3 ms·
The thing about sociology is that there simply aren't definitive theories akin General Relativity in sociology. At best there are broad methodological schools a
by joe_the_user 11y ago
The thing about sociology is that there simply aren't definitive theories akin General Relativity in sociology. At best there are broad methodological schools and approaches, (such as Structuralism, Utilitarianism, etc). The difference is none of these schools and approaches have been or could (within present constraints) be established by experiments as definitive as Newtonian physics, General Relativity, the atomic theory of matter.
I'm not saying sociology is useless - rather it seems to work by combining a broad approach with specific statistical analysis to get some idea that the specific analysis has some merit.
The non-definitive quality of social science at this level is why sociologists talk about nuance. Just finding a correlation tends to really sketchy for causation - having a reason that the correlation would be causation is better than nothing but still a thin reed.
- coldtea 11y agoThe other thing that makes sociology different from those theories, is that for anything more specific/advanced, it needs a system of values. When you measure magnetic forces or examine the behavior of gravity, you don't need that. But when you study society, you need to stand on some foundations of what's desired, good etc -- at least in the very basic sense. And even something as simple "good is what's useful for society" doesn't answer that, because we then can ask "useful towards what end?", etc. Is something like murder justified? What about war? etc. Those questions are not (and will never be) settled. At the most basic, the different schools come from different such understandings.