5 ms·
That's sad that it doesn't handle heavy traffic well. That should be where it does best. Tesla's system, for example, is nice on the open road but absolutely wo
by mikeash 11y ago
That's sad that it doesn't handle heavy traffic well. That should be where it does best. Tesla's system, for example, is nice on the open road but absolutely wonderful in heavy traffic.
Too bad about not handling full stops, too. I wonder if that's a technical limitation, or if it's just something they didn't want to allow.
- osteele 11y agoTesla switched to electromechanical brakes with the introduction of it's Traffic-Aware Cruise Control (“autopilot”) system. https://www.teslamotors.com/blog/your-autopilot-has-arrived https://www.teslamotors.com/blog/your-autopilot-has-arrived says “In October of last year we started equipping Model S with hardware to allow for the incremental introduction of self-driving technology: […] and a high-precision digitally-controlled electric assist braking system.” On the one hand, this makes it sound like a technical limitation with hydraulic brakes. On the other hand, learning the response of your particular car's brakes seems similar to a number of tasks that the car automation has to do anyway. It's a different program and running on different processors, but ABS is an existence proof of this and works fine with a variety of braking systems. I'd be interested in hearing from someone who knows more about automative systems and automation.
- Animats 11y agoRestarting from a full stop requires good pedestrian awareness. In city traffic, there might be people crossing in front of the car when it's stopped. Restart also requires getting the driver back on line. They're probably on a phone. That's why some driver input to start motion is desirable. The user interface problems for automatic driving are very tough.
- Grishnakh 11y agoI don't think the parent was talking about restarting from a full stop, it looks to me like he was saying that his car's radar-cruise system won't actually stop the car in heavy traffic, so if you're not paying attention and don't brake manually in time, you could rear-end someone.
- MBCook 11y agoHonda's system cuts out at some 'slow' speed like 35mph. If you don't do anything the car should fully stop but that's because you'll trigger the automatic emergency breaking. The problem with the system is it's relatively simplistic. You set a following distance (there are 4 options) and the car will never get closer to the car in front of you than you've specified. It will slow down as necessary to maintain that distance. This works fine on empty highways but in traffic it doesn't help. Since it won't go to (and resume) from a full stop you have to fiddle with it constantly. In tight traffic the distance has to be modified or people will continually jump in front of you (causing the car to slow down and back off). I'll also say that it waits a surprisingly long time to start braking to the point it can be a little unnerving at times. I know it knows there is a car there (there is a symbol on the dash to show that it sees a car) but it doesn't act until you get much closer. A system like Tesla or Volvo have that can bring the car to a stop and then speed back up or could decide to try to maintain a distance similar to that other drivers are maintaining would be much nicer. Still for long trips the Honda system is great. And you can always put it in 'dumb' cruise control mode if necessary.
- rcthompson 11y agoIt seems weird that it would need to brake at all most of the time to maintain a following distance. Unless the car in front of you suddenly brakes or you're going down a steep hill or something, wind resistance usually provides all the braking you need at highway speeds.
- MBCook 11y agoIt's usually more an issue when someone is getting on/off the highway and isn't at a reasonable speed. But that's kind of the issue. At times I think if the car just let off the gas earlier it wouldn't need to brake.
- Grishnakh 11y agoWow, I'm glad I didn't get a Honda and pay a premium for such a system. I got a Mazda3 instead, and the radar cruise control in that is excellent. I cruise all the time at 30mph in it (I work at a facility where I have to drive a couple miles at that speed to get to my building), around turns even. It'll come to a complete stop if the person in front of me stops.
- MBCook 11y agoI think that with cars that offer 'full stop' cruise control the driver must press a button to indicate that they're ready to roll again after the car has stopped it's self (or perhaps tap the gas). Not positive, that what I remember hearing. That way it's still the driver's responsibility, but it's easy enough that it doesn't annoy the driver.
- vvanders 11y agoTesla's doesn't. At least not 99% of the time(occasionally I'll get a hold message but most of the time it just resumes).
- mikeash 11y agoOddly, it used to require manual intervention to resume after any stop longer than five seconds. Then they bumped it up to 30 seconds on highways. Then they (mostly) removed it.
- vvanders 11y agoYeah I've only seen it twice since the last major ap update.
- cynix 11y agoThe Model S now only requires human intervention if it has detected obstacles (e.g. pedestrians) while stopped, otherwise it should be able to resume automatically.
- henrikschroder 11y agoMercedes has some sort of timer, if the car's been stopped for more than maybe five seconds, I have to tap the gas to get it rolling again.
- Reason077 11y agoRestarting from a full stop requires good pedestrian awareness. Cars that accelerate automatically from a stop already have the radar/ultrasonic sensors necessary for collision avoidance. So they should never accelerate into a pedestrian (and not allow you to, either!). If anything, collision avoidance systems have better pedestrian/cyclist awareness than human drivers do, since they can "see" objects in blind spots, etc.
- vvanders 11y agoOh man, all this. I thought Autopilot was nifty but it wasn't until I slogged through ~40 minutes of rush hour without touching the pedals or wheel when I realized how awesome it really was. It's useful at-speed but the killer app really is rush hour traffic.
- sillysaurus3 11y agoI thought Autopilot was nifty but it wasn't until I slogged through ~40 minutes of rush hour without touching the pedals or wheel when I realized how awesome it really was. Which car can do this?
- vvanders 11y agoAll Autopilot equipped Teslas.
- henrikschroder 11y agoHigh-end Mercedes/BMW/Audi/Lexus have had these features for years now, although they still force you to keep your hands on the wheel, presumably for liability issues. (And it's still awesome, it makes stop-and-go traffic bearable)
- saiya-jin 11y agohaving to keep hands on the wheel vs not touching it at all (as vvanders wrote) shows how much trust car manufacturers have in their systems
- mikeash 11y agoI think that's just a matter of risk tolerance. The traditional manufacturers are taking it slow because they have a huge potential downside, and limited upside. Having the best autonomous system on the market wins some sales. Being on the receiving end of Toyota Unintended Acceleration II: Autonomous Boogaloo would be a disaster. So they're taking it easy. Tesla is in "go big or go home" mode. They intend to grow sales by a factor of ten in five years. They have no history and are just beginning to build brand loyalty, so they want to show everyone that they're the best. That makes them much more willing to take risks.