4 ms·
It's hard for me to believe that the crew is the high-cost component in oceanic shipping. From what I've seen they're mostly from the Philippines and similar lo
by jessaustin 11y ago
It's hard for me to believe that the crew is the high-cost component in oceanic shipping. From what I've seen they're mostly from the Philippines and similar low-wage nations. Besides, getting rid of them isn't just a question of steering and throttling. Most of the crew is engaged in maintenance for most of the journey. Are the nerds on the holodeck somehow managing that as well?
- manicdee 11y agoHow much maintenance is required at sea due to attempts at stretching out maintenance normally performed in dock? If you can remove the crew cost, does that free up enough capital to perform regular maintenance of various elements to reduce failures at sea? You are then left with losses due to structural damage at sea, which then disappears in the accounting books as self-insurable. If a ship takes a few extra days to get to destination because it was sailing around storms, there is no incremental cost beyond fuel (and if using wind/solar, the fuel cost disappears too).
- jessaustin 11y agoI have to read that in my internal naive MBA's voice. After enough "optimization", one is left picking up pennies in front of the steamroller. Many things can go wrong at sea. Many of those things will send one's ship and all cargo aboard to the depths. Insurers will not embrace the technology TFA describes.
- showerst 11y agoIs it cheaper to have an emergency maintenance team on call 24/7 in a few key locations and just fly them out when there's an issue, or do the events tend to happen too fast to save the ships from a few hours away?
- jessaustin 11y agoSome shipping routes pass through some fairly remote stretches of ocean. While it's true that few issues would require instant attention, just getting attention within twelve hours might be difficult. And now a widely-dispersed fleet of large seagoing helicopters and their support infrastructure is a link in the chain. Here I thought ship maintenance was a challenge! Perhaps the biggest problem is that when maintenance is really a priority, severe storms are likely to be involved. Flying into those in order to land personnel and equipment on a troubled ship in order to perform maintenance should not be a regular event in oceanic shipping. This sort of innovation might catch on for less remote routes first, however.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nradov 11y agoLol. Good luck landing a maintenance crew plus tools on a ship that's dead in the water in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. The available helicopters don't have enough range.
- protomyth 11y agoNo, but I submitted an article a bit earlier about the first drone delivery to a ship. It does occur to me that the same technology being developed for remote surgery could be developed for remote ship repair.
- nradov 11y agoDrones don't have any more range or cargo capacity than piloted helicopters so that's not going to solve anything. No one is going to risk sending a drone to land human technicians on a disabled ship. We are decades away from being able to build remotely operated repair robots that could begin to approach the capability and reliability of human technicians. Building a surgical robot that stays fixed in one operating room and moves a limited set of tools a few inches is orders of magnitude easier than building a robot that can roam around a huge ship and repair the hull, engine, electrical systems, painting, etc.
- protomyth 11y agoI would expect the droids on board to be built into the ship at strategic places. Since this whole automated thing won't happen for a bit, I would bet drones will improve and might just drop parts depending on the quality of the bots. If they build automated ships, I would expect they would be built to have automated repairs.
- JshWright 11y agoThe crew isn't just there to fix stuff that breaks. They're performing routine preventative maintenance constantly as the vessel is underway. That's in addition to performing inspections that would be difficult to do remotely, and training to handle emergencies that need to be dealt with _right now_ (you're not going to flying a response team out to a ship that has caught fire in the middle of the ocean... at least not if you expect to recover anything... that sort of thing needs to be dealt with by people on board).
- nbb 11y agoCrew cost is expense, not capital.
- jessaustin 11y agoWell-spotted, actually maintenance is as well.
- JshWright 11y ago> How much maintenance is required at sea due to attempts at stretching out maintenance normally performed in dock? I don't follow... How does removing the crew make it any more worthwhile to perform maintenance while in port? The issue with trying to handle all maintenance when the ship is "parked" is that the ship only makes money when it is working. By performing routine maintenance while the ship is under way, the owner reduces their opportunity cost pretty substantially (far more than they would save by getting rid of the crew). Additionally, "a few extra days" can represent hundreds of thousands of dollars for a large container ship. The economics of container shipping depends very much on getting from point A to point B as quickly as possible, and then spending as little time at point B as you can, before continuing on to point C, and so on. A ship sitting around in port is an expensive hole in the water.
- didgeoridoo 11y agoPerhaps it's not about direct crew costs, but the additional security needed to keep an onboard crew safe[0]? Without humans aboard, hijacking may become far less of a risk, since the ship doesn't need to be human-pilotable at all. With that resistance to hijacking, not to mention the fact that no crew lives would be at stake in a piracy event, the shippers may be able to pay less for insurance and security services. [0]: http://www.theigc.org/project/the-economic-costs-of-piracy/ http://www.theigc.org/project/the-economic-costs-of-piracy/
- nradov 11y agoThat's not much of a factor. Piracy is only a risk in 3 regions right now, and even there the risk is low.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- superuser2 11y agoI'd guess that the marginal efficiency of cutting a few crew positions isn't much, but no longer needing to support human life at sea would seem to cut significant overhead. As soon as you need one person for a mission-critical task at sea, you need a bunch of other stuff (including people) on the ship just to support him. A medic, a cook, food, water, shower, toilet, transportation (the ship's boats), maintenance on all of the above, etc. It doesn't have to be the high-cost component to be worth automating. Seems like you could program a route by satellite without too much difficulty and just watch telemetry from there. If something goes really wrong, just have the ship sit in the water until a roving maintenance crew arrives. Unlike flight or driving there is a pretty wide margin for error before safety consequences kick in (unless it's near shore).
- nradov 11y agoThat doesn't work in the real world. A disabled ship won't just obediently sit there like a broken-down truck on the side of a highway. A ship without power will drift with the current and crash into a reef, or simply break apart and sink when it gets caught in a storm and can't keep its bow into the weather. http://gcaptain.com/tag/el-faro/ http://gcaptain.com/tag/el-faro/
- superuser2 11y agoOkay, but how much of a difference does it make to fly a crew out to the ship only when needed vs. having the crew on board?
- nradov 11y agoThat wouldn't work either. Current helicopters lack the range to cover many Ocean shipping routes. And they can't safely land on a disabled ship in the middle of a severe storm.
- jessaustin 11y agoThis is the most sensible justification I've seen yet, but I note that for some time, ships have gotten larger and larger. To torture a metaphor, when all our eggs are in one basket, we want somebody watching the hen-house. It seems common that while small systems are designed for maintenance-free reliability, really big systems worth lots of money are designed to require occasional human intervention. Maybe the observation robot can't maneuver well enough to notice coolant leaking out of the oil pump (I'm not a maritime diesel mechanic, but let's imagine that these oil pumps get hot enough to require their own cooling systems), or maybe it's not equipped to tighten the relevant fitting. When the remote operator gets on the phone with the manufacturer to complain about having to shut down, they're not going to have much sympathy for her when she relates that there's no one on-board to turn a wrench. In the meantime, the shipper is paying pro-rated late fees while the ship floats in the Northern Pacific without an engine.
- steve19 11y agoThis would kill seafaring unions. Don't underestimate how appealing this is to shipping companies. Note: I am not arguing against seafaring unions, just explaining the reasoning of corporates (having worked in head office of a shipping company). They are not quite on the same level of stevedore unions, but they are immensely powerful and militant. The term "sea lawyer" [0], which predates unions, adequately describes them. They know their rights, are completely inflexible and prone to strike. Simply not having to think about union demands is enough to make a CEO salivate over autonomous ships. I like sailors, I especially like sea captains and know a few captains of huge container ships. I have major respect for them. But I completely understand why corporates would end seafaring unions is they have half the chance. [0] http://www.dictionary.com/browse/sea-lawyer http://www.dictionary.com/browse/sea-lawyer
- tarpherder 11y agoI think that it is too simplistic to think that all Rolls-Royce will do is replace the onboard crew with computers and an on-shore control center. Granted that I don't know anything about shipping I can see some areas that could change: - Not having a crew onboard means a ship can be underway any amount of time as long as it doesn't run out of fuel or misses cargo deadlines (I don't know but there's probably a good amount of stuff that is allowed to take a good while to arrive). - Not having a crew onboard means that the drawbacks for having many smaller ships is significantly less than it would be otherwise. - Not having a crew onboard means onboard maintenance either needs to be automated (not very likely to be possible) or it should no longer be needed. Perhaps smaller ships with replaceable parts or sufficient backup systems are low maintenance enough to only need servicing at ports. Usually running costs far outweigh the cost of materials so shifting the balance to having less of the former and more of the latter makes complete sense to me. Perhaps I'm missing key information but I can definitely see why Rolls-Royce would want to go in this direction. I see a lot of comments about what happens when something goes wrong with helicopters not being able to reach the ship if something happens. But I fail to see how that is different from the current situation with crew on board; surely they can't fix every problem that could occur. And in the event of an emergency the crew could require immediate evacuation which a drone would never need. Doesn't seem like a problem?