12 ms·
I tend to dislike systems of the form "if you make/own less than $X, you get $Y benefit". It often leads to nasty non-monotonic outcomes and like this. For ac
by amluto 11y ago
I tend to dislike systems of the form "if you make/own less than $X, you get $Y benefit". It often leads to nasty non-monotonic outcomes and like this.
For actual public benefits, I'd much prefer to give all the benefits to all the people and raise taxes accordingly. This means that, as a CA resident, I think I should be permitted to deduct rent even if my AGI is $38,259, and I think I should get the full Affordable Care Act subsidy regardless of my income. The rules would be simpler and my taxes would be simpler. In exchange, I would gladly pay higher taxes to make up the deficit.
For public university, it's a bit messier because of state residency rules. And for private universities, this wouldn't work at all unless the government directly subsidized private education.
(But maybe the government should ditch all the complicated student aid and student loan benefits and offer a blanket subsidy for education at accredited universities.)
- marcoperaza 11y agoThrowing more free money at universities will just make things worse.
- _delirium 11y agoThe universities I know of that have free-tuition programs do phase them out gradually, to try to avoid too much weirdness that would come from a hard threshold. For example, Harvard charges no tuition to students from households making under $65,000, but above $65,000 tuition phases in slowly, reaching full tuition only at $150,000+. However I do agree your proposed solution is better. Have universalist public programs that everyone can take advantage of regardless of income (tuition-free public university, no-charge public healthcare, etc.), and then instead of mucking with means-tested benefits and aid phase-outs as a way of indirectly taxing the rich, just tax them through actual taxes, the old-fashioned way.
- Domenic_S 11y ago> above $65,000 tuition phases in slowly, reaching full tuition only at $150,000+ Which is still silly. Who has more to spend/better opportunity to save? Two parents that make $75k each in Mountain View or 1 parent who makes $64,500 in Nowhere, Indiana?
- jimbokun 11y ago"I think I should get the full Affordable Care Act subsidy regardless of my income" I appreciate your sentiment, but you realize all of the insurance companies will just raise their rates by the amount of the subsidy, right? More demand in the form of government money earmarked for a specific good, with the same supply of the good, means higher prices.
- dangrossman 11y ago> you realize... right? Gosh, I really dislike that turn of phrase. Anyway, they can't do that, since the ACA has mandated that insurers spend at least 80 or 85% of premiums on health care costs since 2012. The insurers ride that line as closely as possible, since their profit has to come out of the 15% allowed margin. This means an increase in total premiums without a commensurate increase in the cost of claims cannot happen. If an insurer's payouts don't exceed the mandated Medical Loss Ratio, they have to refund their insured customers for the difference by mailing out rebate checks. I've received two such checks myself.
- koolba 11y ago> Anyway, they can't do that, since the ACA has mandated that insurers spend at least 80 or 85% of premiums on health care costs since 2012. That part of the law is particularly terrible. It directly incentivizes keeping costs high as the profit of the insurer is a fixed (says max but that means exactly 15%) percentage of the gross. It's in their interests to have the price of everything go up!
- Grishnakh 11y agoThe whole law is terrible and it should be repealed and replaced with a nationalized system. As long as you have the insurance companies acting as middlemen, it's in their best interest to deny care as much as possible, to increase their profit. What actual good do they do? None, they just come between the patient and the caregiver.
- 11y ago
- fovc 11y agoThere was an article recently where Finland was considering something along those lines. [1] is all I was able to find quickly: > The Finnish government, elected earlier this year, is planning to introduce a tax-free monthly payment of 800 euros ($865) to all adult Finns, regardless of income, wealth or employment status. The payment would replace most other state benefits. [1] http://money.cnn.com/2015/12/07/news/economy/finland-basic-income-800-euros/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/12/07/news/economy/finland-basic-i...