2 ms·
> what are the secure channels that don't require an uncompromised server and uncompromised client? I can't think of any. Assuming you trust your hardware: I c
by e12e 11y ago
> what are the secure channels that don't require an uncompromised server and uncompromised client? I can't think of any.
Assuming you trust your hardware: I could hand you a bootable CD.
In practice, there's a bootstrap problem: the general way is to trade the insecure CA system (will always be insecure, there are too many trusted parties, all the CAs) with a web of trust and/or widely distributed hash'es of ISO images/install files.
While surely your cd writer software theoretically could be backdoored so that it will compromise all bootable iso's (all bootloaders?) that contain a gpg executable - that is something quite different from having a rouge CA sign a cert, allowing the individual replacement of js code on a single connection.
Ultimately, one can only trust people, web-of-trust is an attempt at widening that network geographically with the help of technology. It's not perfect, but I think it's hard to argue that it's not better and more flexible than the CA system.
[ed: Note that getting an iso file over an insecure channel; bittorrent, ftp, http -- isn't a problem if you can verify a signature. Now, you still need to have a way to trust the signature (by way of well-known, trusted, cross-signed keys). But compromising the server and the transport now becomes a denial of service, not a compromise of the client. And again, yes there are some bootstrap issues here too.]