7 ms·
"The company has raised more than $900 million to date from Amazon, J.P. Morgan and Lightspeed Venture Partners." That's the biggest red flag for me. General
by jedberg 11y ago
"The company has raised more than $900 million to date from Amazon, J.P. Morgan and Lightspeed Venture Partners."
That's the biggest red flag for me. General rule of thumb is that your VCs won't approve an exit unless it's for at least 10x the funding you've taken, which means they need a minimum exit of about 10 billion.
That's a tough spot to be in, and really changes your thinking. I know of at least one company that had an exit opportunity but it was only 2x funding, so the investors wouldn't allow it. They then slogged along for 8 more years until they finally had an exit that was 0.2x and it all went to the series A investors with their preference. Founders got nothing, angels got nothing, employees got nothing, and series B and beyond (the ones who blocked the 2x exit) got nothing.
Edit to clarify: I'm not saying the VCs are doing anything wrong here or being irrational or anything like that. I'm saying as a founder you need to watch out for this because the VC has a diversified portfolio and the founder doesn't.
- pc86 11y agoA bird in the hand and all that. Surely the VCs have the data on how often they get burned by blocking a profitable exit. How often do they block a 2x return and later get 10x? Is it really enough the compensate for the (sure more common) result of getting 0.2x or 0?
- jedberg 11y agoThere may not have been enough situations to give good data, but even if there were, my point was that it changes the thinking of the company leaders, who are now forced to "swing for the fences", which is great for the VCs with their diversified portfolios, but not so great for the founders who have all their eggs in one basket (who admittedly put themselves in this situation). To be clear, I'm not talking badly about the VCs, I think they are making the right decision for their situation. I'm saying it's a bad place for the founders to be.
- jmount 11y agoDon't know the details of LivingSocial, but in general liquidation preferences can complicate it. Instead of 1x or 2x return for all investors it is often 5x for the last investor and 0x for the rest. So it not all investors have a reason vote "yes" at a given total.
- acdha 11y agoIt's important for founders and employees to appreciate how often that happens – a VC might have a dozen bets going but everyone else is committing their future to just one. A great deal of casual conversation treats investment as unambiguously good rather than a real risk to be balanced.
- sawthat 11y agoI worked at a .com era startup that went through something similar. Biggish acquisition offers came in circa 2001, but much smaller than the theoretical enterprise value if the product worked out. Company finally sold in 2005, preferred shareholders got everything but still lost money. Founders got nothing, employees got nothing. But everyone got to keep their jobs which was better than just going out of business. This seems to happen pretty often. Also common is founders turning down acquisitions because they are sure they can make more if they keep at it. You wouldn't start a company if you didn't believe it.
- x0x0 11y agoI "lost" well over a half million dollars because founders turned down a $50-$60mm acquisition offer to try to hit a home run. The problem was the ceo had been previously acquired and left before he fully vested in order to start the company I worked at, and had walked away from $5m in the process. (Which is crazy, right? That's a $5m bird in hand if he just didn't get fired for 2 years.) Anyway, he was really attached to the idea of building a company worth $300m plus so instead he built a company worth a handful of millions. It was pretty damn frustrating for me.
- mahyarm 11y agoThere are so many of these stories of wealthy founders turning down bird in the hand offers and then losing it all X years later even though the company got 'big'. I too got burned by one myself. I advise friends now to avoid those companies as employees, because an exit that would be very good for you might be turned down by wealthy founders. Joining a startup with a wealthy founder means they will go huge or bust, and nothing in between. Great if you want to do that yourself, but you usually want to be wealthy already.
- nedwin 11y agoWhich is kind of funny advice since essentially you're suggesting to avoid working for companies with successful founders.
- georgeecollins 11y agoYou are assuming this is just a profit maximization problem for the VC firm. There is also a reputation problem for the people that are involved in a suboptimal exit. They may be motivated to kick the can down the road to avoid acknowledging an underperforming investment.
- tosseraccount 11y agoMaximizing profit is a good reputation to have in business.
- rdl 11y agoThe main reason not to block deals is that 1) this should not be a single-round game for VCs 2) people talk. If you block an exit in a way which angers founders/employees, even if you have a higher expected return on that particular deal in doing that, you're now going to be "that fucking asshole VC who blocked our sale" every day until the company gets a 100x return above what the deal would have been (which is probably...never). Not only will the founders hate you forever (both your firm and you personally, the partner); employees of that firm will hate you, and anyone those founders/employees talk to. Also earlier-stage investors/angels in the deal will also likely hate you for being "that asshole late stage investor who tanked our deal." As a professional investor managing a large pool of other people's money, you probably have the greatest risk tolerance and most diversification of anyone involved in the deal. For employees, founders, and even angel investors, even a 2-5x exit, if it's the best/most likely thing, is probably going to be life-changing in a positive way.
- jonesb6 11y agoPeople do not bite the hand that feeds. How many stories have you read where the VCs get lambasted by founders and employees? Not many right? Remember it's a two way street. Sure maybe there is some incentive for VCs not to be ass holes. But there is equal incentive for founders (many of whom are serial entrepreneurs) to stay liked by the VC community at large. Final point: people with "fuck you money" as mentioned elsewhere in this thread, commonly don't give a fuck.
- rdl 11y agoPeople are much more willing to share information in private with their friends about which investors/vendors/employees/etc. are good/bad. "Hey, I want to talk with someone at Firm X, who is good?" "They are asshats, call me, this is why..." leads to impaired dealflow for Firm X.
- ams6110 11y agoI don't see it ever happening. I would not even call LivingSocial a "startup" at this point, they've been around a few years at least. Their new strategy (discounts linked to credit card) seems uninteresting, hard to scale, and something that dozens of others have been doing for a while now (none of whom I can name, because who cares?)
- mattmanser 11y ago9 years. https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/livingsocial#/entity https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/livingsocial#/entity
- wpietri 11y agoYes. For me, a startup is a new business formed to discover a new product or business model. Then once they've found that, they enter a phase of very rapid scaling. I'm ok with calling those startups as well, as they're still very learning-focused. But once they have a reasonably stable product and revenue stream, I think it's a mistake to call them startups any more. Their values and behaviors become much more like typical companies.
- nxzero 11y agoIn my opinion, at the point LivingSocial copied Groupon's business model, they weren't a startup anymore; before that they were a social app on Facebook.
- eli 11y agoYou're only a startup if you have an entirely original business model? I don't agree with that definition.
- MajorLOL 11y agoI think it means, at the point in TIME when they became a groupon copy they where already past the "startup" phase. Not that they stopped being a startup because they copied groupon Crazy to see the downvote mafia around here on this kind of thing.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhy would investors have veto power? Did the founders and employees give up complete control over the company? In such a situation, might it make sense for all workers to drop those investors and recreate a similar company without them?
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> Why would investors have veto power? Did the founders and employees give up complete control over the company? Likely. Sometimes you'll do anything for the investment to keep your company afloat. I know of companies who gave up board control in their seed round.
- jedberg 11y ago> Why would investors have veto power? They often sit on the board, and also often control enough shares to outvote the founders. > In such a situation, might it make sense for all workers to drop those investors and recreate a similar company without them? I'm not certain but that would probably be illegal? At least immoral.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago
- rdl 11y agoThat rule is relaxed in later stage financings.
- speeder 11y agoThis made me remember what happened to Maxis. The company was founded with VC money right off the bat (Will Wright, although a central figure, wasn't the "real" founder, the investors that found him and convinced him to start the company, not the other way around). When they release SimCity 2000, they were right on track as VC expect... the problem is that game cycle is long, they expected to release SimCity 3000 or TheSims in at least 2 years, meaning 1 year without a big release, VCs weren't happy with this, they wanted exponential growth every year, not a "staircase" growth, so the VCs kept bugging them and the result was a premature exit (where they were sold to EA for a amount of money that I think undervalued them). Now they are mostly dead :/ (after the massive failure that was SimCity 5, almost everyone was fired, including EA CEO).
- noer 11y agoOh is that why they released SimFarm, SimCopter and Streets of SimCity? edit: SimFarm was between SimCity and SimCity2k
- CalRobert 11y agoAh, I quite liked SimCopter. I would love to see a modern SimEarth, too, especially given how the threat of climate change which seemed abstract when the first came out has gotten a lot more tangible.
- mhurron 11y agoA new SimEarth would be cool, but if they made it now it would be the size of a tiny asteroid and you'd have to deal with everyone else on other asteroids in the asteroid belt.
- speeder 11y agosome of the "weirder" games they released because they wanted to. In fact SimCity 2k they made because they "had" to, they didn't wanted to make it, but it was their obvious cash cow. SimAnt, was a prototype for "The Sims" (then named "Project Dollhouse") that ended becoming what was released instead (they made the "house" and the human and the dog in SimAnt before the ant farm simulator part). After they released SimCity2k, the CEO quit (I dunno why), the VCs then started to meddle directly, and demanded they released 4 games by the end of 1996, they ended making SimCopter (that started as a 3D engine and AI prototype for The Sims again... later when they released the actual The Sims, they used the actual engine from Sim Copter, but "converted" back to 2D), SimPark (that also had parts of its engine used in The Sims and SimCity 3k and 4), Sim Tunes and FullTilt Pinball It didn't went fully well, although SimCopter people liked it, the rushed release was problematic, for example with the buggy bimbo easter-egg (one of the programmers introduced without permission an easter-egg where men in speedos and nipples that glowed would run around named "himbos", a bug, not caught due to rushed released, made the easter-egg trigger in a frightening pace, spawning hundreds of "himbos", that would run toward the helicopter, get sliced by the blades and killed, heavy PR fallout ensued). Then the VC demanded that they dropped everything (including The Sims) and started doing the next SimCity, but they wanted it in the SimCopter engine, despite the dev protests, knowing it would never work... Indeed, it didn't, SimCity 3k in SimCopter engine was throughly bashed at E3, with journalists extremely disappointed, and the team morally dropped like a rock, being forced to work in a product they knew it would never work. So they ended needing the early exit to EA to save them, it was EA, or risk the entire team quitting.
- mathattack 11y agoI've seen it more like they're aiming for 10X the last round. (Though in most cases the last round is by far the largest) I think the reasoning is that 2X vs 0.2X barely registers a difference for the VC. The home runs are what moves the needle on their returns. Founders need to be aware of this when they ask for the check. I think we'll see a lot of situations like the one you've observed. In this case I think "The CEO told Re/code that the cuts are not an attempt to dress the company up for a sale, but said he “might be open” to those conversations if they arose during the process of trying to secure new investments" means "We'll sell out at the first opportunity, rather than go through a painful down round" Doing the math, it sounds like they're down to 200 and change employees from a high of over 1000.
- acjohnson55 11y ago> I think the reasoning is that 2X vs 0.2X barely registers a difference for the VC. I thought this was worth calling out. This is more believable than the reputation/pride argument for holding out. The business model is built around homeruns and busts. Middling exits are essentially busts.
- taneq 11y agoThat's insane, and highlights the unreal expectations around the VC investment model. A draw is not a huge win but it's still a draw, and that means you get to play again.
- ihaveajob 11y agoAFAIK, a typical fund is structured to close within 10 years. If the exit is, say, 6-7 years into the fund's life, there won't be material time to "play again" and still honor the agreement with the fund's limited partners (read: institutional investors) of getting their money back in time.
- sakers 11y agoIn 2012 LivingSocial had 5000 employees.
- frozenport 11y agoEmployees got paid
- maerF0x0 11y agoIts a very common pattern to underpay market rates in exchange for equity lottery tickets. Thats what he means "employees got nothing" .
- toomuchtodo 11y agoOfftopic: Will we see tech workers demanding higher salaries with valuations coming into question? (ie your lottery ticket has much lower odds of success than you first assumed)
- rdl 11y agoSV tech wages at post-Series-B companies are generally close to Google/Apple/Facebook/Microsoft, anyway, at least in engineering. (Early stage, up through some Series A, are definitely lower) There are big/public companies which underpay people, too, of course. I think wages for a 5-10y experience "good" engineer are probably around 200-350k all-in in SF right now (cash, bonus, reasonable equity calculation, etc.). At an early startup it might be that you get a more advanced role than you would in a larger company, but in general there is close to parity now. It might be $25k more cash at a big company, and the stock being more liquid in RSUs vs. options, but the total compensation based on what I'd consider fairly reasonable valuation of equity is probably roughly the same. (I don't really know the 0-2y experience market/college hires, or non-technical roles, though.)
- draw_down 11y agoHaving had friends on the inside, it also just seemed like a terrible place to work. Grew quickly and they never paid down the organizational and technical debt. I think there were a lot of troubling signs for this business from the start, including the business model.