industry, with a declining diversity of hardware choices by vendors, or an industry protocol. * I think the GUI situation on Linux can be improved, but I also think that distros like Ubuntu already offer a great experience with no command line needed.
- XorNot 11y agoThe laptop driver issue would be solved by general improvements which would benefit all hardware drivers: less special snowflake interfaces. We didn't "solve" USB mass storage - it was just so useful that people went to pains to conform to whatever was built into Windows, which in turn benefited everyone. It would be wonderful if we could get the same for power management hardware.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoIt comes down to research. Presumably, one researches what laptop to purchase. It's only a matter of a little more time to research if Linux has been installed successfully on the laptop. I don't have one piece of Linux incompatible hardware because I research first. It's really that simple.
- cm3 11y agoThe Linux desktop is way past Windows and OS X these days in user friendliness focus. GNOME and KDE are so user friendly that they don't work for me as a development environment. I run either FVWM or XMonad depdending on the machine at hand. Also, have you ever compared application management on OSX and Windows to Linux? Linux packages just work, are very very fast to install/update/remove compared to Windows installers and updating a linux distro is very quick in comparison. Some Linux distro installers even upgrade the distro during install, so you get an up-to-date install on first boot. Try achieving that with OS X or Windows. More, Debians, Fedora's and OpenSuSE's installers are super powerful while having a quick next-next-next mode. It's true that some users are better served with a tablet these days, but those who actually use PCs for productivity feel at home on Linux. Hey, printers just work without trying to find a driver download online that has no virus and afterwards runs a couple Windows services just so ink levels can be reported and HP can show you ads about new products. Plus, Linux doesn't spend insane amounts of time in some hardware registry every time you plug a USB device in another port of the computer. But, the Windows kernel is generally great, just not all the stuff on top. Same can be said for Linux, but at least there you can choose your userspace more freely. Please, just go to Windows appwiz.cpl and try removing an application that uses Windows Installer. It'll take ages before actually deleting files and some afterwards. Same during install. There are just a few Windows setup engines like NSIS that avoid this. And, why does Microsoft think it's a good idea to bulk build .Net Frameworks on each and every security update on each and every machine, regardless of performance? Surely, Microsoft's compiler does not have more than 10 or 20 variations of compiler backend switches, meaning they could provide .Net assemblies that have been compiled in Redmond already. To end this, I cannot believe anyone would believe the desktop has no place anymore. Where do would work get done? Software development, media production, gaming, engineering, to name just a few cases. It's both consumer and prosumer, but yes, average Joe can do 99% of tasks with a tablet.
- cm3 11y agoAnd some Windows drivers for HP deskjet are written in a way that makes the scanner/printer work only with a single USB port (first one it was ever used with?), whereas the same device on the same computer works with any USB port. This is in addition to the wait anytime you plug in a random USB device and Windows decides it has to do "enrollment". It's not what I'd call user friendly. This may all be a little rant, but on top of everything, Windows usually does much more I/O for the same action vs Linux. With or without antivirus overhead.
- thiht 11y agoI thought exactly the same thing until a few weeks ago. Recently I tried a lot of DMs: the cool kids Pantheon, Elementary and Mint, the classics Gnome, Mate, KDE, XFCE and none of them were usable to me, they all have flaws (I won't detail this here but I talk mainly about usability flaws, not technical flaws). The closest thing to usable I found was XFCE because it was highly configurable, but it was hard and unsatisfactory. And then I installed Xubuntu. Their XFCE is really well configured and it REALLY is usable. For the first time I would consider suggesting it to a relative. As for me, even though I'm not a big fan of the Ubuntu base, I wouldn't consider using another distro than Xubuntu because they're simply broken both in terms of design or ergonomic. The only non-user-friendly I encountered so far with Xubuntu is it doesn't seem to support WPS out of the box. And it would be nice if xfce4-clipman-plugin was installed by default. Except for this, everything just works.