3 ms·
>Depression is similarly crippling and unhelpful. Though it must have some function or evolution would have got rid of it. My theory is keeping your head down
by tim333 11y ago
>Depression is similarly crippling and unhelpful.
Though it must have some function or evolution would have got rid of it. My theory is keeping your head down may be helpful if you are screwing up socially. These days if the people who know you don't like you you can just move but in the hunter gatherer days that may have been fatal.
- elbear 11y agoEvolution tends to keep things that increase survival chances, but it can also keep useless features. Also, when the environment changes, a previously useful feature may become useless. Evolution doesn't ensure that feature will disappear, unless it provides a major disadvantage.
- Dylan16807 11y agoSometimes you can infer from evolution that a trait is useful. But only if the trait: 1. Is in a stable part of the genetic code, giving opportunity for bad traits to be weeded out. 2. Is not correlated with a different useful trait that overshadows its goodness/badness. 3. Shows up early enough to affect reproduction. Human intelligence is quite recent, so prerequisite #1 is not met. We have no idea if prerequisite #2 is met, and prerequisite #3 is met. So natural selection can't tell us if depression is/was useful. The kinks of human intelligence are not yet worked out.
- tim333 11y ago#1 Dogs can get depressed so it doesn't need human intelligence. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness) #2 Depression has a major effect, I doubt it's overshadowed #3 You get depressed teenagers So I'd think 1,2 and 3 are met.
- lomnakkus 11y agoRe #1: There's absolutely no way to know if dogs experience "depression" in the same way humans do -- even assuming the outwardly symptoms are similar. Re #2: Your doubt does not constitute evidence in any reasonable sense.
- Bjartr 11y agoBy that logic, why can I get sick at all? Why must depression only have social roots?