5 ms·
I hate the term 'computer science'. There's no science in computer science, as the article says, it's a branch of mathematics.
by jgrahamc 17y ago
I hate the term 'computer science'. There's no science in computer science, as the article says, it's a branch of mathematics.
- ugh 17y agoComputer science is called "Informatik" in German. (French: "Informatique", Russian: "Информатика")
- jgrahamc 17y agoTrue. When I lived in France it was l'informatique.
- sprachspiel 17y agoEven in England it used to be commonly called Informatics. I like Informatics/Informatik/Informatique etc. much better than "Computer Science", because most applications are not really about computing, but about information.
- jonsen 17y agoIn danish computer science is called "Datalogi" (Data-logy; data as a subject of study)
- silentbicycle 17y agoIn English, "information science" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_science http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_science) is usually more closely associated with classification and resource collection management, such as archival work and library cataloging. I like "informatics" though. It is used in "bioinformatics", at least.
- nopinsight 17y agoCertain parts of computer science (e.g. machine learning) qualify as experimental science.
- fec 17y agoIn the cases where there are no physical-world measurements, as with inputs and outputs to many machine learning problems, it is math. "Experiments" using randomized algorithms and measuring the results, themselves, certainly don't qualify as science.
- jerf 17y agoIn the twentieth century we learned that math is bigger than we can possibly handle with anything like traditional mathematical rigor. There is no contradiction in saying one is running an experiment on math when it is not possible even in theory to obtain the result of the experiment through any means more efficient than simply running the experiment. And given Computer Science's focus on things that are, generally, Turing Complete, proving that that is frequently the case is a sophomore-level homework problem in any decent curriculum. (See "Rice's Theorem".) The idea of "math" you get in school is not wrong, but very incomplete. "Experimental math" is a perfectly valid field of study; mathematics itself proved it, about a hundred years ago. Theories are made, predictions are given, and there's no way to prove or disprove them until the experiment is run, at which point you still only have evidence, not proof (in general); sounds pretty scientific to me.
- fec 17y agoComputer science is more similar to math than the physical sciences, if one of these two had to be chosen from.
- proemeth 17y agoMathematics would be regarded as a science. Though this seems open for debate : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability#Logic_and_mathematics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability#Logic_and_mathem...
- JeffJenkins 17y agoComputer science is a "formal science": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_science http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formal_science
- scott_s 17y agoThings that are "computer science" but I contend are not mathematics: programming language design and implementation, operating system design and implementation, computer architecture and networking. All of these things depend on math. But they go beyond the scope of math because they deal with the realities of designing and building systems for computation. Physics also relies on math, but I've never seen anyone make the reductionist statement "Physics is a branch of mathematics."
- nzmsv 17y agohttp://xkcd.com/435/ http://xkcd.com/435/
- cabalamat 17y ago> programming language design [...] All of these things depend on math. Really? I'm currently designing and implementing a programming language, and I haven't (consciously, at least) used any maths concepts more complex than arithmetic.
- scott_s 17y agoSome aspects of programming languages are very math heavy - things like type theory and lambda calculus. It's accurate to say some of the field of programming language design and implementation depends on math. Hence, I'm willing to say the field aggregate has that dependence, even if some other parts of the field do not have an explicit dependence.