14 ms·
Illegal Math
- gaur 11y agoRelated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number > Any image file or an executable program can be regarded as simply a very large binary number. In certain jurisdictions, there are images that are illegal to possess, due to obscenity or secrecy/classified status, so the corresponding numbers could be illegal.
- pussinboots 11y agoI'm more of a fan of illegal primes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_prime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_prime
- bfstein 11y agoDisclaimer: I agree with the author on the encryption debate. However, it's a slippery slope to say that encryption can't be illegal because in is math, and math can't be illegal. It's equivalent to say that making bombs is chemistry, and chemistry can't be illegal. It's an oversimplification. Presenting the practical consequences of a backdoor produces a far more sound argument.
- venning 11y agoTo your point, bombs are not chemistry, bombs are the application of chemistry. Encryption is not math, encryption is the application of math.
- Johnny555 11y agoThe difference is that math is an abstract concept with no physical manifestation. I can encrypt something in my head, but I can't make a physical bomb in my head. Even when an encryption algorithm is implemented on a computer, it's still not a physical object, it's just a mathematical algorithm. A computer simulation of explosive chemical reaction is not going to get you arrested, why should an encryption algorithm?
- techdragon 11y agoA computer simulation of a nuclear explosion could be considered illegal to possess under the "Born Secret" doctrine applied by the US government, depending on the circumstances.
- joeyo 11y agoThe math-cannot-be-illegal argument gets more difficult when you consider that the digital representations of files are just really long numbers: Copyright infringement is making a copy of a (really secret) number. Possession of child pornography is the possession of a (really bad) number. etc. I think the banning of encryption or forcing encryption products to have government backdoors would be horrifically bad policies, I don't think there is anything in our current legal framework that prevents it.
- marcosdumay 11y agoHum, no, math and chemistry are simply different on that. Math can not harm anybody because math isn't real, it's speech (yes, maybe except for psychological harm). Chemistry is quite real. Anyway, I don't see merit on the author's argument. It's true, but useless. The discussion is about protected speech and evidence gathering, nobody is claiming cryptography directly harms people.
- theandrewbailey 11y agoI can assure you that math is most certainly real. Just because you can't hit a head with it doesn't mean something isn't real.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- RockyMcNuts 11y agoSeems a little like saying, you burn some gas and your car goes, and if it goes 80mph, that's just physics. You can't make it illegal to obey the laws of physics? Plants are just biology and burning things is just chemistry. You can't make it illegal for a plant to grow and for a human burn it and inhale it, can you? Well...if you pass a law that pi=3 it doesn't change the nature of the universe, but it does regulate human transactions, and human behavior can be and sure is regulated using some strange laws.
- dingusoo 11y agoIt's more like saying if you draw a picture of a car going 80mph, that's just a drawing. Doing physics or chemistry can directly harm people. Doing math or drawing pictures can't.
- programmer_dude 11y ago>Doing physics or chemistry can directly harm people. Doing math or drawing pictures can't. Like the article said analogies are no fun. I agree with your premise but not with your conclusion. You will perhaps agree that encryption has the potential to directly harm people just as physics or chemistry?
- CamperBob2 11y agoDoing physics or chemistry can directly harm people. Doing math or drawing pictures can't. This argument might have worked, up until the point when they criminalized cartoon child pornography. You will perhaps agree that encryption has the potential to directly harm people just as physics or chemistry? No.
- nekopa 11y agoFrom what I remember, the child pon drawing law was about people taking child pon photography, and running it through a Photoshop filter to make it look like a drawing. That way people were trying to get around the law. Also, it was trivial to return the 'drawing' back into a photo by reversing the filter.
- kawsper 11y agoPoul-Henning Kamp (bsdphk) known from FreeBSD and Varnish, have speculated that the future will bring certification for using cryptography, where decryption keys will need be placed on government servers. He says that to avoid this to happen the citizens need to demand access to strong cryptography. [0] He writes about it here (danish to english): https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=da&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.version2.dk%2Fblog%2Fagent-0x007-med-licens-til-pgp-571048&edit-text= https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=da&tl=en&js=y&prev...
- c_c_c 11y agoThe future may not be now but it is near.
- dingusoo 11y agoIf this were ever to happen, the only people using secure (deniable) cryptography would be be the bad actors. Everyone else would be screwed.
- ajmurmann 11y agoYou and I understand that, but how many politicians understand that? We constantly ban stuff that's futile to ban and make things worse I the process.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agogovernment on all levels is corrupt. buy guns and do something about it, pussies. you nerds are pathetic.
- aresant 11y agoI enjoyed the article's major theme of encryption as math - but the dedication of the second & third paragraphs to disparaging analogies was distracting. Educating HN and SV on this topic is throwing so many logs on the fire - I literally haven't met anybody in tech that doesn't strongly support Apple / encryption. On the other hand analogies - like "locks, doors, and burritos" - are the only chance we have to sway the POPULAR opinion in this country which currently sits 52% in favor of handing the govt the keys. (2) And Donald Trump has recently shown with great effect what speaking like / explaining thing simply (at a 3rd grade level in fact) can do to reach Americans. (3) And, as for "Illegal Math" in general, unfortunately there's prior art in this department as well ;-) (4) (5) (1) http://www.people-press.org/files/2016/02/2-22-2016-iPhone-release.pdf http://www.people-press.org/files/2016/02/2-22-2016-iPhone-r... (2) http://www.people-press.org/files/2016/02/2-22-2016-iPhone-release.pdf http://www.people-press.org/files/2016/02/2-22-2016-iPhone-r... (3) http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/08/donald-trump-talks-like-a-third-grader-121340 http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/08/donald-trump-... (4) http://everything2.com/title/Copyrighting%2520a%2520number http://everything2.com/title/Copyrighting%2520a%2520number (5) http://mathbric.blogspot.com/2009/01/just-how-small-is-smallest-illegal_05.html http://mathbric.blogspot.com/2009/01/just-how-small-is-small...
- kenningrmd 11y agoSerious question: Even if a government makes encryption illegal, if I have the source code to gpg then I can still encrypt anything I want right? In other words, even if we lose secure access via SSL because of a master cipher, nobody can make the gpg source code, for example, disappear entirely.
- kelnos 11y agoSure, but that same government can jail you for using it, or jail you for refusing to turn over the passphrase to your encryption key.
- Lexarius 11y agoThe government also can't stop you from robbing your neighbor, but that's not how laws work. Laws are about punishing you after the fact. If they catch you, of course.
- natch 11y agoBuried in the article below the clever though not original point that encryption is not math, is a much more important point: This debate should really be about whether or not people have the right to have secrets. If your answer is "no" then you ought to explain how you square that with the fact that many of our everyday activities can be considered criminal in some jurisdictions.
- tptacek 11y agoI understand where the sentiment is coming from, but the point you are making here is incoherent. Your argument is literally this: people need encryption so that they can conceal evidence of crimes. I think next time you pose this argument, you should remove the bit about how your actions might be illegal in some jurisdiction or other. It isn't doing the work for you that you think it is.
- chm 11y agoI perceived his point as more subtle than what you make it out to be. The whole debate is about what's grey vs what's gray. I don't think there's a clear cut answer either way to the question "Is encryption an inviolable right?" The exercise here is to try and find a border between gray and grey, preferably avoiding any knee-jerk reaction such as backdooring every encryption scheme. Note that I'm assuming such a border exists, which is, to be honest, not on such solid ground. It might very well be that this is an "all or nothing" deal, considering the nature of encryption...
- Zigurd 11y agoEncryption is part of reality, like gravity. We can say "government agents have been able to vault fences for hundreds of years." So fences should only be four feet high, so they can't conceal crimes or prevent entry? Government is limited by reality, math, physics, the height of walls, the fact that telepathy isn't a thing, etc. Encryption is just one more limitation.
- natch 11y agoUgh, I have a bad typo in the first line, and unfortunately can no longer edit: "not math" should have been "just math." But that doesn't seem to be what you're remarking on. I'm not sure what you see as the problem with my argument. Some people, if private messages were read by people around them or by their local law enforcement, could be sentenced to death, in certain jurisdictions. For "crimes" like being Christian, Muslim, atheist, Gay, etc. How is that a good thing? How is it a bad thing that people want to protect themselves with encryption? Or if you're saying you get the argument and I'm just doing a bad job of making it, yes, maybe so, but maybe it's a hard side of the argument to take. Any suggestions on how to put it better? Or maybe you're saying it's entirely the wrong argument to make, tactically. I'm still not sure why. Having not heard a reason for not making this argument, I think it's good to make it because it seems to be discussed too little.
- slg 11y ago>Various government agencies are crooning that they should be able to knock down whichever doors they please because they're the government. I think this analogy is apt but it actually works against the author's point. Our government has legally been allowed to knock down whichever door it has wanted to for centuries assuming it has received the proper warrants. An encryption door cannot be knocked down. That is a very scary problem for the government and law enforcement. Things like personal notes, journals, communications all used to be accessible to the government through warrants. Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. This is a huge shift in the way governments fight crime. We need to recognize that fact in order to have any productive debate with anti-encryption folks and we can't just pretend the government is evil because they wanted to keep the status quo of the physical world alive into the digital era.
- x5n1 11y agoNot true. You can jail the person for not revealing passwords if you have enough evidence and reasons to suspect the person is guilty and is hiding evidence behind encryption. This is not about being able to access something. This is about the ability to illegally search and seize all information at all times, often without any warrant at all. The government is worried not about not being able to search it, it's grasping for more totalitarian control of people's thoughts and behaviors. I guess because it's scared of what people are capable of.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Things like personal notes, journals, communications all used to be accessible to the government through warrants. Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. The government already has plenty of ways to collect evidence through legal means. A judge can compel you to provide access to your company files, to unlock your home, to decrypt your computer, etc. If you don't comply with the discovery process, you can be held in contempt of court. Encryption doesn't change anything in that equation. The difference here is that the person in question is dead, so he can't provide the password. So the FBI wants to set a precedent that they can obtain information they want through means that would normally not be available to them.
- tlrobinson 11y agoYou can say things like "math cannot be illegal" all you want, but the people with the guns and jails ultimately decide what's "illegal". (To be clear, I am absolutely not in favor of putting any sort of restrictions on the use of encryption)
- munin 11y agobad news, some math is already illegal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_secret https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_secret
- mirimir 11y agoWell, encryption is already effectively illegal in the UK. Using unauthorized VPNs is illegal in Saudi Arabia. And Iran, I believe. Tor and VPNs are effectively illegal in China, although mostly they just block access. So it will be interesting to see where the US goes on this. The lines are being drawn.
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoThis is sort of how I have always felt about the idea of "legal or exportable levels of encryption." It seems a very strange thing. However, even though we may be right that it lacks sense, I don't think the government is moved by such an argument.
- jimworm 11y agoOne of the problems with outlawing encryption is that it takes nothing to prove the crime, and therefore it is impossible to prove one's innocence. Would it be possible to outlaw the possession or transfer of data that appears random? Nearly all data is random data, and nearly all processes randomize data. All data could be "proven" to contain information under at least one encryption scheme. It is the ultimate guilty until proven innocent argument. If your credit card were erased with a magnet, could you now be prosecuted for the possession of encrypted data, because it could be proven that using a certain one-time pad it could be transformed into something meaningful to humans? It doesn't end there. All things could be interpreted as information. We would have to start explaining the arrangement of books on a shelf, of spices in a rack, colours of stitching in clothing. If encryption were illegal, we would all be guilty all the time. Fine, some would argue that random data isn't proof of guilt. What about the means of encryption? Now all random data are one-time pad keys. Prepare to rot in jail.
- CJefferson 11y agoExcept, the law is about "reasonable doubt", and has been dealing with this kind of thing for hundreds of years. This isn't new magic. By a similar argument, any phrase someone says to someone else might have been code for "kill that guy". Except usually it's not, and unless there is convincing evidence you did mean to kill that guy, you'll be set free. Conversely, if you have previously agreed a code where "2+2=4" means "kill that guy", and then you say "2+2=4", you can't argue in court that "Oh, I was just saying a true statement of maths, how could that possibly be illegal?"
- jimworm 11y agoYou're talking about reasonable doubt on an order to murder, I'm talking about reasonable doubt on the possession of encrypted data. Strongly encrypted data looks random and the only way to tell the difference is to have the decryption key. So is withholding the key sufficient for reasonable doubt? If it is, the law is useless; if it isn't, any random data is evidence of guilt.
- 11y ago
- bcook 11y agoI equate encryption (right to privacy) with free-speech. I could babble about the similarities, but smarter, better educated minds have already done that.
- shirro 11y agoMostly the maths just enables easy key distribution and makes encryption viable for commerce and privacy. I don't see the public benefit in restricting this. It seems more targeted at ordinary citizens than criminals or foreign powers. If all you want to do is bring down the government then you can distribute one time pads on microsd cards and there is not much legislation can do to stop that. Any governments planning to ban xor?
- sphilipakis 11y agoIllegal Numbers - Numberphile https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wo19Y4tw0l8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wo19Y4tw0l8
- Taniwha 11y agoDid the US supreme court (in 1877) not find?: "No law of Congress can place in the hands of officials connected with the Postal Service any authority to invade the secrecy of letters and such sealed packages in the mail; and all regulations adopted as to mail matter of this kind must be in subordination to the great principle embodied in the fourth amendment of the Constitution." (Ex parte Jackson, 96 U.S. 727, 733 (1877)) Why does this not also apply to newly invented forms of communication
- samatman 11y agoAny time the "math cannot be illegal" argument is raised, it's time for a re-reading of "What colour are your bits?": http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- milesftl 11y agoi have never seen this article, thanks for reposting it. This articulated a bunch of things I have a very difficult time explaining to other non cs people. very well put.
- mehwoot 11y agoVarious government agencies are crooning that they should be able to knock down whichever doors they please because they're the government. Not really a sound argument but… they're the government after all. Various government agencies are crooning that they should be able to knock down whichever doors they please because the interests of being able to have somebody find out what people are doing under certain scenarios is preferable to never being able to do it. The fact you misrepresent the argument as simply "because they're the government" means you either don't understand the opposing side or you're willfully misrepresenting them. In either case, why would anyone who doesn't already agree with you take what you said seriously?
- thetruthseeker1 11y agoEven though the contents of iPhone is encrypted, the government agencies have been able to get that out of iCloud with the help of Apple in the past. So it is not entirely true that the whole encrypted content is off limits in all cases. May be that is all that is needed. And may be we shouldn't need to do anything more which I think is a valid argument. However, lets also not paint the ones who request such a feature as "morons"
- pfarnsworth 11y agoThe more things change... This is a similar debate we had 20 years ago, when people were fighting against the government who wanted to limit encryption to 56-bit DES. Stronger algorithms were not allowed (and then they acquiesced and allowed stronger keys to be used within the US only, unless you applied for special licenses). But you could print out the same encryption algorithms as a book or even a t-shirt and it would be totally legal and exportable. The government was saying that they were protecting us, but really it did nothing. It was ridiculous and we had a few years of relative peace on the encryption front until this whole faux-terrorist debacle.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hahagavkdr 11y agoClearly the writer is not a mathematician. It is easy to see that math can be illegal. It is enough to consider the obvious example of encryption in violation of various export laws and we are done.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoAnalogies are stupid. It's perfectly constitutional for a law to be passed to ban encryption. It'd be a stupid, terrible law with horrific consequences. But there's nothing unconstitutional about bad laws. We have more than a few as is.
- banku_brougham 11y agoWhat happens if the government succeeds? When manufacturers and software shops are required to leave keys for the FBI, NSA, etc for all encrypted storage and communication, what will happen to our technological world? Has anyone written about the probable unintended consequences? I think it could happen and I am concerned.
- antxxxx 11y agoWhitfield Diffie and Martin Hellman did not invent public-private-key-encryption. It was invented in secret by mathematicians working at GCHQ before Diffie and Hellman but not publicly acknowledged until 1997 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_H._Ellis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_H._Ellis
- krylon 11y agoWell, technically yes. But a) the invention of asymmetric encryption at GHCQ was kept secret, so Diffie and Hellman did not know about it; they invented it independently, it happens from time to time. And b) AFAIK, GHCQ did not develop asymmetric encryption into anything practically usable, they did come up with the basic concept, but stopped there (again: AFAIK - I am happy to be corrected if I have been misinformed there).
- antxxxx 11y agoWhitfield Diffie and Martin Hellman did not invent public-private-key-encryption. It was invented in secret by mathematicians working at GCHQ before Diffie and Hellman but not publicly acknowledged until 1997 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_H._Ellis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_H._Ellis
- lr4444lr 11y ago"Encryption is math. Math cannot be illegal." I wouldn't go so far as to say that the author made no interest points, but statements like this are a perfect example of that STEM worker arrogance stemming from the logical fallacy that just because you control systems which masses of people don't understand but rely on heavily (and make good money doing it in a secure comfortable job), that you have adequate knowledge to make sweeping statements in other areas outside of engineering knowledge. It isn't the math, but the activity of _applying_ that math in actual communications which is subject to legal statutes and regulation, which I don't pretend to be an expert on, but know enough of my own ignorance about the theory and practice of the law (and having a number of attorneys in the family to check my own tendency toward that aforementioned arrogance) to understand that it isn't a simple freedom of expression or open knowledge issue.
- awinter-py 11y agoEverything is math. Specific example: chemistry is physics & physics is math. Should all chemical processes be protected on these grounds? I agree with your conclusion that we should let people secure their own information, but not because the process of securing information is an algorithm derived from math research.