6 ms·
Obama Has Gotten 3,000+ Tweets about Encryption. Let’s Double That
- terravion 11y ago3001!
- deciplex 11y agoHow many of them has he read, though? And, how many of them does he need to read / receive to change his administration's posturing on this? (My guess: 0 and ∞)
- prestonbriggs 11y agoTweets, schmeets. He can ignore 'em all the doo-dah day. Send him a letter.
- aarongolliver 11y agoAfter you do that you can also leave a message at White House comment line, 202-456-1111.
- odinduty 11y agoDo you honestly think he's going to read any of them? I can't imagine him scrolling through his notifications feed, but hey, who knows what he does when he's sitting on the toilet :P
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoDoubtful he has that kind of time but he has staff who will. And if he has any integrity, he will at least take people's concerns into consideration.
- privong 11y ago> Doubtful he has that kind of time but he has staff who will. And if he has any integrity, he will at least take people's concerns into consideration. If he's not reading them himself (I agree with you that he probably isn't) he likely only hears what his staffers tell him, so he might not even be aware of some people's concerns.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- afarrell 11y agoRather than sending a message to a president who no longer has any elections left and has less than a year in office, wouldn't it make more sense to look up your legislators[1] and write letters to them? 1/3rd of US senators and all representatives have an election coming up. They care more about voters than they do about Apple's $38 Billion[2] in liquid assets, so they need to be convinced that votes are on the side of sound security. [1] http://openstates.org/find_your_legislator/ http://openstates.org/find_your_legislator/ [2] https://ycharts.com/companies/AAPL/cash_on_hand https://ycharts.com/companies/AAPL/cash_on_hand
- cft 11y agoMany of the senators have de facto lifetime terms. One can argue that writing to them makes even less sense.
- jrcii 11y agoIt could be argued that the power of lame duck presidents cuts both ways since they can act with less fear of reprisal. You may still be right about prioritizing congress. Related, I once read an AMA on Reddit where a congressional staffer advised everyone to do their best to get op-ed pieces in newspapers which mention your elected officials, since it was their job and the job of the staffers they knew to compile such pieces for review every morning by the legislator.
- kiddico 11y agohere is said reddit post: https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1os8rz/ https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1os8rz/
- tn13 11y agoAgree. How about creating "Digital Civil Liberties" rating for every politician ?
- afarrell 11y agoSure, but at this point isn't it about security infrastructure? As long as we frame it as Liberty vs Security, then there will be people who disagree and the side with the stronger emotional salience will win. The response to "if you have nothing to hide etc." Should be "What is the password to your bank account?", not a more abstract philosophical argument.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoI don't encrypt because I have something to hide. I encrypt because I don't want anyone to tell me I can't hide anything.
- WillAbides 11y agoMe too. Also, I have terribly embarrassing secrets.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoAsk HN: A very genuine question. How do you propose we keep an eye on those who mean to physically harm others? How would you solve this?
- blakesterz 11y agoSometimes there's just not a good answer to problems. The rhetoric on the anti-encryption side is "We need to be able to break encryption because if we can't then bad guys will do bad things with it". This is true. There is no way to make it so only good people can do only good things with it. It's either secure/unbreakable or it is not. There's no middle ground that won't lead to it being worthless.
- deciplex 11y agoWell for one thing we could open up all the secret courts that these people use to do what they do with no accountability. Oh wait, were you talking about "terrorists", or government agents? It's not clear.
- rrggrr 11y agoTerrorism kills fewer people than almost every hazard Americans face. Cancer, auto accidents, drug resistant bacteria, and hundreds of other risks are how 99.5% of Americans will die. So, for the minuscule risk that terrorism presents we've spent billions, give up privacy and consider ever more extreme measures? How about instead we instead acknowledge the risks are small to Americans, and refocus our attention, our lethal attention, to the clerics, organizations, bankers and states that sponsor terrorism. Let's talk giving up civil liberties after we have run out of accountable parties to bring to justice.
- lemming 11y agoMaybe there is no solution to this problem. I have yet to be convinced that surveillance has been effective at all at combatting terrorism, and even if it's been occasionally effective its ROI is terrible. Our various societies are generally willing to accept certain tradeoffs because there are no black and white answers. In the US, society as a whole is currently willing to accept a relatively enormous amount of collateral damage to allow widespread gun ownership. This causes multiple orders of magnitude more deaths than terrorism, and yet for now, it's deemed acceptable to protect certain liberties. If encryption is allowed to be truly secure, it's possible that more people will die in terrorist attacks. It's also possible that more people will get away with truly terrible things like child pornography. But the freedoms that we give away generally never come back, or they take an enormous amount of time to come back. For me, maintaining those liberties is worth the tradeoff.
- spoiledtechie 11y agoIts interesting that such a vocal West Coast crowd votes for Obama, when in fact he has been one of the worst presidents in recent history on use of privacy and security. Im curious to know why people still follow a person with such a horrible record on the constitution, when he studied in great detail.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWith Obama's recent actions regarding privacy and encryption, I'm terribly glad I didn't go to work for the US Digital Service.
- studentrob 11y agoIt's not like the President understands that encryption is ungovernable and is pursuing a fruitless path on purpose. He just doesn't get it. We should be begging smart people to get in the White House and help relate the facts to him. The current CTO Megan Smith is there calling for more people to join. She says the discussion about encryption is "ongoing". She's obviously outnumbered. Tech does not have proper representation in the White House.
- spoiledtechie 11y agoStop giving the president just another excuse to give him another out. He has plenty of smart people around him, yet he still insists on government over privacy.
- studentrob 11y agoIt's not an excuse, he's a lousy guy for not giving tech staff his sincere attention. My point is, nobody has broken through to him yet. It's his fault, but that doesn't mean we should stop trying. We all bear the results of what he says publicly.
- jaredklewis 11y agoNo great mystery really: voters choose among the options they have. There are very few pro-privacy US politicians (such as Rand Paul), and they are most certainly not on the presidential ticket.
- studentrob 11y agoThe EFF is fighting the fight we all should be fighting. In my opinion their letters are too forceful and not understanding of how difficult it is to enforce the law and bring justice to victims. For example, they write > We call on the Obama Administration to heed the advice of neutral security experts, engineers, and even his own advisors who have affirmed the dangers inherent in the order issued to Apple There's no need for Obama to change his mind here simply because experts say so. In fact, if properly explained, he could understand himself that software is ungovernable. Encryption technology is just words on paper. Print out an encryption program and send it to your representatives. Let them see how anyone can create it for free. Let's educate our representatives. Enough with this idea that they need to be beaten over the head with a stick. They believe they are doing the job protecting public safety and the constitution. Once you give them that benefit of the doubt, then we will be able to move forward.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoHe doesn't need to "govern" all of software. He just wants to control the dominant platforms, so some percentage of law enforcement efforts can get a little traction there. The fact that a percentage of criminals will use encryption anyway is unavoidable they're not trying to stop that.
- studentrob 11y agoHe has not said that, nor has any representative or DOJ official.
- studentrob 11y agoBy the way, the next meeting of the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) is on Friday, March 25, and will be shown live here [1] You can submit questions to them at PCAST@ostp.eop.gov . This might be another good place to direction questions about the President's understanding of encryption technology. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/administration/eop/ostp/pcast https://www.whitehouse.gov/administration/eop/ostp/pcast