9 ms·
Can someone explain to me why universal basic income seems to be more popular than negative income taxes these days? To use some examples I'm picking out of my
by CydeWeys 11y ago
Can someone explain to me why universal basic income seems to be more popular than negative income taxes these days? To use some examples I'm picking out of my hat:
1. Universal basic income: Everyone gets $10K per year.
2. Negative income tax: Everyone gets $15K per year, phased out linearly across an income of $60K (i.e. if you earn $0 you get $15K, if you earn $20K you get $10K, if you earn $40K you get $5K, and if you earn $60K then the negative income tax is fully phased out).
Why is 1 preferable to 2? Is it just that it's less susceptible to tax fraud? Note that the amount that an unemployed person gets in UBI is less, because the same amount of money is being distributed to more people, even millionaires.
- Frondo 11y agoMy guess would be simplicity and fairness: everyone gets $X per month, no matter who you are, that's a simple thing to get. It fits neatly into our pre-existing mental models of how people get paid in the world. Tying it to taxes, sure you could still space it out monthly, but we're used to thinking of taxes as a once-yearly (or once-quarterly) event. Fairness: everyone, even millionaires, gets the same thing. The idea doesn't discriminate, so it's not just "the poors getting a handout" (n.b. I don't endorse that idea or phrasing).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Mz 11y agoI think: First, basic income is a simple concept. Anyone can understand the idea. The idea is that everyone gets a check. Everyone. (The reality: It probably won't work that way.) Taxes are complicated and poorly understood and so on. Second, I think a lot of people are incredibly scared right now. I have seen articles from very wealthy people about how afraid they are for the world these days. A great many people are afraid that automation is "taking our jobs" and that if we do not simply cut a check for everyone, vast swaths of people will be left out and there is just a lot of fear right now. The world is more complicated than ever. An elegant solution in the face of that level of complexity is hard for many people to envision, much less fathom. (For the record: I am not for basic income. I am for 1) Affordable housing and 2) making "gig work" a path to a real middle class income.)
- derefr 11y agoI don't see why we can't build such systems from simple elegant "mechanism" cores (like true 100%-of-population UBI) and then put "policy"-based compensatory mechanisms atop them, rather than mining policy and mechanism in every single thing the government does. I.e., in this case, everyone gets a check from one (small) department; and then that check is treated as income, and so another (large) department will take some varying amount of it away, along with the rest of income. Seems far better than trying to optimize treasury-need vs personal-need during both the giving and the taking-away steps.
- Mz 11y agoI have written about this before and, in a nutshell, there are problems inherent in cutting everyone a check. If you literally give everyone a check starting from birth, you will almost certainly see poor women cranking out babies to increase their own income and they will not be good mothers and they will not raise children who are decent human beings, prepared to contribute to the world. One of my previous blog posts about my objections too ubi: http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2015/09/it-was-obsolete-before-we-opened.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2015/09/it-was-obsol...
- derefr 11y agoI agree that there are problems if we just add UBI on top of the current system. But that doesn't go against my point—we can set up a mechanism (give everyone money) and then write policy assuming that mechanism (e.g. pass laws about children's income requiring it to go into trusts, where any money being spent by the parents requires a new Financial Auditing branch of Child Protective Services to do a check that the money is being spent for the child's best interests.) The important thing is that the latter step is general: it safeguards the interests of children who get any kind of income, including child actors, child competitive-tournament winners, etc. If this were just part of the decision process of granting the money as income in the first place, then these side-benefits would be left unrealized. It's the same as the mechanism/policy separation of Internet infrastructure: instead of trying to create a physical-layer transport with perfect reliability, we create a simple physical-layer transport (Ethernet) and then reliability is a policy decision made at a higher level, compensating for a physical layer where "potential unreliability" is taken as axiomatic. We should strive for "foundational" laws that set up universal systems of incentives—because that lets us predict how society will shift in aggregate. Then, having done so, we should be able to write specific, ephemeral laws that assume such incentives exist, and then create multiplicative or countervailing forces to shift those incentives for the specific case. The one obvious example of where the law does this is in terms of inalienable rights. The constitution "grants" them universally (though the language is more like "these rights are already axiomatic in the cultural fabric, and we're just making them explicit in law so they can be pointed at.") Then, legislation and caselaw just work in terms of them, layering new things above and around them to achieve an effect, rather than being able to say anything like "and in this case, [some right] doesn't apply." For any given area of policy, having a low-level non-changeable core policy that can always be trusted to be true—and then a high-level set of situational laws to attenuate the output of that core, rather than overriding it—is both easier to legislate, easier to adjudicate, easier to enforce, and easier to learn. Everyone including later policy-makers can know and rely on the core policy always applying, so they don't have to worry; there's no combinatoric explosion of "if we add this, then will that other thing that was intended to be countervailing now go too far when this branch of the core decision tree is taken?" Instead, we just get the equivalent of D&D's "non-stackable bonuses": an explicit notion of a "non-core law" (like a notion of a "bonus") where the core law can set meta-policy on how policies combine.
- shiro 11y agoAren't they basically the same thing? In your example 2., you can say you still distribute $15K to everyone, but you set the progressive tax rate so that if you get $60K the extra tax amount would become $15K that cancels the flat distribution. (If you say UBI is for every person including kids, you can still adjust tax rate in 2. with dependent deductible/compensation). The amount people get depends on the design of whole scheme (including tax increase to compensate UBI) so you can't say which is cheaper/expensive in general. Can you? (I'm not an expert, so my reasoning may be flawed.)
- hzhou321 11y agoIt is the KISS principle.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoI think because UBI is guaranteed to be fair. With negative income tax you're still going to get people fiddling with their taxes to get every penny they can out of the system. UBI is also less bureaucratic so less expensive. You simply wire everyone who has registered their money. With negative income tax their is more paperwork which means more people need to be employed to deal with it and to deal with the potential fraud. It also places more burden on citizens to correctly report taxes or face prosecution.
- zanny 11y agoThis is the answer. Disconnect the economic floor from the means to fund it - when you have a NIT, it tightly couples its revenue source to itself. One of the cornerstones of UBI proposals is to tie it to cost of living to avoid having to touch it, whereas with tax code you often want to change it all the time determined by how prosperous or stagnant the economy is. In addition, humans are kinda weird animals. It is much easier to pitch much higher taxes and a guaranteed $1500 a month from the state to people rather than higher taxes and no state check.
- adventured 11y agoThe frequent counter argument to this, is that it isn't fair to give rich people a basic income at all. That it's inherently regressive to give rich people welfare. Instead, those income payments should be going to those that need it the most. Basic income is fair like a flat tax is fair, and just as regressive.
- erkkie 11y agoI believe the premise is that those rich people will pay much more in taxes than their cut of the UBI pool. I guess if you mean rich people who don't work / pay taxes, but I don't think that's an actual issue (since the few who end up unfairly benefitting don't matter in the grand scale), more so an emotional one. Would love if anyone had actual numbers on this.
- ant6n 11y ago
- mjirv 11y agoAssuming a progressive tax system they're basically the same thing. (1) is a simpler description, if less precise.
- redthrow 11y agoOne form of means-tested basic income is negative income tax, which economists like Milton Friedman supported. However, some basic income supporters don't seem to like means testing, but they usually don't show how to fund universal basic income other than saying (a) streamlining bureaucracy and (b) more taxes for the rich will fund it.
- qrendel 11y agoI'm not really inclined to spend time on a detailed analysis at the moment, but given what the US wastes (imo) on military spending and healthcare (relative to other similar nations, e.g. Canada), you could get a good portion of the way to a UBI just by cuts to those and similar programs. A previous back-of-envelope estimate put it at around $6,800/person just for halving the total military budget (not just DoD) and switching to single-payer.
- marcoperaza 11y agoCanada isn't responsible for keeping the peace and keeping trading routes open in Europe, the South China Sea, the Persian Gulf, etc. Nor is it responsible for defending Taiwan, South Korea, and Japan. Nor will it be be able to make any decisive contributions to the defense of the easternmost NATO countries. The West's military might rests almost entirely in the United States. You don't want to see a world where we don't inspire fear in the halls of power of China and Russia. Never have the good been so much more powerful than the bad. Let's keep it that way. ==================================================== I've been rate-limited by HN, so here's my response to derefr: ==================================================== That's a good point. I've heard the argument that the US's defense of Europe has infantilized Europeans into thinking that they don't need military might, that institutions like the ICC and the UN can actually keep them safe. Much like a child doesn't understand the value of money because he's never had to work for it. I think there's a little more to it than that; the horrors of the two world wars are surely part of Europeans' distaste for military power. Unfortunately, if the US just withdrew its defense of Europe, I have no doubt that Russia would conquer the rest of Ukraine and the Baltics. Japan has been trying to become more responsible for its own defense under Prime Minister Abe, but look at the vicious opposition he's gotten for it. Maybe one day the political tides will shift in Europe and elsewhere and the US can responsibly hand over some of its current military obligations. For now, I reckon it's a price worth paying for a world of peace and commerce. And in which America does exceedingly well.
- marcoperaza 11y agoOne difference that comes to mind is that the negative income tax requires all of the government machinery of the income tax to operate. If you decide to abolish income taxes in favor of something else, like sales or property taxes, you'd still need income reporting to compute everyone's benefit. A universal basic income is much simpler to operate because it's the same amount per-head. If we're going to stay on an income tax system, then the negative income tax is probably smarter. Interesting aside: Milton Friedman was a proponent of a negative income tax.
- jbkly7 11y agoOne of the differences is that a basic income eliminates the "welfare cliff". With any kind of means-tested system, there's a reduced incentive to increase your earnings because every dollar you earn reduces your benefit. With a universal basic income, there's no disincentive to work extra because you receive the benefit no matter your income, and earning an extra $5k is $5k more in your pocket rather than being offset by your benefit going down.
- zanny 11y agoThat isn't an actual answer to the question, though. With UBI, you get a fixed amount and just end up paying more taxes to make up for getting the UBI in the first place. NIT means instead of taxing you for the amount of money they give you you just stop getting the money.
- eru 11y agoYou can set up your tax system to exactly mirror the net effects of UBI. Negative income tax is just one possible implementation of UBI.
- aninhumer 11y agoIndeed. For example, the parent's suggested scheme is equivalent to a $15k basic income, with a 25% tax on earned income up to $60k. The only real difference between the two is the constants each framing leads us towards. The above scheme is fairly mild, but if you shrink the window down to $30k, which initially sounds progressive (less money for richer people right?) you actually end up with the equivalent of a 50% tax band on income below $30k. I prefer the Basic Income framing for this reason.
- CydeWeys 11y agoYes, you figured out why I picked the numbers I did. It's somewhat surprising how high the full phase-out amount has to be for things to work: It basically needs to go to several times the poverty level in order to make the marginal taxation on poor people of acceptably low levels.
- Zakharov 11y agoNegative income taxes generally mean high marginal net tax rates for low-income earners. In your example, there's a 20% marginal tax rate for people earning less than 60K.
- CydeWeys 11y agoI don't consider 20% to be a high marginal tax rate. I would love to be able to keep a full eighty percent of every additional dollar that I earn. Instead it's a lot closer to half. Indeed, the current tax code has the marginal rate set at 25% for single filers over $37,650 in income. Yes, 20% may be a higher marginal tax rate than the poor are currently paying, but it's more than made up for by the huge payments they're getting. The marginal tax rate of a single filter earning $10K under the current tax codes is 15% (not that much less than 20%). But said person would also be getting $12,500 from the NIT. Doesn't seem bad to me at all. And if you're really still worried about it, you could make the phase-out not linear over $60K by adding brackets, like the current tax code has. In other words, I don't think the effect that you are saying is really caused by the NIT per se, just in my sandbox implementation of it.
- Riseed 11y agoIn addition to what's been mentioned in other comments, one big difference between basic income and negative income tax is who receives them. Basic income is given to everyone, and negative income tax is only given to those below a threshold amount -- creating two classes of people. The funding structure is substantially similar because in both systems some people pay more in taxes than they receive. However, by only distributing the payments to a subset of the population, there is a social stigma associated with receiving benefits. With a universal payment, there is no stigma. By virtue of being tied to the tax system, negative income tax operates on a year-based system and pays retroactively. Regardless of whether the year's overall income would qualify for negative income tax, individuals must self-fund any time off. A negative income tax does nothing to help those who are temporarily out of work, or who only want a few months off to help with childcare, learn/improve skills, or address an illness. Implementing negative income tax by making adjustments to withholdings would help employees with low incomes, but does not address the self-funding issue for low-income independent contractors, or those experiencing temporary/long-term joblessness.
- eru 11y ago> By virtue of being tied to the tax system, negative income tax operates on a year-based system and pays retroactively. That's a naive interpretation. In practice people are already paying their income taxes every month via withholding, so paying out the negative income tax as you go would be possible to implement similarly.
- Riseed 11y agoI did mention implementation of negative income tax via withholding in the final sentence of my comment. However, I haven't read/heard how adjusting withholding would work in a non-retroactive manner for independent contractors or those who are temporarily jobless. What's a non-retroactive negative income tax payment proposal for persons in those situations?
- eru 11y agoMake an estimate, then retroactively fix the (hopefully small) delta?
- netcan 11y agoThey are not a million miles apart. 2 out of an infinite number of variations of a policy. Major UBI plans will likely involve major changes to the tax system anyway, either as part of the initial legislation or eventually and the net effect of either could be very similar. So, it's mostly a semantic difference. But, going off the two scenarios you mention the UBI version has a little more of what makes the idea appealing to the political right (though there have been negative income tax ideas that came from the right too). The main one being losing the complexity, overhead, unintended consequences, perverse incentives and nannying that comes with means testing. I think there are arguments to be made for either.
- Chathamization 11y agoThere's no reason why the amount going to poor people under UBI should be less. Money goes out to more people (everyone), but the higher brackets would pay more, so it'd be a wash. IE, the millionaires get an extra $10,000 a month than they would with a negative income tax, but end up having to pay an extra $10,000 a month than they would with a negative income tax. As for why UBI is preferable, let's look at some situations. If a person gets fired in May and needs the extra income, with the UIB it would be coming in already and they wouldn't need to worry about anything. With a negative income tax they would probably need to apply to some government agency, at which point they would either start sending the person payments whenever they get a chance to review the application (which could take weeks or months), or they deny the application for one reason or another and the person has to appeal/send more evidence and try to navigate a bureaucratic maze while they're running out of money. Or a person is self-employed, and at the beginning of the year they believe they will make too much to get the income, then mid-way through the year their business slows to the point where they start going through the bureaucratic hell of the previous person, and then after a few months some new clients come in and they start trying to navigate the bureaucracy again to update the agency without a penalty. I don't know if you've ever applied for benefits like these, but very often things turn into a mess, and you're spending weeks calling different offices and waiting for thing to go through, at which point your eligibility changes and you have to start over again. UBI doesn't eliminate all issues, but it's simpler in the same way that sending your kid to the local public school is simpler than trying to get support using the FAFSA. Also, with the checks going out to everyone it's going to be hard to get rid of something like that (look at Social Security for an example of this).
- keithpeter 11y agoUK: this is an attractive part of the basic income proposition. I think such a scheme might also promote risk-taking in employment in the sense that people might be motivated to try stuff they would not normally try e.g. setting up their own micro-business or working on temporary contracts. Now, the OA is talking about a pilot. How do those work? How do you decide to ring fence the residents in the region you are trying it in? Why could not I just move over there for a couple of years during the pilot?
- rattray 11y ago"Negative" + "income tax" = poor political phrasing. Hopefully UBI looks something like the phase-out you described in practice.
- patio11 11y ago"Free $THING_OF_VALUE for everyone!" sounds a lot more palatable to the middle class than "You're going to be asked to kick in more in taxes to buy $THING_OF_VALUE for poor people." This is true of food, education, and health care. It may also be true of "money."
- a-saleh 11y agoI think I would consider myself a middle class, and I think I have two reasonable arguments why I dislike my "taxes buying $THING_OF_VALUE" for poor people. 1. this implies my taxes need to pay for somebody deciding who is poor or not 2. the decision if you are poor (and get or not get the $THING) tends to be binary I have met a few people who were surviving only on some goverment support, that felt that any attempt to integrate back to the work-force would force some imagnary switch to be flipped that cuts them off from welfare and leave them worse off even when they have salary. From my perspective UBI and negative income tax can have implementations similar enough in attempting to solve this problem.
- toomanybeersies 11y agoNegative income tax is essentially subsidising companies employing low wage earners.
- saalweachter 11y agoTechnically both are. Which I'm actually OK with: I would be perfectly happy to trade UBI for no minimum wage, from a human-welfare point of view. Right now, people choose to work for wages below the cost of living because starving to death slow is better than starving to death fast. With UBI, the "don't accept/stay at low-paying job X" penalty is just a loss of marginal income, not an existential threat. Some people will work for peanuts because the job isn't that hard and the extra marginal income is nice. Other people will feel more empowered to tell employers offering shit pay for terrible, unsafe work to shove it. So you'll get wins on both sides. (On the other hand, the government may need to mandate minimum wages just to ensure there is enough of a tax base to continue funding UBI, which is a different issue.)
- maxerickson 11y agoA VAT works without regard to the wages paid.
- toomanybeersies 11y agoI think UBI is different in that everyone is given a certain amount of money as a basic human right, and then people can be paid market rate for the work they do. You're right about the security that UBI offers though, and I think that removing the minimum wage would go well with introducing UBI. In some developed countries without a minimum wage, unions set the pay rate for specific jobs, a similar arrangement happens in Australia, where people are paid according to industry agreements on the value of a worker.
- CydeWeys 11y agoThat's not any different than what we already have, though. There are numerous entitlements (food stamps, Medicaid, WIC, public housing, etc.) that already do exactly the same thing. By that token UBI is also subsidizing companies employing low wage earners, because it allows people to take low-paid jobs that they otherwise wouldn't since they wouldn't be able to survive on them without UBI. Also, marginal utility of money means that $15K going to someone who is well-compensated isn't that meaningful, but it means a lot to someone working a part-time minimum wage job, so the latter is compensated more (thus, subsidy).
- a_imho 11y agoPro: you can describe 1. in 5 words. Simplicity can be nice, especially when it comes to red tape.
- CydeWeys 11y agoOne more question I meant to ask, but forgot to: Is UBI intended to be universal across the entire country, or does it scale to cost of living of a given area? I can see pros/cons to either.