5 ms·
Terry Pratchett has Alzheimer's, and is becoming an assisted suicide advocate.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- philk 17y agoIt's good that Terry Pratchett is advocating for this (although it would be much better if he was healthy). This article reminded me of an Op-Ed he wrote in the Guardian last year, which I posted as another article (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128224 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128224)
- jimmyjim 17y agoThere was a healthy discussion on this issue just two days ago on Reddit: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b1n8h/i_remember_when_i_was_younger_hearing_about_dr/ http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b1n8h/i_remember...
- camccann 17y agoTch, show proper respect. That's "Sir Terry" to the likes of us. And I don't think "becoming an advocate" is perhaps worded strongly enough. A few choice quotes from something he previously wrote on the subject (the link in philk's comment): "I live in hope - hope that before the disease in my brain finally wipes it clean, I can jump before I am pushed" "I am enjoying my life to the full, and hope to continue for quite some time. But I also intend, before the endgame looms, to die sitting in a chair in my own garden with a glass of brandy in my hand and Thomas Tallis on the iPod - the latter because Thomas's music could lift even an atheist a little bit closer to Heaven - and perhaps a second brandy if there is time. Oh, and since this is England I had better add: 'If wet, in the library.'" "I have met Alzheimer's sufferers who are hoping that another illness takes them away first. Little old ladies confide in me, saying: 'I've been saving up my pills for the end, dear.'" As terrible as death is, interminable, futile suffering with no hope of respite until the bitter end isn't necessary and isn't what most people want.
- Groxx 17y agoMuch less to inflict that and the costs associated with it on the ones they love. I've always sided for the ability to choose in this because I really do think there are things worse than death, especially when you're assured there's no recovery before the end.
- dbz 17y agoI'm (also) pro everything. Pro Choice. Pro Abortion. Pro choose your own death. Pro Gay Marriage. Why? I don't give a fuck what anyone else does. If I have to, I will die while living off of a tube because my religion doesn't allow me to commit suicide. I also won't tattoo myself for the same reason. (I do choose not to follow some laws, yet I follow others) Just because I personally believe anyone who commits suicide is going to hell (Note: I don't actually believe that previous statement), doesn't mean I'm going to stop him or her. Not my place. =]
- flipper 17y agoYes, it's another 'victimless crime', so I'm pro, too. I've seen some relatives die slow, lingering deaths and others fairly quick ones. Neither is ideal though it's bloody obvious which way is less unpleasant. Enough time to tick off everything on your bucket list and properly say goodbye to those you care about is the best we can hope for.
- pyre 17y agoThe only issue with assisted-suicide, is at what point does the line get drawn between assisted-suicide and murder. If we do 'make it legal' I think there needs to be some clear definition in this area so that it doesn't end up too grey (i.e. the method of assisted-suicide has to make it clear that the person wanted it; legal documents must be signed or something similar). Also the question of "What happens if someone changes their mind at the last minute" needs to be answered or at least have some sort of legal context to it. I haven't spent a huge amount of time pondering the issue, but the opening of legal loopholes is the only thing that I could possibly see blocking this. Well, I guess the other thing might be some sort of required counselling to prevent impulsive emo teens (or similar) from using such a thing (i.e. make sure that people are in a rational frame of mind when making the decision, not just running off to die because of a break-up).
- simonjoe 17y agoActually, alzheimer's can't be diagnosed premortem. It's only diagnosed by characteristic neural striations during a necropsy. Before death, the only conclusion that one can draw (along those lines) is some kind of dementia, not the particular kind. (citation: Dr. Corballis, GT PSYC 3020 - Biopsychology)
- epochwolf 17y agoI have to agree with him to some degree. Modern medicine allows us to extend life far beyond circumstances that would normally kill us. If someone is old, unhealthy, and no longer wishes to live they should be able to choose to end their life. The medical resources that would be used to keep them alive could be devoted elsewhere. I certainly don't advocation allowing a healthy person to end their life because they have a chance at things getting better.
- koningrobot 17y agoI certainly don't advocation allowing a healthy person to end their life because they have a chance at things getting better. This is gambling with other people's lives. If such a healthy person is forced to stay alive, things might never actually get better, and they will have suffered needlessly by staying alive. (And if things do get better, that is merely relief from suffering.) On the other hand, if such a healthy person is allowed to end their life, that's all there is to it. They'll never regret it. Besides, if you deny people professional help with ending their lives, they will try to get the job done themselves, often with bad results.
- plinkplonk 17y agoSo from what I read (thanks ot this submission) about terminally ill people killing themselves the consensus for people to kill themselves would be some kind of morphine/opiate overdose. Sounds like a decent way to go. I always thought I should get a gun (Possession of firearms is largely illegal where I live so this would involve some shady dealings and a lot of money) if I am ever diagnosed with something painful and/or terminal. As a programmer who is used to working with his mind I am horrified at the thought of staying physically alive but slowly losing my mind. Getting enough morphine to overdose should be easier than buying a gun from a criminal. Damned if I'll stay alive in constant pain just so some religious nuts can feel elevated.
- andrew1 17y agoI think a preferred option for many people in this situation would be to go to an assisted suicide clinic like Dignitas in Switzerland where you can choose to die at a time of your choosing, without pain, surrounded by your loved ones, with the 'operation' performed by a medical professional. A problem with trying to kill yourself is the risk of getting it wrong - shooting yourself in the head but not managing to kill yourself, not taking enough of your drug of choice - and leading to a possibly lengthy agonising death, or permanent coma etc. The problem people in the UK have with going to somewhere like Dignitas is that the law around assisting someone with suicide is vague, so if someone's family goes with them to Dignitas, they risk arrest when returning to the UK. In practise I think prosecution has never happened, but people have certainly been arrested on returning to the country. Personally I think assisted suicide should be legal (although not as something that can be a spur of the moment decision) so that people can choose to take their own life, without the risk of pain or error, and with the support of their families.
- pyre 17y ago> I think prosecution has never happened, but people have certainly been arrested on returning to the country. How would they know why you left/re-entered the country unless you told them? Do the UK authorities track anyone the enters/exits a Dignitas facility?
- danw 17y agoListen to his Richard Dimbleby Lecture to understand his viewpoint http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00qmfgn http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00qmfgn. There are text versions and recordings floating around. Here's a shortened one: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/feb/02/terry-pratchett-assisted-suicide-tribunal http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/feb/02/terry-pratchet...
- pmccool 17y agoTerry Pratchett writes movingly and convincingly that assisted suicide should be allowed. Coming up with some general rule about how and when will be the hard part. I can't see any legal reforms in this area being anything except controversial and problematic. I fear it will be a long time before the legal system can accomodate the mature, considered decision to end one's own suffering. I'm referring, btw, to the Australian legal system. From the sounds of it, the UK system is in more or less the same position.