6 ms·
Why do American commenters become so defensive whenever an American company operating abroad is subject to local laws? Foreign countries aren't subject to the f
by Someone1234 11y ago
Why do American commenters become so defensive whenever an American company operating abroad is subject to local laws? Foreign countries aren't subject to the first amendment of the US constitution, and a lot of other countries both through law and through social norms don't consider freedom of speech absolute.
This law doesn't allow individuals to remove any information they find distasteful, it allows individuals to apply to remove information about THEM. And there is already built in a "public interest" defence, meaning if there is a public interest to the link then the link stays.
Ultimately this isn't black and white, and there are some interesting use cases of this Right to be forgotten (e.g. revenge porn), I'd suggest people read the Wikipedia article top to bottom, it is quite fascinating: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten
But I'll say this, whatever opinion you come away with, you cannot criticise France for not holding up to the US's ideals. If Google doesn't want to operate under the EU's privacy standards then Google can leave.
I also find it slightly ironic that Americans on one hand whine endlessly about other countries violating perceived rights while on the other operating the world's largest surveillance dragnet, and Americans routinely say (paraphrasing) "it is unacceptable to monitor Americans, but fine to spy on foreigners!" So if you're going to start arguing that the US's 1st amendment should apply in France then I'm going to argue that the US's 4th amendment should too!
- turbohz 11y agoInternet will die by thousand cuts if we let any country apply their clueless, stupid, misguided, shortsighted, unenforceable laws. This is a European giving leaving his opinion.
- kodablah 11y agoThe defensiveness, at least for me, is that the laws are being applied globally. Nobody should agree with US laws applying in France. Seems a lot of people agree with EU laws applying in the US. The internet is global, laws are not. I have the same opinion if a French company, doing business in the US, is told how it must do things in France by US regulators (as opposed to its part in the US). > So if you're going to start arguing that the US's 1st amendment should apply in France Did you read the article? It's the opposite (EU law applying outside of the EU)
- hk__2 11y agoThe law doesn’t apply globally: it allows a French citizen to ask Google to have their info removed. Period. It doesn’t allow US people to do the same. That this info is hidden in all countries Google operates in is a side-effect. As I wrote in another comment when Gawker is sued for publishing some private info about an American you’re not expecting Gawker to censor itself in the US only.
- tponestarter 11y ago> The law doesn’t apply globally: it allows a French citizen to ask Google to have their info removed. Period. It doesn’t allow US people to do the same. That this info is hidden in all countries Google operates in is a side-effect. Currently the info is only hidden if Google thinks that you are searching from within Europe.
- jrock08 11y agoGawker could chose to relocate it's business outside the US, but as long as they are a US corporation, they are bound by US laws and rulings handed down by US courts. Furthermore, defamation laws for publishing content are very different than the right to be forgotten laws which apply to indexing content. No one is arguing that the content is defamation, since it is true and reasonable, the argument is that the content is no longer relevant to a person's character (eg shoplifting arrest as a teenager that made local news).
- hk__2 11y agoFair point; the Gawker analogy doesn’t work here.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoBear in mind, the way Google applied the law 'only in France' originally was to delist the search result in google.fr, but French citizens could simply go to google.com and the results would be there. So Google was not complying with French law, even in France. Apparently, they've since taken the step of adding country detection, regardless of which domain you go to, to ensure RTBF is applied based on where you're browsing from. However, the extended point, is that France has granted those individuals certain rights. It's in France's citizens' best interests for France to protect their citizens' rights globally. Note that if an American is incarcerated for a violation of another country's laws, the US will often actually intervene and try to negotiate for their release. Your country is protecting your rights (as your country defines them) even when you're outside of their borders.
- _rpd 11y agoGoogle has already complied in France - google.fr has been censored. The issue is whether a French court can require global censorship of the information.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jim-greer 11y agoNot only that, it has made it so that French users are only able to use Google.fr. Until a few weeks ago they could use Google.com as well. Now they would need to use VPN to do that.
- schoen 11y ago> So if you're going to start arguing that the US's 1st amendment should apply in France then I'm going to argue that the US's 4th amendment should too! I would support that; while that's not a universal position among American civil libertarians, it's not particularly unheard of.
- kyrra 11y ago> "it is unacceptable to monitor Americans, but fine to spy on foreigners!" Btw, the US isn't the only country that does this. Spying on foreign countries is something most other countries try to do as well. France is doing the same thing[0][1]. [0] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/04/france-electronic-spying-operation-nsa http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/04/france-electron... [1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/09/frances-government-aims-give-itself-and-nsa-carte-blanche-spy-world https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/09/frances-government-aim...
- hk__2 11y agoAll countries do that; but only in the US people think it’s ok.
- jrock08 11y agoI'll copy-paste my reply to every comment you make, since you seem to really like making this non argument. Gawker could chose to relocate it's business outside the US, but as long as they are a US corporation, they are bound by US laws and rulings handed down by US courts. Furthermore, defamation laws for publishing content are very different than the right to be forgotten laws which apply to indexing content. No one is arguing that the content is defamation, since it is true and reasonable, the argument is that the content is no longer relevant to a person's character (eg shoplifting arrest as a teenager that made local news).
- hk__2 11y agoMy comment was clarifying OP’s. Their point wasn’t that the US spy on everyone but that they think it’s acceptable.
- mineshaftgap 11y agoEurope always doubles down on stupid, but they are in no position to dictate what happens in the US.
- linkregister 11y ago> Americans routinely say (paraphrasing) "it is unacceptable to monitor Americans, but fine to spy on foreigners!" I think you'll find that this viewpoint isn't routinely said on this American internet forum. The prevailing opinion here is that dragnet surveillance in general is bad and should not be practiced by the U.S. government. Not to mention, France (among many others) routinely conducts digital surveillance, including industrial espionage, against American and EU citizens.
- jim-greer 11y agoDo you think a customer service representative at Google should be the one making this decision? Seems like it should be a French official. There are hundreds of thousands to deal with though. And over half are invalid (examples include public officials delisting articles critical of them, etc)
- jim-greer 11y agoShould Iranian internet restrictions apply in France? Chinese? If not, what's the distinction?