4 ms·
Off-topic: The title and several post refer to BMW as a plural: "BMW are complying" and "Do BMW have any obligation...?" I know BMW stands for Bavarian Motorwo
by unethical_ban 11y ago
Off-topic: The title and several post refer to BMW as a plural: "BMW are complying" and "Do BMW have any obligation...?"
I know BMW stands for Bavarian Motorworks, a plural, but so does the US, and it is a singular entity today.
Are the people using BMW plural non-American? I've never heard that here in Texas.
- niccaluim 11y agoIt's British English. I see this usage all the time on BBC News. Drives me batty.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoThey (BMW) are a group of people. They (BMW) are complying. That's the way I've had it explained to me.
- sk5t 11y agoHow is that an appropriate explanation, when you--presumably--wouldn't say "The group are complying"?
- sjwright 11y agoYou're overthinking it. If a group of people are complying, you say "they are complying". Your example is not a valid parallel.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoCorporations are viewed as collective nouns to be used with plural verbs, where as "group" is a collective noun that is treated as singular. I can't think of a context in which I'd use a plural verb with it, but I can think of dozens of such nouns that I would. You can say "The group is complying. They have an obligation." without it sounding awkward, however. Something about formal, notional and situational agreement[0]. The "they" explanation just helped bridge the gap in my mind. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_American_and_British_English#Formal_and_notional_agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_American_and_Bri...
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoI think you would say "the group are complying" when you want to specify that the group as individuals are complying (or when, like me, you don't grammar too well).
- stordoff 11y agoBoth are used in British English for companies, though the plural form is more common. It (to some extent) depends on which aspect of the company you are emphasising (though usage is not always consistent in that regard). Consider "TeamA is a football club" and "TeamA are beating TeamB". In the first example, TeamA is considered a singular entity, and you aren't really concerned with its makeup (though "TeamA are a football club" would also be correct). In the second, TeamA is a group descriptor as it is a group of players that are winning the match, not the single legal/business entity. AFAIK, the plural usage for business names is the most common usage in British English, though it also varies between British dialects (it always surprises me how much dialects vary in English - some areas of England still use an informal form of "you" occasionally, for example)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- robmcm 11y agoSingular is typically used when talking about an entity or brand, where as a plural form is taken when talking about the company as a group of people, or when anthropomorphized. "BMW is a fantastic brand" "BMW are facing tough financial pressure"