4 ms·
Definition of mental illness is relying on whether a condition conflicts with society. Therefore, as a function of 19th century western society, it was a mental
by golergka 11y ago
Definition of mental illness is relying on whether a condition conflicts with society. Therefore, as a function of 19th century western society, it was a mental illness; thankfully, now it is not.
Without a context of environment a definition of mental illness can not possibly exist. For example, paranoid schizoprenia wouldn't be a mental illness in an environment where all paranoid fantasies turned out to be true.
- diskcat 11y ago>Definition of mental illness is relying on whether a condition conflicts with society. This just sounds like a scientified social inquisition.
- threatofrain 11y agoThe definition of mental disorder is a permanently context-bound construct. There is no inherency in nature or physics which requires a classification of disorder. However, the construct is both useful and abusable.
- sedeki 11y agoThat they want to exclude environmental factors does not mean "pick an arbitrary universe".
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoAbject incoherency is a symptom of some mental disorders that doesn't appear to rely on the context. There are others I think: sudden lack of abilities without any corresponding [macroscopic] physical symptoms probably counts. Your last sentence appears to rely on living in a Universe completely unlike our own.
- kazinator 11y agoYes, paranoid schizophrenia would still be a mental illness in which the fantasies turned out true, if they turned out true by complete fluke. That is to say, if some crazy nonsense for which you have absolutely no evidence turns out true by amazing coincidence, it was still crazy to have believed it.