3 ms·
>a huge wealth and status divide between those born with high IQs and those born with normal IQs // Are you saying that's the primary reason for the status div
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
>a huge wealth and status divide between those born with high IQs and those born with normal IQs //
Are you saying that's the primary reason for the status divide? Any citations that support that, the most recent research I've seem looked at societal status/wealth of families a few generations back and then traced living descendants to find how stratified things were. They found a high degree of stratification; that across generations it was far less likely that poor ancestors had wealthy descendants. Perhaps IQ goes this way too?
>High IQ people commit less crimes //
Or get caught less often. Wealthy people (in the UK) often commit some common crimes at what seems like a far larger rate because the penalty is usually just a fine and to the wealthy it's pocket-change [speeding, parking offences, tax evasion ...].
- Moshe_Silnorin 11y ago>Perhaps IQ goes this way too? Yes. IQ is highly heritable. Gwern has a good page covering this research: http://www.gwern.net/iq http://www.gwern.net/iq As most people desire wealth and intelligent people are better at achieving their desires, wealthy people tend to have higher IQs on average than less-wealthy people. This has class implications as IQ is highly heritable. This isn't good or just; it's just the state of things. When I was young I was a blank slatist, but the world kept disappointing me. Marvin's razor:the most depressing explanation is likely be the truth. > Or get caught less often. I suppose smart criminals are less likely to get caught. Nice selection effect there, but I doubt it accounts for much of the difference.
- mikerichards 11y agoYou seriously think that high IQ people are committing as much crime as "whoever else", but get caught less often? Seriously? Obviously a high IQ person on average will have a better job/more money and therefore have less reason to commit crimes. You think average/below average IQ people are scared to jaywalk, illegally park because they're scared of the fine? Does your ideology really cloud your reasoning to that extent?
- jqm 11y agoThere are all kinds of criminals. Hi IQ adults probably don't (generally) shoplift $3 worth of beauty products nor hold up gas stations for $56. Bernie Madoff was probably pretty smart though don't you think? And there are no doubt plenty of others who are too smart to get caught, and if caught not prosecuted, and if prosecuted not convicted. I'm not convinced hi IQ people commit that much less crime. Just that they probably commit less petty crime.
- mikerichards 11y agoI think you're like the parent where your ideological persuasion clouds your judgement. The Bernie Madoff reference is obviously an indicator. Like a lot of leftists, you believe that many affluent people have gotten their money via illegal means.
- EdHominem 11y agoAnd a rightist is someone who believes only poor people commit crimes? But, no, unless this is a "reality has a well-known liberal bias" joke, it's plain objective fact that many (more than 2) affluent people have gotten their money illegally and not been punished as hard as a poor person would be for stealing food. A leftist would be someone who says that this is bad.
- jqm 11y agoExcept...... I'm not a leftist. Not sure how you got that from the post. I in no way think all affluent people got their money by illegal means nor did I even slightly imply that. But some affluent people did get their money by illegal means. Fact. Therefore the idea that rich people don't commit crime is false and the idea that they commit less crime is somewhat suspect.
- dang 11y agoWe've asked you before not to post personal attacks and ideological rants to HN. Please don't do this again.
- 11y ago