15 ms·
$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout Seattle region
- serge2k 11y agois this system going to be anywhere close to the actual needs of the region in 25 years? Seriously, 25 years out. That just seems ridiculous to me.
- melling 11y agowhatever happened to those maglev trains that I used to read about as a kid? Oh right, China... http://youtu.be/c8SqDVUdMtY http://youtu.be/c8SqDVUdMtY http://gbtimes.com/china/beijing-launch-first-maglev-line-2016 http://gbtimes.com/china/beijing-launch-first-maglev-line-20... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_S1,_BCR https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_S1,_BCR
- djcapelis 11y agoLine S1 will be much slower than most traditional trains, the energy usage of maglev isn't that much less than traditional rail (so they don't tend to run faster, the metal rails aren't a large limiting factor for speed) and the vertical alignment restrictions on maglev technology means it's not necessarily gonna be technology you can easily put everywhere.
- melling 11y agoCan you be more specific? How fast are traditional trains? These are intercity trains we are discussing, right? The S1 is being used where you would have a subway or light rail.
- Alphasite_ 11y agoWell i'm not sure about outside europe but Italy's new trains run at ~400Kph
- melling 11y agoThey run that fast between cities. Clearly we aren't talking about that. Japan"s intracity maglev is going to go almost 600kph. http://youtu.be/VuSrLvCVoVk http://youtu.be/VuSrLvCVoVk Of course, you don't build that to go 10 city blocks.
- djcapelis 11y ago> Japan"s intracity maglev is going to go almost 600kph. No it's not. 603 is the fastest they've ever gotten the train to go on a test track, which doesn't make that the speed they'd actually run for commercial service. Their current plan is 500 with a top speed of 505. Which is really good, but also a decent ways off and involves some serious earthworks to make the track flat enough. For comparison, the speed record for wheel on steel rail trains is currently 574 km/hr. The rail really isn't a huge impact on the speed yet. At those speeds it really start being more about aerodynamics of the vehicles and the cost per kWh. Maybe maglev technology will change that at some point, but right now we haven't really seen results that would lead us to assume that big of an advantage comes from getting rid of the rail. Arguably the biggest advantage is going to come when someone figures out how to put the trains in a tube where the aerodynamic situation changes completely. That's why the hyperloop proposal wasn't just "use a maglev". Maglev trains are cool as shit though, you're literally floating through the air, it's awesome. I highly recommend riding the one in Shanghai. Make sure you hit a 430 km/hr run and not the slower 300 km/hr ones, the experience is very different. It's fun as hell.
- djcapelis 11y agoThat is definitely not an actual commercial operating speed, IIRC. Trains can go really fast in test and demos, operating speeds right now rarely break 300 km/hr on most systems. Many systems are headed to 320-360 though. The Shanghai maglev is the only commercial line that regularly does over that in commercial service, at 430 km/hr, but that's only for a few runs a day, most of the day it goes 300 km/hr.
- djcapelis 11y agoThe point I'm trying to make here is the speeds on Line S1 are similar to commuter trains in a similar class of operation. Maglev doesn't really provide a speed advantage on that line over traditional rail.
- brandonmenc 11y agoFor reference, the Phoenix light rail timeline: 1989 - route plan 2000 - voter approved tax increase 2005 - construction started 2008 - operations started
- jschwartzi 11y agoLet's just do nothing but build more highways, then. I'm sure all the 25-year-olds will thank us for planning for their future then.
- LAMike 11y ago50 Billion could buy a lot of self driving cars in 5 years.... why not just spend it on city owned cars that taxpayers can order on demand?
- st3v3r 11y agoCause that would do nothing to alleviate traffic congestion.
- barney54 11y agoAnd neither does light rail. light rail is a bad investment. It is expensive and low capacity. It is 19th century technology. Building bus rapid transit makes much more sense because it is felixible and less expensive. But politicians don't like photo ops with buses nearly as much as with trains.
- stephenboyd 11y agoThe proposal is for bus improvements and bus rapid transit as well as light rail.
- g8gggu89 11y agoThere's no drawback to buying a lot more electric buses for Seattle?
- dpark 11y agoPoliticians like trains because their constituents like trains. Buses are stuck in traffic. Light rail runs on dedicated lines. Light rail is attractive because it is more predictable. The buses in Seattle are less attractive because they suffer the same congestion and unpredictability as driving.
- superuser2 11y agoBus rapid transit specifically refers to bus lines on dedicated right-of-way. However, once you are going to the trouble of building dedicated right-of-way, the incremental cost of making it rail isn't too bad compared to the enormous efficiency/scalability of rail over buses.
- kingnight 11y agoWhy 25 years?
- jessaustin 11y agoClicking on the map to magnify it, makes it smaller.
- cwbrandsma 11y agoWe should have the guys that ran the Big Dig in Boston take care of this. They can run that tab up to $100B in no time.
- notatoad 11y agoI don't think seattle needs any help in that department, they've got their own over-budget long-delayed tunnel project. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Way_Viaduct_replacement_tunnel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Way_Viaduct_replacemen...
- g8gggu89 11y agoThere's already that underground highway being dug, that runs along the bay.
- zifnab06 11y agoJust to point this out: sound transit's last project, which expanded the existing westlake->seatac airport light rail from Westlake to capital hill and finally to UW, finished under budget and ahead of time. It was originally scheduled to open September 2016, and the first trains carried passengers last weekend.
- hacknat 11y agoTo all the people dissing this plan from afar you have no idea how bad Seattle has gotten in the last three years. Over 100k people have moved into the metro area every year for three years. My commute times changed noticeably over the course of one year. It went from consistently 30 minutes over the 90 bridge to consistently an hour (we're talking 18 miles, door to door). This thing should have been built in the 70s. My wife and I actually moved back to the Midwest 2 months ago after living in Seattle for 8 years, despite my comfortable Senior Engineer salary, because all of our closest friends moved away in the span of a year, because they could no longer afford to live in the city (none of them worked in tech). I wish Seattle good things from afar, and it will always hold a special place in my heart, but I'm glad I'm not living through these infrastructure growing pains that should have been addressed years ago.
- erikw 11y agoI think that economics will sort out the cost-of-living issues. Seattle doesn't seem to have the NIMBYism of the Bay Area, and Washington State actually requires that communities plan for growth under the state Growth Management Act. I'm not sure how this compares to California (witness the unencumbered sprawl of LA, or the inability to build anything in the Bay Area), but from what I've seen, local Washington governments are not pretending that population growth is a fantasy. Seattle's growth plan specifically mentions "directing growth to existing urban centers and villages", so I can see how the proposed Sound Transit line extensions would help facilitate urbanization. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_State_Growth_Management_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_State_Growth_Manage... http://www.seattle.gov/dpd/cityplanning/completeprojectslist/comprehensiveplan/whatwhy/ http://www.seattle.gov/dpd/cityplanning/completeprojectslist...
- specialist 11y agoI hope so. Seattle, Vancouver, SF, etc need to upzone, to permit more development, so that supply can meet demand. As I understand it, that upzoning is not happening nearly fast enough. Public transit initiatives trigger (begats?) upzoning. This is an end run around the regressive restrictions on property taxes and entrenched NIMBYism. I fully support it. Whatever works. I wish my peeps working on affordability, homelessness, economic justice would put less emphasis on set asides, protecting older listings, etc, and place more emphasis on increasing inventory. One potential monkeywrench of increasing supply is absentee landlords. I just read something like 1/3rd of Vancouver properties are owned by Chinese investors. Which I'm totally cool with so long as the units are mostly occupied.
- sitkack 11y agoWhat was the cost for the monorail again?
- erikw 11y agoTrains are very cool, and the idea of shared public transportation is probably noble, but there is an intractable economic problem. If my wife and I both take the train, it costs twice as much to us. If we drive somewhere, it costs half as much. Additional issues that need to be solved to make pubtrans competitive with car ownership are scheduling, the ability to bring cargo, and negative class connotation. And this completely discounts the probable arrival of ubiquitous autonomous electric vehicles before Sound Transit even gets to finish this project. As much as I enjoy the romantic nature of trains, I think the Puget Sound is gearing up for a folly of a white elephant.
- jacalata 11y agoIf you drive, it costs the same at best. Cars don't run cheaper when you put a second person in them.
- remontoire 11y agoI think he means per person.
- paulddraper 11y agoYes, though he's using a double standard. Per person, a train costs the same regardless of the number of people.
- greggman 11y agoIt's a fair comparison and one I make often. Example: My friends and I could take public transport 10 miles. It might cost $5 per person. For four people that's $20. $20 might pay for a cab for all four of us. Same with planes. I could fly or drive from LA to Vegas. Flying is $240 per person friday to sunday. 4 people = $960. 1 car carrying 4 people will be a lot less even if I rent it.
- jacalata 11y ago
- 13of40 11y agoMeanwhile, on the east side of Lake Washington, we're busy tearing up all of the track and replacing it with bike paths.
- stevewilhelm 11y agoBuilding transit infrastructure is expensive and time consuming in metropolitan areas. Case in point: a five mile extension on an existing Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) line and one new station cost $890 million and took seven years to build. [1] The resulting extension is expected to increase in ridership by 5000 to 7000 daily trips in the next decade. [2] [1] http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx [2] http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx/chronology http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx/chronology
- greggman 11y agoI have a strong feeling much of that is corruption and/or over charging. I have no proof but AFAICT Singapore and Tokyo have no trouble building new lines quickly and for far less money and I suspect they both do a better job.
- stevewilhelm 11y agoWell, the Shibuya-Ikebukuro section of the Tokyo metro is 12 miles long and was built between 2000 and 2012. It cost 250 billion yen, or just over 2 billion US dollars. [1] [1] http://www.treehugger.com/cars/trainspotting-new-subway-line-opens-in-tokyo.html http://www.treehugger.com/cars/trainspotting-new-subway-line...
- Aleman360 11y agoI wish the train to the east side went across 520 instead of 90. Oh well.
- NotSammyHagar 11y agoIt seems idiotic that we didn't allow for that on 520. Did we really screw it up that much?
- WalterBright 11y agoIronically, the existing tracks from Renton to Bothell could have been used for half of a light rail system for a song. But the government has desperately pretended those tracks don't exist, and has gone to considerable lengths to destroy them. A few years earlier, they destroyed the tracks from Renton to Black Diamond so thoroughly the right-of-way can never be used for rail again. It boggles the mind.
- OrwellianChild 11y agoThis interests me... Do you have any articles I can read about this? I was always under the impression that the Sounder (our commuter heavy rail line) used tracks shared with commercial traffic (BNSF, etc.) and thus couldn't be fully developed into a city-wide system...
- WalterBright 11y agoNothing has run on the tracks for 20 years. Some of it has been pulled up, but the right-of-way remains. Seattle Transit just announced a $50 billion plan to blast new right-of-way, never mind the trackage could be doubled by re-using that right-of-way for a few million. You can still see the tracks on Google Maps: https://www.google.com/maps/@47.6753261,-122.1882192,16z https://www.google.com/maps/@47.6753261,-122.1882192,16z although it has been renamed "Cross Kirkland Corridor" in their attempt to hide what it is. Sound Transit prefers a plan that costs one thousand times as much, still won't serve the eastside, and will not be in service until half the existing taxpayers are long dead.
- Twirrim 11y agoIt's not Sound Transit's fault. The cities won't let them. Kirkland wants them to build out Buses and threatens to veto any light rail project. Residents by the CKC want to "save the trail" (aka we're selfish jerks that bought a property by a railway line, but don't want noise of trains) http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/12/kirkland-st-struggling-to-agree-on-st3/ http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/12/kirkland-st-struggl...
- JDDunn9 11y agoI wish someone would give PRT a chance. Something like skyTran could be built for 1/5th the cost and would be significantly faster for commuters (since most time is spent at stops before yours).
- Grishnakh 11y agoYep, I say this all the time, and people think it's an even crazier idea than bigfoot and alien sightings. Somehow, it's realistic to think about us all having self-driving cars dealing with the chaos of city traffic and pedestrians, and it's realistic to propose spending billions and billions of dollars on slow light-rail systems which require years of construction where the roads are all torn up, but it's completely bonkers to think about building a system with elevated rails hanging on utility poles and small, autonomous cars riding on these rails for only $1 million per mile. I can't wait until Israel has their SkyTran system working so all these idiots in America won't be able to say how "impossible" it is.