6 ms·
Aren't you nervous about doxxing someone like that so thoroughly?
by mirimir 11y ago
Aren't you nervous about doxxing someone like that so thoroughly?
- omginternets 11y agoYeah, I'd like to know the answer to this as well. Do you think their might be repercussions for this? If not, why? If so, how has this affected you?
- tptacek 11y agoIsn't "doxxing people" the actual job of a journalist?
- clinta 11y agoDoes that make it okay? Do the reasons we find it socially unacceptable in other instances apply to journalists?
- 794CD01 11y agoNot everyone finds it socially unacceptable.
- analognoise 11y agoThe same can be said about cannibalism.
- 794CD01 11y agoYes, it can. What's your point?
- tptacek 11y agoWho finds it socially unacceptable? Redditors?
- danielweber 11y agoReddit is hardly the only place. Off the top of my head, Twitter has rules against it, too. NB: I'm not claiming these rules are good or bad. But it's not like only freaks that are members of The Other have concerns about doxxing.
- patio11 11y agoPolice officers, almost universally. Abortionists. Parents of little children, frequently. "This guy we pictured in front of a gay bar." Many people who find themselves targeted by one of the (numerous) Internet hate machines. Elected officials. Unelected officials. Anyone involved in a contract negotiation with the Teamsters. People who take substantial efforts so that ex-romantic partners do not discover where they live because of a well-founded fear that that ex-partner would attempt to murder them. Television personalities. People who recently won the lottery. People named Adolf Hitler (no, not that one). There exist numerous reasons to not love the idea of one's personal information, particularly regarding one's work or home, put out there broadly, particularly when it is attached to information one does not control and/or in a circumstance which would tend to show it to people who do not respect standard middle class norms of detachment. Redditors did not invent concern over this issue. Many of the people with strong concerns about it are demographically dissimilar to the modal Redditor. Edit to add: It occasionally happens that journalists will transgress upon society's norms in this area and persons sympathetic to the aggrevied parties will transgress back. I have not heard a journalist say, in response to that "OK, fair commentary, wot wot." This often comes up in the context "We have published gun owners' addresses because the public has a right to know who owns guns." "We have published your address because the public has a right to know who writes newspapers." I feel like I've read that story ~5 times over the years. First Googleable citation: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/07/nyregion/after-pinpointing-gun-owners-journal-news-is-a-target.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/07/nyregion/after-pinpointing...
- tptacek 11y agoI'm a little confused. I agree that there is such a thing as maliciously or recklessly posting personally identifying information about people. Is that "doxxing"? If so, why are we pretending that this story constitutes "doxxing"? Because that is what the comment to which I replied upthread claimed.
- rincebrain 11y agoThere's a difference between learning private information and disclosing it. Publishing information on a particular private individual because the public's benefit is sufficiently great is a hard line to even vaguely pin down - a home address, all private contact methods, and enough personal data to forge their identity on a passport application is probably never warranted to publish, but you're going to acquire that information while researching private citizens for any reason, and then pare it down to the minimum required to establish whatever story you're reporting on. One might distinguish "doxxing" as "publishing all the information you can retrieve", without any filter or goal other than making the information as public as possible.
- tptacek 11y agoDid I miss the place in these stories where the author published the subject's home address?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rincebrain 11y agoI was not attempting to insinuate that the author had done so; I was just thinking aloud on the distinction between "doxxing" someone and what journalists often do.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 11y agoSome people who do that consider themselves journalists. But then, people who doxx people might also consider themselves journalists. It's a hard call.
- akavel 11y agoPersonally, I interpreted the question as a shorthand for: "Aren't you afraid LeRoux could see that as doxxing, and of potential dangerous consequences to yourself?"
- mirimir 11y agoYes, that's what I meant. But I do also consider the distinction between doxxing and journalism to be highly subjective. The judgment typically comes down to ingroup vs outgroup. Once someone is identified as "other", they're fair game. This all occurs to me as a show trial. They're making an example of him, as authoritarian systems tend to do. And one aspect of that is being dragged through the mud. Being slandered. It's dog pack behavior, and I find it disgusting.
- myrbergs_army 11y agoAs tptacek says, I don't view reporting like this as "doxxing." As the series hopefully shows, Le Roux was a hugely newsworthy figure for many different reasons, so reporting his background and how he got there is part of understanding where he is now. As for being nervous, many of the major players in the story are in US custody, and perhaps somewhat counterintuitively a lot of people involved want to tell their part of the story. If they have beefs, they are typically with each other not with me. I do try to be careful, though.
- mirimir 11y agoTo me, it's just semantics. Let's say that someone published this much information about you. And let's say that they had whatever justifications. That there was widespread agreement that it was OK. Whatever. How would you feel?
- landryraccoon 11y agoAre moral rules situationally dependent on the personal feelings of the person subject to those rules? I would hate to be in jail, but I think it's morally and ethically valid to put people in jail in certain circumstances. Similarly I think that politicians and public figures should be subject to a high degree of scrutiny and transparency about their personal lives, even though I personally wouldn't enjoy such treatment.
- mirimir 11y agoBy "feel", I meant more what you might feel justified in doing about it. The key "moral rule" for me is to only mess with people who have messed with me. I don't get into third-party stuff, and I have little sympathy for those who do.
- BHSPitMonkey 11y agoSo what you're saying is, it would be moral for this guy's murder victims to dox him, but not a reporter? The funny thing with murderers is that they can only really be stopped by third parties.
- CiPHPerCoder 11y agoWhy should they be nervous about doing their job? Also, one X, not two: https://stallman.org/doxing.html https://stallman.org/doxing.html
- dfc 11y agoIs Stallman a new William Safire or Brian Garner? I never knew this was one of his areas of expertise. Oxford lists "doxx" as an alternate but accepted version. I don't have an OED license so I dont have access to the full etymology they use. http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/dox http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/dox
- cakeface 11y agoThe OED does not have listings for "dox", "doxing" or "doxxing". Well, one entry for "dox" that relates to orthodoxy but that does not apply here.
- CiPHPerCoder 11y agoIt's simple: Dox is short for "docs". Shortening a 4-letter word to a 3-letter word is sensible (albeit lazy). Shortening a 4-letter word to a 4-letter word ("doxx") is stupid. I don't know why people spell it with two. Maybe they think it looks cooler? But really it's hacker slang for "I accessed and published sensitive information about an individual" and is in most cases horrible.
- na85 11y agoStallman has been irrelevant for years so I couldn't care less what he has to say on the subject, but tt very clearly comes from "documents -> docs -> dox" and should therefore have just 1 x.
- m0nty 11y ago> Thus, we usually have to write the name of the oil company as "Exxon", though its proper spelling is "e exx o n". (Don't make the mistake of pronouncing "Exxon" like "exon"; you will appear unsophisticated.) The development of the Exxon exx is shown here: http://www.logodesignlove.com/exxon-logo-raymond-loewy http://www.logodesignlove.com/exxon-logo-raymond-loewy It's clearly a double-x rather than any more exotic character, the styling is just that - styling. The Wikipedia article has it as /ˈɛksɒn/ and that's the pronunciation used in their commercials: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s80Hbac2b8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s80Hbac2b8 So that's way off-topic. But what he says about "dox" vs. "doxx" is as much a preference as "focused" and "focussed", or "busing" and "bussing" - there's no "correct" way, not even if it is the original way.
- mratzloff 11y agoDoxing is a targeted attack intended to harass and terrorize the victim as retribution for expressing dissenting opinions or beliefs. The ultimate goal is suppression of free speech. Journalism is not doxing.