6 ms·
>Avoiding money laundering is a laudable goal, while avoid the dissemination of information is not clearly so. You're not comparing apples to apples. The goal
by SilasX 11y ago
>Avoiding money laundering is a laudable goal, while avoid the dissemination of information is not clearly so.
You're not comparing apples to apples. The goal of money laundering laws is to make it harder to profit from crimes, achieved by the means of e.g. violating financial privacy.
The goal of copyright laws is not to "prevent dissemination of information" but to encourage better intellectual works by granting their creators temporary control of them; this is achieved by the means of restricting some kinds of copying.
Both intents are noble; to characterize the goal of copyright law as "preventing the dissemination of information" is the wrong comparison.
- over 11y agoYou've introduced a means into your goal: goal: "encourage better intellectual works" means: "granting their creators temporary control of them" There are other ways to meet that goal.
- EGreg 11y agoCan't the same be said about money laundering laws
- over 11y agoYeah, it was just a nitpick to clarify means and ends. I think the means and the ends need to be acceptable in any endeavor, one never justifies the other. But at the same time, one never disqualifies the other.
- cturner 11y agoYour point wasn't a nitpick. It is crucial to get the structures right, because otherwise the status quo easily hides behind non-obvious circular reasoning.
- coldtea 11y ago>There are other ways to meet that goal. And yet, judging from international laws, all lawmakers worldwide seem agree that a variation of the current method is the preferred one.
- over 11y agoThere are plenty of laws that give federal grants to artists and scholarships to graduate students.
- coldtea 11y agoThose are supplementary laws -- since all country also have similar copyright laws too. And 99% of those you mention are for avant garde, classical, jazz, traditional and other endangered species of art.
- deciplex 11y agoMost lawmakers worldwide have shitty ideas on most topics.
- coldtea 11y agoAnd most individual people, especially those involved in an industry only as consumers, have naive and ridiculous ideas of what would work.
- deciplex 11y agoIt's almost like, oh I don't know, a balance of consumer and business interests and input would lead to more acceptable outcomes for everyone, when drawing up policy, as opposed to shutting one side out of the discussion completely. Weird, eh?
- orionblastar 11y agoOriginal copyright law expired after so many years to fall into the public domain so others could use it and it made copyright holders invent new copyrights to encourage better intellectual works. Only Mickey Mouse was set to expire so Disney had the laws changed. The same with Time Warner aka DC Comics and Superman. So other companies can't use them as they will never fall into the public domain.
- eru 11y agoThat's a bit parochial --- I guess you are talking about the origin of copyright law in the US? The world is older than that country. Copyright law has its origins in censorship and rent seeking. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law and the linked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Anne https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Anne and even further back.
- orionblastar 11y agoYes US copyright law is trying to be pushed on other nations. http://www.intellectualpropertylawfirms.com/resources/intellectual-property/copyrights/how-long-does http://www.intellectualpropertylawfirms.com/resources/intell... US copyright used to be only 14 years then it went into public domain. But it has been changed over the decades.
- digi_owl 11y agoThe biggest change happend in the 80s, when USA signed the Bern convention on copyright. Note btw that said convention was called to merge two systems of copyright. The English, and the "continental" (French). The English system was basically what the US system copied back in the day. It was mainly focused on the economic aspect and thus had a "short" duration. The French concept on the other hand, "rights of the author", was more focused on the reputation of the author, and thus had a long time frame (life of author+x years). It was about giving the author the ability to say "no you can't use my creation in your political campaign". Frankly, if i am to speculate, i would claim that USA stayed out of these conventions as long as it was importer rather than exporter.
- marcosdumay 11y agoHum, no, modern copyright laws do not have have the intent of encouraging better intellectual works. Politicians may claim this intent on some countries to deceive the population, but it is obvious by their format that they were not created for that goal. Anti money laundering laws vary a lot in quality, and some of them do have the goal of catching criminals.
- drdeca 11y agoIt might not be the goal that they serve in practice, but if you ask a random person why they think some sort of copyright is a good idea, provided that they do think that, uh, actually nevermind a fair number of them will probably talk about the rights of the creator of the work instead. Hm.
- SilasX 11y agoDifferent people have different goals for the laws. For a sane comparison, you should look at the most laudable goals, otherwise it's going to be a fruitless discussion, trying to divine the "real" reason behind copyright laws.
- nitrogen 11y agoFor a sane comparison, you should look at the most laudable goals I don't think this is self evident. One cannot understand the current state of copyright without also understanding the less than laudable goals of some of the media conglomerates.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> Different people have different goals for the laws. For a sane comparison, you should look at the most laudable goals I couldn't disagree more. This makes you a simpleton who's excessively vulnerable to baptists-and-bootleggers type efforts. Don't ever support legislation (or anything else!) because it's labeled with a goal; attaching a goal to something is free. This comic is actually highly relevant: http://dilbert.com/strip/2003-10-05 http://dilbert.com/strip/2003-10-05 For a sane view of laws, you should look at the effects. What people say they want the law to do just isn't relevant compared to what it actually does.
- orionblastar 11y agoMoney laundering laws require your driver's license number when transfering accounts to verify who you are. They discriminate against those who can't get a license for some reason. Copyright laws get rid of fair use by DMCA takedown notices of any material that has even a small bit of copyrighted material even if it was nonprofit or educational or parody and covered under fair use.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> The goal of copyright laws is not to "prevent dissemination of information" but to encourage better intellectual works by granting their creators temporary control of them We know that copyright systems originate in efforts by the state to prevent publications from being disseminated freely. This is all part of the same political impulse that made private organizations such as volunteer firemen illegal -- if you let people assemble and speak to each other, who knows what might happen. So you've stumbled into the interesting question "if we create a system to promote goal X, but later decide we can't endorse X and relabel the system as promoting goal Y (without making non-cosmetic changes to the system), what is that system's goal?" It's like the Ship of Theseus for organizations. It's not really crazy to argue that the goal is still X. (As to this particular case, I don't believe that the US government is particularly interested in using copyright to prevent stuff from getting published. But I do think the people saying "the goal of copyright is to prevent certain things from being published" have a reasonable argument that deserves more than just an offhand dismissal.)
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> As to this particular case, I don't believe that the US government is particularly interested in using copyright to prevent stuff from getting published. There is a fair argument to be made that the companies who induce the government to enact excessive copyright terms do want exactly that, because competition with more public domain works would reduce the margins on works still under copyright (supply and demand). It also allows those companies to more effectively censor unflattering parts of their own history, e.g. Disney's Song of the South.