5 ms·
And there is no shortage of people out there who would not think twice to blow things up. I think this may be the essential flaw in the logic that says we shou
by nitrogen 11y ago
And there is no shortage of people out there who would not think twice to blow things up.
I think this may be the essential flaw in the logic that says we should be dead by now. Maybe there is a shortage of people who want to blow things up without thinking.
- jaredandrews 11y agoHah! People always say this sort of stuff, and while I don't believe it, I could never come up with an answer simpler than "go read that Better Angels book." I never looked at it like that before. I am going to use this line now, I hope you don't mind!
- labster 11y agoAnd, if elected president, I will do something about this shortage.
- mdpopescu 11y agoAgreed. Given that airports have been closed because of an empty cardboard box with BOMB written in marker, if a lot of people wanted to mess up with everybody else they could have done so easily.
- marcoperaza 11y agoJudging by the continuous stream of people convicted for buying what they think are explosives from undercover FBI agents posing as jihadists, there are a lot of people that want to blow things up. Or take the 53,000 to 258,000 people that are estimated to be part of ISIS's military forces and allied groups. Thankfully, most of them are pretty stupid, but there are also plenty of highly educated terrorists and they tend to be engineers. The flaw in the argument is likely GP's inference that "there are some controls there that I'm sure if the wrong person pushes that red button, something will go kaboom." Critical infrastructure tends to be better engineered than that. Cybersecurity threats are newer, less widely understood, and inadequately guarded against, but human error is an age-old problem.
- philsnow 11y ago> Judging by the continuous stream of people convicted for buying what they think are explosives from undercover FBI agents posing as jihadists, there are a lot of people that want to blow things up. Well. If it were the case that there are lots of people trying to buy explosives from fbi agents posing as jihadists, I would go so far as to conclude that there are a lot of people who want _the ability_ to blow things up. If there were a lot more office bombings, infrastructure bombings, etc, then I would agree that there appear to be a lot of people who want to actually blow things up.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- marcoperaza 11y agoIn these cases, there's always a clear intention to carry out an attack. Here's one such case: http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/01/14/377287190/ohio-man-is-arrested-for-plotting-attack-on-u-s-capitol http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/01/14/377287190/... By running these stings, the FBI has made it very hard for real terrorist plotters to get in contact with real would-be foot-soldiers. If someone agrees to carry out a bombing when a fake terrorist is asking, what makes you think they wouldn't do it when a real terrorist asks?
- fapjacks 11y agoThere's also this: "For months, the FBI used a confidential source to get close to Cornell, who allegedly said he wanted to hatch a plot inside the U.S." "Get close to" in law enforcement parlance means "encourage criminal activity". If you read the details in these court cases, you repeatedly see an almost universal pattern of activity on the part of law enforcement to egg their targets on towards the criminal act. Drug "dealers" hassled for months to purchase LSD and repeatedly being told "no", only to finally give in and then get arrested. "Terrorists" being repeatedly contacted by informants or agents and plugged pro-terrorist encouragements for months until they agree to a part in some kind of "plot". You have to remember that the vast majority of people won't take action by themselves. Even the crazy people that want to blow something up won't go out of their way to do it. It's the leaders you should be worried about. People that coordinate or incite others. Part of my career as an infantryman involved "riot police" training. The number one thing for arrest teams to do is to isolate and detain the people inciting the others. And this is why the powers that be are so hungry for mass surveillance: It's actually pretty easy to make giant relationship graphs of these networks to find the leaders. Remember the military talking about dropping five hundred pound bombs on phone numbers? They don't know who the person is, but they know he's a leader. Those people are easy to identify with enough information (and no, they don't need to unlock our iPhones to get at it). It is in their best interest to keep pushing this idea that any random anti-government person is capable of an Oklahoma City bombing. The fact is, they're not.
- qwtel 11y agoI think survivorship bias is the central flaw in "why aren't we dead by now". If survival depends on an event not occurring, I'd be extra careful in estimating its odds.
- morsch 11y agoThat only seems to apply to "why wasn't I hit by a SCADA exploit". Unless an exploit that affects everyone in one fell swoop is given a material likelihood.
- tamana 11y agoHow many nuclear power plants have been blown up by hackers? For whatever reason, civilizations suffer incredibly small damage relative the amount of technical insecurity. The worst destruction comes from large scale war, not attacks.
- eranation 11y agoWell depends how you define shortage. Every single ISIS member probably would be happy to save a trip and blow himself up and just click a button.