3 ms·
>For example I have a deplorable sequential memory: I can't really well memorize songs or karate katas. I blame my total lack of musical and dance education. I
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
>For example I have a deplorable sequential memory: I can't really well memorize songs or karate katas. I blame my total lack of musical and dance education. I never really trained for memorizing sequences… Of course I could point to some innate genetic flaw, but this seems like a less likely explanation given what we know about the brain plasticity. //
I trained at piano for about 7 years and played for my own enjoyment for about 4 more (then moved from having a piano to play). I still can't keep a rhythm, still struggle immensely with recognising note progression.
My son has been in a choir for 2 years (he has a musical mother) - from the outset he could find the right pitch, match rhythms, keep tune with others, etc..
Other son, started with choir - he has no ability for tunes, lacks rhythm, etc..
They have a very similar upbringing, very similar schooling, we dance with them, sing, play tunes, have instruments for them to mess around with. One of the children resembles me in their musical ability; the other my wife. My mother had the same problems with musicality, her sister became a music teacher and played many instruments, my mother like me can't keep a tune or continue a beat.
Now I don't doubt that the second son can improve their ability, just as I have; but like me I expect them to be unable to shake off the lack of natural ability. Ultimately they're unlikely to make a career in music - but I do and will encourage them in it as it's been and continues to be an important part of my life.
This is just an example, I suspect it works in other fields too; certainly in other creative arts it seems to.
I consider that it matters very little in these instances whether the ability is entirely innate or whether it's down to certain brain areas being reserved, pathways being fixed to a certain task at an early age.
Aside: Occam's razor is a useful philosophical tool but it lacks any ability to demonstrate the truth in a situation. Much in the world works with more complexity than it appears to need. Look at physics which often progresses by discounting simpler explanations in favour of more complex ones (of course this hinges on the element of "necessary entities" in the razor which actually make the razor useless as one is required to answer as to the necessity of an entity; if you know an entity is unnecessary to establish a proper explanation then you don't need the razor to suggest it).