3 ms·
Hmm, The thing about human beings - or goal-seeking subjects, is that they imagine a series of possible future lines and choose those lines they want to have h
by joe_the_user 11y ago
Hmm,
The thing about human beings - or goal-seeking subjects, is that they imagine a series of possible future lines and choose those lines they want to have happen.
If you put a human being on one of these closed timelike curves (CTCs), then the human does their usual human-thing, the human analyzes several lines and acts to cause the one they want to occur to actually happen. Only their action could causing a timeline that they are already a part of to change. Which is where the grandfather paradox might come in - the situation of the grandfather paradox being not just that a person might kill their own grandfather but rather that they might want to kill Hitler or whoever's grandfather to keep something they don't like from being true about their present world (and humans generally have something they don't like about the world).
Of course various devices could be evoked to deal with this - the circuit could be too long to influence or by some magic the things you do to stop the undesirable event actually cause the event (or oppositely for the desired event) - over and over again in the time loop. Science Fiction authors have dealt with along with other scenarios.
But the problem is the "magic", (the coincidence or force that stymies human intentions) is required for every instance of comprehensible time travel, a situation that intuitively seems very unstable as a state-of-the-world.
Thus I think the element that's incompatible with closed timelike curves is intentional thinking itself.
- studentrob 11y ago> Thus I think the element that's incompatible with closed timelike curves is intentional thinking itself. Interesting. I think I followed you.. Expanding on that, We do not know for certain whether intentional thinking exists or if everything is fated. We do not know if true randomness exists. Our intuition says both intentional thinking and randomness do exist, yet there may or may not ever be a science that proves this.
- joe_the_user 11y agoActually, I think science, quantum mechanic in particular, points to hard randomness being an inherent part of the physical laws. On the other hand, I don't think you need any really specific physical laws to have intentional thinking - I would say that any computer program that works with tree search, alphoGo or even much simpler alpha-beta pruners, is going to be engaging in intentional thinking on a level where they act in the present to attain their most desirable outcome in the future - and if that future somehow loops back to the present then the only stable situation is one where the intentional-thinker's efforts are thwarted or otherwise stabilized - ie, the only stable solution is artificially constructed for the instance of the closed causation loop.