14 ms·
More Encryption, More Notifications, More Email Security
- akerro 11y agohttps://www.salon.com/2014/11/16/googles_secret_nsa_alliance_the_terrifying_deals_between_silicon_valley_and_the_security_state/ https://www.salon.com/2014/11/16/googles_secret_nsa_alliance...
- mtgx 11y agoWhat's the progress on the End-to-End tool? What's the progress on making Hangouts end-to-end encrypted for that matter? I feel that these improvements, while useful, are a sideshow to stop privacy enthusiasts from switching to better encrypted services or tools, while Google (and Microsoft, and Yahoo) continues to mine all of your private conversations for advertising purposes.
- danieldk 11y agoIndeed, it's surprising that there is no sign of end-to-end encryption on Hangouts, while the competition (with marketshare) is getting there. iMessage had end-to-end encryption since the beginning. Whatsapp has end-to-end encryption on Android based on TextSecure (though it is still hard to see whether it's active). Telegram has support, though it's not the default. In the meanwhile, Apple also has encrypted notes, phones that are encrypted by default, etc. Google seems to focus purely on transport security.
- ikeboy 11y agoE2E would mean you can't log in to hangouts on a new device and access your history, which is a useful feature.
- ComputerGuru 11y agoNo it doesn't. It just makes that a little harder to implement. You can set up a side channel between your own devices to sync that history. Or you can use double-encrypted key and just change the outer layer of that onion when a new device is added.
- ikeboy 11y ago>You can set up a side channel between your own devices to sync that history. Then 1. Some device would need to be logged in and online (not always true) 2. You'd need a way to authenticate the new device, which means not only do you need the other device on, but you need it close when first setting it up, and you'd need to manually transfer keys or something of similar bandwidth 3.Either all history would need to transfer, which is a bandwidth hog if history is large (although if device is close then you could transfer over Wifi direct or bluetooth or something), or that other device would need to kept online whenever I want to query history (currently, Google serves this function) 4. If you lose a device, there's no recovery (this is probably the main reason Google won't do it.) If you really want it, there are apps that do E2E and support Google Talk. See https://chatsecure.org/ https://chatsecure.org/
- kuschku 11y agoConversations.im [1] fulfils the same purpose, has the same features, also is open source, is on F-Droid, and looks better. ________________________ [1] https://conversations.im/ https://conversations.im/
- drakenot 11y agoThe development on the end-to-end extension seems to be relatively slow if you look at the commit log. Does anyone with more inside information know what is going on with it? Does it have dedicated team members or is this just an internal side project for a couple people?
- MajesticHobo 11y agoWhy would Google implement e2e crypto? Doesn't that violate their business model?
- jonknee 11y agoI would assume for their millions of paying email users... The business model would be to charge money for feature requested by customer.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoIf you think that enterprise hosted email customers want end-to-end encryption, you are seriously mislead. What most of the customers want more than anything is censorship and compliance, at delivery time. They want mails to be rejected if they have naughty words. They want viruses dropped. They want messages containing customer credit card numbers dropped. Content analysis is the #1 feature required by enterprise email customers. They do _not_ want end-to-end encryption that would prevent content inspection by intermediaries. They do not want that at all.
- jonknee 11y agoI guess it all depends on the enterprise. Encryption is a requirement for certain businesses. My partner is required to use it at her law firm when working with certain clients.
- codelitt 11y agoThis seems like much ado about nothing. I certainly appreciate the effort is better than nothing, however, how often are those notices served to US/European citizens? It's one thing to stand up to government overreach in foreign countries, but how about the country where you (and a large percentage of your users) reside? They specify attackers, but I'm assuming this notice to the end user does not apply to the US/EU governments requesting your data and them complying? Another gripe I have is that TLS has probably been broken by the NSA^1. It's better than nothing to alert us about the other party not using it, but really provides limited protection. PGP/GPG is really the only assurance you have and the plugins for different desktop apps are nearly always buggy. I end up just manually encrypting/decrypting with GPG because a buggy encryption integration is not a comforting thought. If they really cared about keeping your privacy safe, they'd have an end-to-end encryption tool/integration. [1]: http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2013/12/how-does-nsa-break-ssl.html http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2013/12/how-does-nsa...
- tibbon 11y agoAgreed; bake easy PGP into Gmail.
- nxzero 11y agoIf they had end-to-end encryption, then Google wouldn't be able to read the emails; meaning to gain value, Google would have to charge for the service.
- dorfsmay 11y agoGoogle does charge for email services, for anybody using gmail with their own domain, which is a lot of small companies and probably a few medium size one.
- nxzero 11y agoRight, though my guess is that doing custom domains and end-to-end encryption as a service are not comparable services or markets.
- theandrewbailey 11y ago> In the 44 days since we introduced it, the amount of inbound mail sent over an encrypted connection increased by 25%. I'm surprised that it's not more than that. I can imagine executives everywhere asking their IT people "Why do all of our company's emails have this error on them? They are all red and scary!"
- mhurron 11y agoYou're assuming anyone noticed.
- comex 11y agoWell, someone noticed if the percentage of encrypted mail increased that quickly.
- tam7t 11y agohttps://motherboard.vice.com/read/how-the-us-military-fails-to-protect-soldiers-emails https://motherboard.vice.com/read/how-the-us-military-fails-...
- kuschku 11y agoWell, if GMail would be open source, and we could self-host it, we could get the same advantage. Giving all your private data to a foreign company, serving interests of investors, acting directly against your and your nations interests is NOT acceptable, and should NOT be common.
- delroth 11y agoPlease read the link I posted before replying. Mike Hearn explains that the biggest advantage that large email service providers in the war against spam is their centralized aspect. Because of the access to large amounts of data (obviously) but also because there is basically no known way of writing decentralized anti-spam computation engines that cannot be gamed by spammers. Also, would you rather have users willingly giving their data to a foreign company (legally liable, bound to a published privacy policy) or unwillingly to malware authors and credentials phishers? In the current security landscape this is a very real tradeoff to think about.
- kuschku 11y agoYou realize that almost all email filtering that GMail is doing nowadays is based on trained networks on the content of the mail, not trained on the domains? And in fact, if you train your own neural networks to do this same task – as I’m currently doing – you get the same quality of categorization and spam filtering that Google got. I consider Google, the NSA, and so on just as trustworthy as a Nigerian Scammer, so I see no difference in giving my data to Google, or giving it to the phisher. They operate under laws I can’t control, use my data in ways I can’t control, and don’t ask me if they wish to use my data for more other purposes later on.
- thomasahle 11y agoBut how do you get access to large enough sets of training data? Wouldn't that always require plain text access to other peoples mail? Even more, the data would have to be recent, as to take into account trends in approaches.
- rubyfan 11y agoI agree with much of the others commenting here. The IETF strict transport security draft is ridiculous. If every carrier who passes the message can #1 read it and #2 potentially change the content and #3 promiscuously route messages to each other then why does it really matter if they pass it amongst themselves securely? Line security is easily defeated by other 'features' of SMTP. End to end encryption is the only thing that will really matter in email security. And even with end to end encryption email is a flawed medium, since it leaks meta data in the process of message delivery. That is kind of a barrier to secure messaging.
- azinman2 11y agoBecause if you trust your email provider(s) then big baddies can't manipulate it. It's about improving the threat model, not "solving it." Basically it cuts off the easiest attack angles from very sophisticated hackers and governments.
- sliverstorm 11y agoLine security is easily defeated by other 'features' of SMTP. I'm not enough of an SMTP/security guru to know what you're referencing. I'm curious, can you share?
- rubyfan 11y agoTLS Cipher downgrade and DNS weakness. SMTP and almost every protocol out there whether SSL/TLS enhanced are designed for least common denominator interoperability and legacy compatibility. SMTP and really email as we know it is inherently insecure. Without end to end encryption and relying on hosted mailboxes, we're inviting "service providers", government and hackers alike to read and tamper with our email.
- ryporter 11y agoWhy "state-sponsored" attacks specifically? If any group of attackers is targeting me, then I'd be just as concerned. Introducing that distinction seems like it will force Google to determine whether a group is backed by a government.
- ethbro 11y agoI'd guess from a network level "state-sponsored" attacks are easier to fingerprint than individual password phishing attempts.
- thomasahle 11y agoI imagine this relates to certain attacks which are only feasible for Governments.
- huntsman 11y agoThere's many other warnings and notifications that Google gives users about phishing and hijacking attempts. This specific warning is exposing the fact that we think someone is being targeted by a government backed attacker. We believe this is information that could be useful for some people and that we shouldn't keep this to ourselves.
- satbyy 11y agoBy chance, I happened to type (note the www.) https://www.security.googleblog.com/ This immediately popped up a red warning in Chrome: Your connection is not private Attackers might be trying to steal your information from www.security.googleblog.com (for example, passwords, messages, or credit cards). NET::ERR_CERT_COMMON_NAME_INVALID It seems that the SSL certificate is issued to *.googleusercontent.com. Given that we're talking of Google, I expected that the URL will redirect to non-www https site, but apparently not.
- philip1209 11y agoThis seems to be an edge case between how wildcard certificates work versus how HSTS works. Wildcard certs only validate one subdomain of depth (so *.foo.com cert does not validate a.b.foo.com). HSTS "includeSubDomains" will require a valid SSL cert for all recursive subdomains. It's a problem, but I don't think it's a problem worth solving.
- lallysingh 11y agoIgnoring kuschku's telling, this is a big move for a big ship (email security). Congrats!
- dadrian 11y agoCongrats Jon!
- Tepix 11y agoGoogle has no interest in end-to-end encryption: It would put them out of the loop. It would be contrary to their mission to analyze the customer data to deliver better ads. Gmail is a big privacy problem. Even if you don't use it yourself, nowadays a large percentage of your emails will end up there. And why? It's all about lazyness and low friction. Computer literate persons (that's you, right?) should really consider to get off their butts and host their own email. It's not hard, it's not expensive and it's not a lot of work to maintain either. It can even be fun and informative. By sticking to gmail, you're no longer credible when complaining about the erosion of privacy on the internet.
- Zigurd 11y agoI pay for various kinds of Google services already. Making a business case for secure paid email is not hard.
- morley 11y agoWhy does Google have to be the one to provide secure paid email to you? Gmail obviously operates at a vastly different scale than their similar paid software products. If you really want secure paid email, I'm sure there are plenty of other companies willing to take your money.
- azinman2 11y agoThey already offer it in their Google for work product.
- fallenshell 11y agoBut not everyone has the time or money to maintain an email server running 24/7. Thus why people resort to hosted services. Also the configuration of mail servers nowadays is a huge pain in the backside. They always get tagged as spam unless you go through a ton of hoops. It's flat out annoying.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hartator 11y agoI think the red lock next to the recipient email is more confusing than anything. It's suggesting strongly some kind of end-to-end encryption, like PGP, when there is still nothing. Google still has full access to the plain text versions of these emails as well as the receiving email providers. It's creating a fake assumption of security that can be more damaging than anything.
- stingraycharles 11y agoI'm not sure if it's far fetched, but instead of creating more security for gmail users, perhaps this is a deliberate attempt for people to start requesting that "lock" next to their email address (especially businesses), and as such create a surge in providers adopting secure communication? Because that's the biggest impact this will have, and as such, will mostly indirectly increase security for google's users.
- technion 11y agoMy major concern here is that to me, end users are reading into this way too much. I say this because I caught a developer a few days ago implementing an online payment gateway using a Wordpress "form to email" plugin. The ensuing argument came down to his firm belief that email to gmail is now "encrypted", and thus, this is perfectly safe. We need to be careful about sending this sort of message.
- Animats 11y agoThe mail content is still in the clear inside Google. As long as Google does mail that way, it's not secure. Only end to end encryption can provide any security.
- daviddahl 11y agoBut, no protection from Google in any of this. Sigh.