19 ms·
I'm seeing a lot of comments to the effect that the government will just try again at some point. Well, welcome to life in a democracy. Nothing is ever settled
by snowwrestler 11y ago
I'm seeing a lot of comments to the effect that the government will just try again at some point.
Well, welcome to life in a democracy. Nothing is ever settled with finality because there are plenty of ways for future generations to change the laws we cherish today--for good or ill.
We could revoke the 13th and 14th Amendments and have slavery again--there is no legal impediment to that. That we don't do that is a reflection of our cultural values--today--which we continually discuss and reinforce.
We could abolish the EPA, or the IRS, or the NSA. We don't because these have enough supporters who value what they do, today. The 2nd Amendment remains strong today because millions of Americans work every day to keep it that way.
So, the long-term solution for strong encryption must be a cultural one. We have to be prepared to fight the crypto wars forever, like unions are still fighting the labor wars a century later. Like civil rights activists are fighting racism even today--and will be for the foreseeable future.
Is that depressing? Not to me; I find it inspiring, much better than a world in which government decisions are truly final. Beware that level of power IMO.
- syshax 11y ago>We could revoke the 13th and 14th Amendments and have slavery again--there is no legal impediment to that. Actually, I think this is the genius of the amendment system. You are correct that it could happen. But unlike laws that can be passed or revoked by Congress by political whim, the barrier to creating or overturning Constitutional amendments is much higher and more difficult to pass.
- studentrob 11y agoPlus the point of our system is to allow both good and bad ideas to be discussed openly so everyone can decide their merits. We haven't seen the likes of Trump since Nixon, and he won't be the last, but we are stronger for giving him room to speak. The bad ideas will hang themselves, even if he becomes president. The US president is not all powerful. There are many limits in place.
- EdHominem 11y agoI feel like we're more immunized against religious flavors of crazy. Like, Cruz is probably further from mentally balanced than Trump even, but if he became president he probably wouldn't cause the same level of trouble. Trump's ideas are "new" in that he does say them first. They appeal to many because we all know the old ideas aren't great, from painful experience. Trump's brand of crazy hasn't hurt us in a long time so we don't see it. As an example: Bush senior said he didn't even think atheists could be considered citizens. But there's 0% chance that he'd try to enact that, or that it'd pass. Trump's ideas have the veneer of "business decisions" and seem more likely to get enacted.
- studentrob 11y ago> Trump's ideas have the veneer of "business decisions" and seem more likely to get enacted. All the more reason to start being active in discussions about his ideas. The most compelling for me is he is okay with arming Japan with nuclear weapons. Trump claims China is tipping the balance of power by building tiny islands in the South China Sea. These are relatively close to China and far from the US. He claims this could kick off WW 3 if not properly off set by adding something to the other side of the scale. He says he'd be okay with arming multiple new nation states, including South Korea and Japan, to balance things again. But arming new nation states with nuclear weapons would severely throw things out of balance. It'd take years for these countries to ramp up the skills necessary to handle nuclear weapons. And during this time, China could build a decent PR campaign in their country encouraging citizens to come together to fight Japan. Japan has still not apologized for all the atrocities they committed in China during WW II, and some Chinese people do not like that. Pour some gasoline on that small fire and it could spread. Knowing China's feelings towards Japan after WW II, China's population would certainly not accept Japan having nukes. They might come together to fight a war. Even though China is not a democracy, they still need their people to unify around a common cause in order to choose war over revolution. I doubt many of Trump's supporters would agree that giving Japan nukes is a good idea. They're the one country we used nukes against. So, it's a good point to bring up with potential Trump voters. I'd like to see that idea of his get more attention so people can see just how impractical he is. Giving SK and Japan nukes isn't just a matter of the US President signing a piece of paper. There are international treaties, diverse governments and populations in place, and as far as I know, Trump has not been to any of those places.
- aaronharnly 11y agoThere's a famous story about the logician Kurt Gödel related to this.[1] In preparation for the US citizenship test, despite assurances from his friends Albert Einstein and Oskar Morgenstern that the test was a mere formality, he studied assiduously all sorts of details about local and national government, including the US Constitution. He quite excitedly told Einstein and Morgenstern that he had found a weakness in the Constitution that would allow the US to become a dictatorship. They were horrified and tried to tell him not to bring up such ideas at the hearing, but the judge happened to note that it was a good thing that in the US, unlike Gödel's native Austria, we were not a dictatorship -- which prompted Gödel to begin explaining his discovery...[2] Unfortunately, no one ever bothered to write down what Gödel's idea was! But it has been speculated[3] that it is this: that the Article V provision for constitutional amendments does not exclude that provision itself from amendment -- so it is possible to first pass an amendment making it easier to pass amendments, after which it could be a short trip to dictatorship under the right conditions. Fanciful, but a fascinating story. Picturing Gödel, Einstein, and Morgenstern hanging out and being playful with each other is a treat. [1] http://morgenstern.jeffreykegler.com http://morgenstern.jeffreykegler.com [2] https://d78508e2-a-97b1dc77-s-sites.googlegroups.com/a/jeffreykegler.com/morgenstern-document/Home/files/Morgenstern_onGoedelcitizenship.pdf https://d78508e2-a-97b1dc77-s-sites.googlegroups.com/a/jeffr... [3] http://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=424069105013095066065027083010109112050024004033095068067067014076107071117079111022028097000118014120007089118096065096097005029055059029004091115090103121013069027026037099005068082025079119104086071121121093114011104006022122007029104067026124006&EXT=pdf http://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=42406910501309506...
- roywiggins 11y agoThe Constitution is pretty much only as strong as the institutions that interpret and enforce it. It's all sort of a collective hallucination that the Constitution has any power in and of itself. "Godelian" defects seem a lot less dangerous to me than plain-old human factors. The UK manages to be a Parliamentary democracy without having a single coherent constitution at all, let alone one free of logical defects- so having a perfectly consistent and "loophole-free" constitution doesn't seem particularly important in practice. The easiest way to wholly undermine the US Constitution is to just expand the Supreme Court bench and then pack it with your cronies, who will then let you do whatever you want and call it constitutional. No amendment needed!
- panarky 11y ago> Well, welcome to life in a democracy. The problem is not that things change in a democracy. The problem is that the change we get does not represent the will of the people. A majority of Americans is dissatisfied with the Patriot Act [1] yet it keeps getting renewed. A majority of Americans thinks political spending is corrupt [2] and that the political system is rigged, yet we get Citizens United to pour even more corporate cash into the machine. A majority of Americans voted for the Democrat in 2000, but the Republican was installed instead [3]. People overwhelmingly disapprove using public funds to bail out reckless bankers [4], but somehow it happens anyway. There was a global uproar over SOPA and PIPA which shut down this draconian legislation. But you can't kill the zombie, and it keeps coming back, now in secret trade agreements like TPP and TTIP that citizens aren't even allowed to read. The Total Information Awareness program was suspended in 2003 [5] after a public outcry over warrantless mass surveillance. Naturally it was all reincarnated into secret NSA programs. We'll see the same thing with devices and personal encryption. This is only a temporary setback for the powers that be, they'll be back with another sensational, emotional case soon enough. The current system does not represent the will of the people. It's an oligarchy supported by a security apparatus run amok. [1] http://www.gallup.com/poll/5263/civil-liberties.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/5263/civil-liberties.aspx [2] http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2015-09-28/bloomberg-poll-americans-want-supreme-court-to-turn-off-political-spending-spigot http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2015-09-28/bloomb... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_election,_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_ele... [4] http://www.gallup.com/poll/106114/six-oppose-wall-street-bailouts.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/106114/six-oppose-wall-street-bai... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_Information_Awareness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_Information_Awareness
- Aleman360 11y agoThe US isn't based on majority rule. No one wants that.
- mtgx 11y agoNo, but I think Americans want a semblance of representation. When The People have close to 0% sway in Congress' opinions on bills, and corporations have like 70%, I'd say that's a pretty big freaking deal, no? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig Every time there's an argument about wanting more democracy in the US, it seems someone always appears to say "but that's mob rule!". No, nobody wants mob rule. But there's a canyon between what exists now and what a more representative government could look like.
- nickff 11y agoOne of the problems that many people have with what the federal government has done in the course of the 20th and 21st centuries is how they have completely ignored the 10th Amendment. I am not sure that the Constitution is an effective protection for civil liberties (or other rights), and I do not know what recourse the citizenry has when the government does ot abide by its own rules.
- studentrob 11y agoYou still have the right to speak up about it in any manner that is not violent. You can say Obama sucks or should resign. That's a right many people in the world do not have. Your voice and vote are more powerful than you think, even when things seem to be going against what you believe in. You can still find a glimmer of hope, like how Lindsey Graham changed his mind in the Apple case.
- rayiner 11y agoIt's not that the federal government has ignored the 10th amendment, it's that it doesn't really mean anything. Here is the text: > The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people. So take something like the ACA individual mandate. Does that violate the 10th amendment? Well, it was held to not be a valid exercise of the commerce clause power. But it was held to be a valid exercise of the taxing power. So it cannot violate the 10th amendment, because the taxing power is one of the ones "delegated to the United States by the Constitution." Say the Supreme Court had held it wasn't valid under the taxing power either. Would it violate the 10th amendment? Technically, but the Supreme Court wouldn't invoke the 10th amendment to strike it down, because a law not supported by one of the enumerated powers is invalid anyway. The 10th amendment, by it's very language, cannot serve as any sort of independent check. If government action passes muster under one of the enumerated powers, it is by definition "delegated to the United States by the Constitution" and cannot violate the 10th amendment. If it doesn't, it's invalid by reason of not being within the government's enumerated powers--no 10th amendment necessary.
- nickff 11y ago
- stcredzero 11y agoWell, welcome to life in a democracy. Nothing is ever settled with finality because there are plenty of ways for future generations to change the laws we cherish today--for good or ill. Some thing seem to be permanent. High priority lobbying goals for big corporations. (Examples: Disney & copyright extensions. Corn & corn subsidies. Car dealerships.)
- studentrob 11y agoThat stuff is not going to change over night, and lobbyists aren't inherently bad. It takes other lobbyists to educate Congress and the public about the flip side of the debate. Tesla is working on that now. If you yourself feel passionately about any issue, nothing is stopping you from launching your own website and campaign. You don't even need to be registered as a non profit. You can say whatever you like. Many countries' populations do not have the wealth and freedom to do what US citizens can do.
- nitrogen 11y agonothing is stopping you from launching your own website and campaign Nothing except the fact that we don't have a multi-billion-dollar interest group paying us to do so ;). I agree with you that things can sometimes be done at the grassroots level, but there is simply no comparison to the tenacity and endurance of influence available to the big players. Any grassroots effort must find a way to surmount that obstacle, not ignore it.
- studentrob 11y agoSure. But collective votes trump money every time. And your voice is part of getting that collective going. It isn't easy. You need to be an active speaker to participate. You need to be good at presenting facts and convincing people. But with the right to free speech, this is something anyone can practice and learn, even computer scientists. As hidden as we liked to stay behind our monitors growing up, it is time we start coming out from under our shells.
- GraemeLion 11y ago
- jMyles 11y agoI think that your comment, while true in spirit, misrepresents some of the mechanics in play here. > We could revoke the 13th and 14th Amendments and have slavery again--there is no legal impediment to that. Of course there is - the constitutional amendment process is designed precisely to be an impediment. Unlike a legal proceeding, where courts can create case law essentially at a whim by legal means alone, the constitutional amendment process is a complex and different political process, requiring quite a few procedural stars to align. One of the problems is that the courts (and, for that matter, Congress and the POTUS) tend not to abide by the text of the constitution, preferring to usurp the political process with their own legal, legislative, or bureaucratic one, respectively. > We could abolish the EPA, or the IRS, or the NSA. We don't because these have enough supporters who value what they do, today. I don't think this is true, but I concede that it's not really measurable. What I mean is: the reason that these methods of control persist is not that they have made a convincing case to the public that their mission is laudable and faithfully executed (environmental protection, accurate and fair taxation, and security for US persons vis a vis international dealings). In fact, it's quite plain to see that all three of these agencies have, from time to time, failed spectacularly at these missions, with some incidents attributable to incompetence and others to misconduct. Instead, I want to suggest that the reason they persist is that they provide convenient mechanisms for exacting power and that they are controlled by people who desire that capacity. > The 2nd Amendment remains strong today because millions of Americans work every day to keep it that way. While I agree with this statement, I think that it is somewhat contrary to your previous one. Here you are talking about the preservation of protections offered by the text of a document, which I agree can only be protected by political vigilance. This is fundamentally different from (and perhaps the opposite of) the assertion by entrenched agencies that they operate by political will. > So, the long-term solution for strong encryption must be a cultural one. We have to be prepared to fight the crypto wars forever, like unions are still fighting the labor wars a century later. Like civil rights activists are fighting racism even today--and will be for the foreseeable future. Here's where I start to agree with you. This is beautifully put.
- woodman 11y ago> ...much better than a world in which government decisions are truly final. Beware that level of power IMO. That is certainly a valid point in the case of laws that expand a state's authority, but I don't think that is true where explicit restrictions on the state's authority are put in place (ex: bill of rights). I doubt anybody (outside of the Brady Campaign) will ever look over the bill of rights and think that we would have been better off without the explicit restrictions made clear.
- cryowaffle 11y agoWell said, thank you Internet stranger
- EdHominem 11y ago> We could revoke the 13th and 14th Amendments and have slavery again No. You can't roll back a human right. If you did it wouldn't be a valid law and people would be justified in armed resistance to it. > We could abolish the EPA, or the IRS, or the NSA. We don't because these have enough supporters who value what they do, today. Well, in the case of the NSA it's more because we suspect they'd commit treason and bring down the country if we tried. (ie, pull out an old tape of Obama and frame him with something, etc.) > Well, welcome to life in a democracy. Nothing is ever settled with finality because there are plenty of ways for future generations to change the laws we cherish today--for good or ill. Yes, things can always be screwed up. But it should be illegal for a government worker (ie FBI) to specifically try to undermine existing decisions by, for instance, lying in court, or paying for propaganda they know to be untrue. Both things we know they do.
- jonpaine 11y agoReally? If a well-funded superpac would systematically and indefinitely try every legal exploit to re-enact slavery you'd be grinning each attempt because "democracy"? .... The idea that our form of government allows us the freedom to resist predatory laws is inspiring, the necessity to fight that fight... over and over again... is the best representation that true freedom is delicate. To protect that freedom we need to hold critical thinking above all else to guard ourselves against the faux intellectualism of statements like yours.
- jaredklewis 11y agoI don't think the parent comment is "grinning," just reiterating the unfortunate reality. Democracy doesn't inherently produce morally laudable outcomes; it just reflects the will of the majority. If everyone in the US strongly valued privacy, then our government would have to behave very differently. The US government's lack of respect for personal privacy merely reflects the apathy towards the issue held by the American voting public. I agree with the parent, that if we want progress, there is no easy path. The only long term solution is to educate the voting public as to the value of privacy. Anything else is just a band-aid.
- lultimouomo 11y ago> We could revoke the 13th and 14th Amendments and have slavery again Could, but won't. Government won't ever try. People are saying - right or wrong - that they will try again to enforce backdoors.
- StanislavPetrov 11y ago>Well, welcome to life in a democracy. If there has ever been a time to illustrate that our country is an oligarchy and not a Democracy, this has been the year. There is a non-zero chance that even in our rigged, broken system that the candidates that are recognized in one or both parties will be ones that received less voter support and were chosen by the wealthy. >We have to be prepared to fight the crypto wars forever, like unions are still fighting the labor wars a century later. Just like the war against CISPA, which was lost to attrition. >We could revoke the 13th and 14th Amendments and have slavery again--there is no legal impediment to that What does the Constitution matter at all? Our system of checks and balances is beyond broken - its gone. Not to be disrespectful, but anyone who thinks that the Constitution is recognized by the government is delusional or worse. The 1st, 4th, 6th, and 9th amendments have been rendered basically moot by recent government action and court inaction. The truth is that you can't have a functioning democracy without the informed consent of the governed. When the majority of the population lacks the capacity to generate informed consent and those in power work actively to suppress that capacity you end up with the authoritarian oligarchy that we have today.
- EdHominem 11y ago> informed consent Our servants have been shown to be lying to us, and have continued lying to congress when called to task. That's directly subverting our democracy. Treason.
- arrrg 11y agoI really fail to see what that has to do with living in a democracy. No matter which system of government, rules (in the broadest sense) can always change. Democracy is just the attempt to better align those rules with the interests of the people (in the broadest sense). As long as the FBI keeps within the rules they can obviously try again. And that’s got very little to do with democracy and much more with the rule of law which is really central here. Everyone – even and especially the government – has to adhere to the law, but there are mechanisms to act within the law or to settle questions or even to change the law, all through some sort of proper and defined process. That’s just what the rule of law is. However, within the system of rule of law (and the particular implementation of that system in the US) there are certainly ways for questions to be more or less settled. Things that are easy to change (e.g. executive orders) and things that are hard to change (e.g. constitutional amendments). There are graduations to this – and graduations that exist on purpose. Behind that is also the realization that quickly changing things – while sometimes necessary – is not really always desirable. So there is a certain sluggishness built right into the system on purpose. And achieving constitutional amendment levels of sluggishness is actually pretty hard to overcome in the US. It’s hard to get an amendment, it’s hard to remove it. Quite on purpose. It’s for settling questions for years. (All of this is not to say that some states don’t try to have some core values enshrined for all eternity. The German constitution has such an article that explicitly forbids amendments of two other articles. No amendment can change that Germany is a democratic and social federal state, that there are elections and three branches of government, that there is rule of law, that every German has the right to resist against anyone attempting to remove that order, that human dignity is inviolable, that human rights are the basis of any human society and that the basic rights defined in the constitution bind as law all three branches of the government. Even if you agree that there is really no way to amend this in any way – something which constitutional scholars aren’t super-decided on – there could still be a revolution of some sort that just abolishes the old constitution … things can always change, also in technically illegal ways.)
- HelloRipley 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sisyphus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sisyphus Your description sounds like Camus' interpretation of the myth of Sisyphus. I like it.