4 ms·
Jeff and I started out with a goal for StackOverflow of changing the way programmers and system administrators get answers to their questions on the Internet, w
by ams6110 17y ago
Jeff and I started out with a goal for StackOverflow of changing the way programmers and system administrators get answers to their questions on the Internet, which was deeply broken. In 18 months we’ve accomplish that
Have they? Whenever I have a question the first place I turn is Google, and I usually find my answer on a site that's not stack overflow.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- llimllib 17y ago"changed the way programmers... get their answers" != "changed the way I get my answers" Clearly, based on their traffic, they have changed the way many, many programmers get their answers.
- michaelbuckbee 17y agoIt's getting better, but StackOverflow is still pretty dominated by C# and .Net questions. If you're using something else there is a significantly smaller chance that they'll turn up in your search results.
- spolsky 17y agoCheck out the "Tags" page to see the popularity of various technologies on StackOverflow. Although C# and .NET are pretty popular on StackOverflow, I don't think they are disproportionate to their overall popularity in the developer community. Look at how StackOverflow has displaced Experts Exchange, though, and it tells a clearer story: http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/stackoverflow.com+experts-exchange.com http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/stackoverflow.com+experts-exch... I don't think there is ANY other general-audience programming site with more traffic.
- davidw 17y agoI've been watching that over time, as a potential data source for http://LangPop.com http://LangPop.com , and StackOverflow has definitely "improved", but it has historically had a .net/c# bias compared to what turns up elsewhere, just like github has had a Ruby bias, which is slowly fading as github gains in popularity with the developer population at large.
- melling 17y agoJoel and Jeff don't create the content for the site, the communities do. The fact that other communities haven't moved into their sections en masse is not their fault. It's YOUR (ie. everyone else) FAULT. For example, I tried to get the Grails community to use StackOverFlow when the site first started and their attitude was that they would rather just use the mailing list and sift through Nabble. http://archive.codehaus.org/lists/org.codehaus.grails.user/msg/8B7D5E3A-6DA7-4A32-86BD-08C150997125@gmail.com http://archive.codehaus.org/lists/org.codehaus.grails.user/m... The problem isn't with StackOverFlow, it's with the other communities refusing to adopt something new. "After all, IRC is where all the best people hang out...who needs this .Net thing..." I'm currently learning Lisp. You wouldn't be able to get this kind of an answer on a mailing list or on IRC. http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2264267/generating-a-quiz-in-common-lisp http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2264267/generating-a-quiz... This .Net/C# site just made it easier to learn Haskell, Lisp, Erlang, Scala... a little irony not to be overlooked.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"The fact that other communities haven't moved into their sections en masse is not their fault. It's YOUR (ie. everyone else) FAULT." The first sentence is fine. The second not so much. "Fault" assumes that moving to SO/contributing etc is unambigously a good thing. I would not be suprised if at least some developers thought their existing communication channels are just fine. "For example, I tried to get the Grails community to use StackOverFlow when the site first started and their attitude was that they would rather just use the mailing list and sift through Nabble. http://archive.codehaus.org/lists/org.codehaus.grails.user/m.. http://archive.codehaus.org/lists/org.codehaus.grails.user/m.... " This sounds like a valid choice to me. "The problem isn't with StackOverFlow, it's with the other communities refusing to adopt something new." They may have good reasons to do so. Just because you are enthusiastic about SO doesn't mean everyone has to be. (Due Disclosure : I don't use SO at all. I once saw an algorithm question on SO I could answer and when I tried, I found out I had to use OpenID to log in. Couldn't be bothered.)
- melling 17y ago
- melling 17y agoThe glass is half empty? I think you're completely missing the point. It's really up to each community (Haskell, Lisp, Scala, Clojure, etc.) to develop their appropriate sections of StackOverFlow. I've been on an Lisp bent lately, mainly Emacs Lisp. Think of a good question and ask it. You'll be throwing down breadcrumbs for the next guy who wants to learn an esoteric language. I've got 86 questions, and the last dozen have been mainly about Lisp, of some flavor. http://stackoverflow.com/users/5020/melling http://stackoverflow.com/users/5020/melling I'm going to turn Emacs Lisp into a mainstream developer tool. :-)
- bartl 17y agoStackOverflow is a help when you don't find the answer with Google. It's not really new: it's more a successor to Usenet which is getting quite dated -- especially since most of the old folks have abandoned it.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoThat's a bit silly, it's structurally unlike usenet. It's advantage is that due to its structure it has the S/N that usenet once did, which is much to its credit since usenet collapsed under the explosive growth of the internet yet stackoverflow appears to just get stronger with growth.
- abyssknight 17y agoA lot of those Google results are now coming from StackOverflow. Arguably, they've done a good job of centralizing programming Q&A and making it manageable. Certainly light years ahead of Experts Exchange.
- petercooper 17y agoIt seems to vary a lot by area. In my usual day-to-day Ruby mode, I rarely come across Stack Overflow. For a couple of weeks, though, I've been building an iPhone game and SO seems to come up all the time for Objective C and iPhone framework stuff.
- BigZaphod 17y agoI use Google to start the process of finding answers (often with results pointing to SO). But when it comes time to ask a question, I go to SO immediately and almost always get a reasonable answer within a few hours. The more this keeps happening, the more the Googling step will become irrelevant.
- ghosttrails 17y agoThis is the thing about SO that really works. You almost always get a good answer within hours of asking any programming question (that's been my experience anyway).
- fnid2 17y agoI wish they would change it back to the way it was when usenet was popular. Years ago, when I was looking for an answer, the first place I would go is dejanews and google destroyed that pretty much... so sad.
- jimbokun 17y agoI often check Google first, not find anything helpful in the first few pages, then remember to try StackOverflow, and have a much higher success rate. Actually, the best technique I've found is Google with "site:stackoverflow.com", as Google does a much better job searching StackOverflow than the built in search engine.