3 ms·
Too bad she didn't have a Fitbit or Apple health app so we could have that data :-( --- EDIT: Who the fuck would downvote that?? Knowing the exercise habits o
by samstave 11y ago
Too bad she didn't have a Fitbit or Apple health app so we could have that data :-(
--- EDIT:
Who the fuck would downvote that?? Knowing the exercise habits of a 120 year old person should be awesome. You think I'm playing fanboi? Jesus, no it just would have been valuable to know her physical habits. So, explain yourselves.
- thesimpsons1022 11y agomurkt
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 11y agoI didn't downvote you but I certainly don't agree with your point. Data about her exercise is hers. It's private. Just because it might be "useful" (in a cargo-cult'ing "what works for one person surely works for all" unscientific and nonsensical version of "useful") doesn't mean we should have any access to that information any more than access to her email would be "useful" to look at the way 100-year-olds communicate electronically. In my opinion we should be thinking of ways we can do useful data science without access to private data, not working out ways to make gathering private data easier.
- madaxe_again 11y agoWell, you say that, but given the arrangement, is it? By taking on a viager you effectively act as pension and actuarial agent - and knowing the health of your client is highly relevant to the investment you are making. This is why one has to have a medical to get health insurance.
- onion2k 11y agoI wasn't suggesting no one should have access to other people's data. If there's a good reason, such as informing the basis of a contract in the case of a medical to get health insurance, then both parties benefit - one gets to understand the risk they're undertaking and the other gets insurance. So long as the person having the medical understands what they're handing over that's fine. What I take issue with is the assumption that any data that could be analysed for some marginal good should be openly available. Data is hugely powerful and incredibly valuable, so we need to take individual privacy in to great consideration. In the case of this old lady the tangible benefits of her data being analysed is so tiny (it's not a controlled study, there's no rigour to 'using a fitbit', and it's a such a small sample size of literally 1 person that any hope of anonymity is impossible) that her privacy is far more important than any possible insight in to ageing that the data might give us.
- imgabe 11y agoDead people don't get much privacy. We already read through their diaries and letters. It's hard to see how they would be harmed by the number of miles they rode a bike being public information.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoOP didn't say the data should be taken against her will, more that it was a shame we didn't have access to it. Beyond that, though, I still take exception to the notion that individual privacy should automatically trump [1] the greater benefit of wider society. [1] Damn, that word's been ruined, hasn't it?
- dekhn 11y agoThere is a general trend in the medical community to adopt consent forms, typically for clinical trials although also more generally as part of health care, that explicitly allow people to state their intent to make their medical data available for research purposes. Generally, I support the idea that people can voluntarily consent to have their medical data made available for wide-ranged studies. The consent needs to be explicit, and the usage of the data needs to be respectful. Studying centatarians is probably mainly useful for increasing quality of life for very old people. It's not clear yet whether that translates to useful medical data for the larger population.
- dang 11y agoPlease don't break the HN guidelines by going on about downvotes. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11368361 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11368361 and marked it off-topic.