9 ms·
> When Spike originally released this list, many noted the lack of female filmmakers. Lee accepted that critique and released an updated list. Does that mean t
by StavrosK 11y ago
> When Spike originally released this list, many noted the lack of female filmmakers. Lee accepted that critique and released an updated list.
Does that mean that he saw movies that he felt were worthy of being on the list and (perhaps subconsciously) decided not to list them? Or did he end up listing some movies that he didn't feel were as good as the others, just to meet the quota?
- ekianjo 11y ago> just to meet the quota? Probably that one, because the Thought Police is always watching. Nevermind that most movie directors are male, so even if you were to be representative in terms of %, you would probably still end up with 90% movies made by male directors.
- caf 11y agoHis "updated list" added 8 films, so a touch over 90%.
- melling 11y agoWere they all by women? What's the diff on the movies and directors?
- caf 11y agoThe Piano – Jane Campion (1993) Daughters of the Dust – Julie Dash (1991) The Hurt Locker – Kathryn Bigelow (2008) Sugar Cane Alley – Euzhan Palcy (1983) The Seduction of Mimi – Lina Wertmuller (1972) Love and Anarchy – Lina Wertmuller (1973) Swept Away – Lina Wertmuller (1974) Seven Beauties – Lina Wertmuller (1975)
- mootothemax 11y ago>> When Spike originally released this list, many noted the lack of female filmmakers. Lee accepted that critique and released an updated list. >Does that mean that he saw movies that he felt were worthy of being on the list and (perhaps subconsciously) decided not to list them? Or did he end up listing some movies that he didn't feel were as good as the others, just to meet the quota? The charitable interpretation would be statistics: if 90+% of recognised films have been directed by men - and I'd expect more men to have directed films in, say, the 1950s than the present day - it's not terribly unlikely that a list would feature only men through chance alone. Given that such lists are going to be loosely defined - I imagine Lee could come up with several, different, lists on any one day - I don't see why including women directors would be to the detriment of a list and only to meet a "quota."
- forgetsusername 11y ago>I don't see why including women directors would be to the detriment of a list and only to meet a "quota." Obviously women aren't a detriment to the list in and of themselves. It's the fact that Mr. Lee made a list of must see movies, was critcized, then went back and changed the list based on the criticism. So which is the list of must see movies? What movies were "must-see" pre-criticism, that were no longer worthy post-criticism? PC run amok.
- mootothemax 11y ago>It's the fact that Mr. Lee made a list of must see movies, was critcized, then went back and changed the list based on the criticism. He added to the list; no films were removed. >So which is the list of must see movies? What movies were "must-see" pre-criticism, that were no longer worthy post-criticism? The current list. And none. >PC run amok. I can't write a sensible comment to this.
- xyzzy4 11y agoDid he specify which films were added in the second revision?
- mootothemax 11y ago>Did he specify which films were added in the second revision? Lee revamped the list to include eight movies by five female directors, bringing the total to 95. The Piano– Jane Campion (1993) Daughters of the Dust– Julie Dash (1991) The Hurt Locker– Kathryn Bigelow (2008) Sugar Cane Alley – Euzhan Palcy (1983) The Seduction of Mimi– Lina Wertmuller (1972) Love and Anarchy – Lina Wertmuller (1973) Swept Away – Lina Wertmuller (1974) Seven Beauties – Lina Wertmuller (1975) http://www.openculture.com/2014/11/spike-lees-list-of-95-essential-movies.html http://www.openculture.com/2014/11/spike-lees-list-of-95-ess...
- LeifCarrotson 11y ago
- Arnt 11y agoThe latter doesn't seem terribly likely. If he wanted to avoid criticism, he wouldn't have set himself a quota as low as 8%. It seems more likely that when he thought about the criticism, he thought about whom he might've overlooked and remembered Lina Wertmüller. Come to think of it, I'll watch something by her.
- jonnathanson 11y agoExactly. If you read his lists, either the original or the amended versions, you'll see that they are really lists of his favorite filmmakers, grouped by the filmmakers' best or most representative works. It's obvious, by the way the list is categorized, that Lee was thinking of it that way.
- StavrosK 11y agoAh, that makes more sense, thanks. My question was because, if this were a list of films, the works themselves are pretty removed in someone's mind from their creators, so I doubt that there would be as strong a bias there. If it's actually a list of filmmakers, then the reaction makes sense, thank you for clarifying.
- jonnathanson 11y agoI'm assuming it's both. Kind of. I mean, the supposed purpose is a list of films, but as you read through that list and the way it's been laid out, you see that Lee approached the task by first thinking about a list of filmmakers. And then you have some other films on the list which are there because they're noteworthy, regardless of the director. So it's sort of a hybrid. A lot of filmmakers, critics and film buffs, when asked to list the best films of all time, will start from the perspective of their favorite filmmakers and then work backwards from there. (The general public takes the opposite approach.) Similarly, if you ask a music critic or musician to list his favorite songs, he'll often start with favorite albums and then back into songs. Or maybe favorite artists -> albums -> songs. They're used to thinking about an individual work in the broader perspective of its creator's entire catalog. This can be a useful perspective to consider. Especially since there are some filmmakers (or authors, or artists, or bands) whose career output is highly influential, but whose individual works never really crack the Best of All Time list. Scorsese is a good example. Arguably none of his films, individually considered, ranks as a Best of All Time contender. But when you consider his entire output, you can't deny his influence on the technique of modern storytelling. I'd say the same thing about Milos Forman, for instance, though One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest does stand on its own merits on many people's lists. You could also make this argument for Steven Spielberg, controversial though he may be to film snobs. He hasn't made any given work as singularly brilliant as many of the movies listed here, but you can't deny that Spielberg has basically been synonymous with popular American cinema for the better part of an entire era. From the late 70s through the mid 2000s, he basically is the pop movie industry. And like Scorsese, he has had an outsized impact on the way people tell stories through the medium.
- ant6n 11y agoOr he realized that by only featuring male movie makers, he inadvertently left out stories worth telling, with a different perspective. In general, including women is not about giving them some unfair advantage, it's about removing an unfair disadvantage.
- PlzSnow 11y agoThe 2 lists are "best of both worlds". We have the original list, which is what he actually thinks are the most important films. And we have the second list for those for whom gender etc is more important than quality. So everyone is happy!
- jbmorgado 11y agoDon't know, let's wait until some other group that thinks they are discriminated to speak up and then check what movies Spike Lee ads to the list.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoI realized this comment was in poor taste, so I deleted it.
- jbmorgado 11y agoOnly when Spike Lee ads them to the list, and Polish Directors as well. We should all be offended by the clear discrimination towards Polish in this list.
- dpweb 11y agoIt's unfortunate Spike was shamed into updating the list. I fear the effect is not to help remove the discrimination and bias (that certainly exists) against women in many areas of society. The effect is more likely feeding a backlash against this kind of unnecessary thing, by providing another example of what many people will just label as "PC gone wild". The net effect, it hurts the cause of trying to increase diversity, instead of helping it overall. Provide scholarships. Encourage girls to enter film programs. Put quotas in film schools even! That's the way a woman will direct the Godfather of the future, not shaming people into including diversity into every single thing.
- alanctgardner3 11y agoIt's important to have role models you can identify with. Recognizing and celebrating the achievements of female directors is important. When you don't include female directors in lists of great movies, when female directors don't win awards, it reinforces the idea that women are allowed to enter the industry, but they can never really thrive and succeed in the same way a man can. Scholarships and quotas help at the top of the funnel, but if the middle of the funnel is still awful and discriminatory you're just feeding more people into the meat grinder.
- tomp 11y ago> It's important to have role models you can identify with. Anyone that cannot identify with someone as a role model just because s/he has a different sex, is incredibly sexist and doesn't deserve to be accomodated in any way. > when female directors don't win awards, it reinforces the idea that women are allowed to enter the industry, but they can never really thrive and succeed in the same way a man can IMO, it just reinforces the idea that women need to try harder to become better.
- benten10 11y agoI believe the issue was that the 'white man' demographic had been given special reservations in the first one. When they asked him if a bunch of white men had (unknowingly to him) influenced him to overrepresent by a laaarge margin, he opted to account for the unconscious bias by 'thinking' more consciously about it. Of course, now those goddamn petulant PC white men want all the spaces in the list, even AFTER he has acknowledged his bias inherent in the original list. If they'd ONLY choose to be objective and stop being selfish about the goddamn unconscious bias they are favored with. But nooo, in this ridiculous age of political correctness and 'everyones view is correct', they get do goddamn complain that they didn't get 100% of his opinion. These people are pretty much Hitlers to free speech : / PS: BTW, what's the politically correct term for a 'petulant white man-child"? I've gotten some sideeye once in a while by one of those radicals when I've used the term in public.
- ugexe 11y ago"Petulant white benten10" should be politically correct enough while retaining the spirit
- bgilroy26 11y ago> Or did he end up listing some movies that he didn't feel were as good as the others, just to meet the quota? The assumption behind this statement is that the list from the article is "Spike Lee's Top Films" This list isn't about movie quality, it's about forming the minds of young directors. Spike Lee speaks his mind. Nobody tells him what to say. If he updated his list, it was because he felt the new list would do a better job helping new directors grow in their craft.
- crusso 11y agoThe assumption behind this statement is that the list from the article is "Spike Lee's Top Films" It's not an assumption. Watch the video where Spike Lee says, "On this list is what I consider the greatest films ever made..."
- JohnKacz 11y agoHe also asks backers to send in their suggestions for the list "because of course there's going to be stuff I left out."
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>Spike Lee speaks his mind. Nobody tells him what to say. // Isn't that demonstrated to be false here. He spoke his mind and then he was told that he shouldn't have said what he did so he revised it and made his "speech" more acceptable to those who complained.
- eitally 11y agoIt likely means he chose many of these films based on specific directorial characteristics, a number of which were easy to swap out for similar, female-directed films containing the same characteristics.
- duaneb 11y agoDo you gain anything from this train of thought? He decided to edit the list; why not simply accept it? Also, I suspect spike lee is sensitive about recognizing minority directors (women are a minority among them).
- aninhumer 11y agoWhy are so many people assuming that the initial list represented his comprehensive judgement of all films ever? Is it not far more likely that he added films as sufficiently important ones occurred to him, and at some point decided the list was fairly comprehensive and stopped? Then subsequently, someone pointed out that there weren't many films by female directors, and this prompt made him think of a bunch of other films worth adding?
- RodericDay 11y ago> JohnKacz 14 minutes ago He also asks backers to send in their suggestions for the list "because of course there's going to be stuff I left out." It's really amazing the degree to which many of us white dudes, over-represented in intellectual compendiums everywhere, react when we feel the slightest, feeblest threat.
- kelukelugames 11y agoHave you read the thread on the Github diversity slides.
- mc32 11y agoIt's not that. He could have put up a list with mostly women, or mostly African films, people would mostly be okay with that. It's the perception of his giving in and revising in the face of dissent on something more or less personal. Let's say he put up a list of favorite foods. Then someone notices there are no lamb dishes and he adds lamb to it. Or there is no vegetarian dish and adds vegetarian dishes. It's not a big deal either way but people read "undue influence to change personal preferences"
- RodericDay 11y agoYou seem to be missing the point of me highlighting that Spike Lee himself asked for people to point out omissions "because of course there's going to be stuff I left out". If there's no lamb dishes, I request reminders, someone points out a lamb dish, and I add lamb, it's not healthy or reasonable to propose that I am being unduly influenced by the lamb lobby. It's within the realm of possibility, sure, but to bring it up reflects paranoia, scepticism towards lamb dishes, and possibly a persecution complex due to overexposure to lamb-related GitHub drama. It is a big deal, by the way. It makes HackerNews look like ReturnOfKings.
- EC1 11y agoDo you have a link to the original?
- fosco 11y agohis response was a larger release of the list [0] which added 8 movies and 5 directors. [0]http://www.openculture.com/2014/11/spike-lees-list-of-95-essential-movies.html http://www.openculture.com/2014/11/spike-lees-list-of-95-ess...