8 ms·
America's Jobless Future?
- johnohara 17y agoIn America, you are either self-employed or you're not. So-called "unemployment benefits" are taxed as income meaning you are actually self-employed while receiving them. It's a matter of perspective. Where does your income come from and how much is it? I'm an optimist. I believe growth in the production and movement of goods and services (the economy) will come from millions of people acting in their own self-interest. A massive collection of interconnected garages, basements, home-offices, libraries, schools, etc. -- all making stuff. Government can stimulate all it wants, but the heart and soul of our success has always come from individual initiative.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoDon't forget the economic role of cheap liquid fuels at relatively stable prices. Those days are over, probably for good. Any economic recovery is vulnerable as long as rising GDP triggers severe oil price volatility. Edit can the person who down-voted this please explain why?
- ccamrobertson 17y agoGovernment can stimulate all it wants, but the heart and soul of our success has always come from individual initiative. Agreed. It would seem then that it would make the most sense for government to focus on minimizing the overhead for formalizing those "individual initiatives" into businesses, rather than inefficiently allocate capital through stimulus (save all of the issues of how much of that stimulus capital is dissipated to essentially non-productive ends).
- flogic 17y agoI'm going to go out on a limb here. This is the inherent weakness of the capitalist system. Eventually productivity outstrips need. The process is kinda backwards but that seems to be the truth. In my world, a manager lays people off to save money. Then they realize work isn't getting done because they have less people. So they use automation to fill the gaps. Those jobs don't come back.
- stingraycharles 17y agoWho makes the automation possible?
- msluyter 17y agoWe do, for now, but for every one job created for a software/hardware engineer, several (probably low skill jobs) may be destroyed. Compare the total number of, say, cashiers to software developers.
- Nwallins 17y ago> Compare the total number of, say, cashiers to software developers. So, ATMS... would you replace them with human bank tellers? Would that be a net benefit to the economy?
- msluyter 17y agoNo, I mean, if it is indeed the case that the total number of jobs displaced by automation exceeds those generated by it, I have no particular take on how to handle it.
- Nwallins 17y agoMy point is that though automation "costs" jobs, it simultaneously reduces the cost of production (e.g. the production of financial transactions, here). Ultimately the benefit from more efficient production is a rising tide that lifts all ships. It would be hard to argue that reversing the industrial revolution and returning to cottage industries would be a net benefit, even though our current production levels would require 10-1000x as many jobs.
- dsplittgerber 17y agoBut the people laid off may found a great company afterwards. You look at the economy as a zero-sum game. But the pie is growing bigger nearly all the time.
- euroclydon 17y agoI'm over 3/4 of the way though the article and it just keeps getting more depressing. Somebody please hide all the sharp objects! I've felt for a while that high unemployment (20-30%) is the normal state of affairs. 20% of folks should probably be engaged in some sort of sustenance living. It wouldn't really have to be that bad, like digging in dumpsters or anything, but just living in a commune, farming, and building their own debt-free shelter.
- jcromartie 17y agoComfortable high-tech subsistence farming is around the corner. Efficient local renewable energy, RepRap machines, domestic robots... it's going to be a very interesting century.
- rcoder 17y agoFarmers are the original pioneers of "renewable energy." Their main energy source is sunshine, converted directly to foodstuffs by some amazing works of generic engineering (a.k.a. "plants). Biofuels? Yeah, they've been burning corn and vegetable oils for decades. Robots? How about biological labor aids -- horses, herding dogs, chickens, etc. Regardless, there's a reason you seldom hear "comfortable" and "subsistence farming" in the same sentence. Growing enough food to feed yourself is a full-time job, even with modern agricultural tech. Yeah, there could be a singularity-style event that makes traditional farming obsolete, but RepRaps and Roombas ain't it.
- sharms 17y agoIt is important to note that roles which are automated only require a shift in skill set. Cashiers may turn into Uscan machines, but Uscan machines require more administrators and support staff. With the money saved with the automated, the retailer may choose to cut prices, or reinvest in their business. If they cut prices, consumers now have money to invest in other industries, the demand spawning new positions. If they reinvest in their business, these positions, not previously open, will also be available. If they simply take their savings, and pay it out to share holders / keep it in the bank, this allows more capital for investment. The more steps that are automated, the more abundantly we will all live. It is a great thing in terms of material desires.
- DenisM 17y agofast forward: there is one person who is producing all our food and one person who is producing all out clothing. they trade with each other and the rest of the people have nothing to offer in return for food.
- sharms 17y agoIn this scenario, if there is only one person providing food, at that point it becomes economically viable for individuals and consumers alike to produce food, and fill that void. You didn't include it in your comment, however it is important to note how much each producer is producing. With economies of scale, it is likely both producers create enough goods to exceed the demand of either consumer. Rationale being if "food producer" became efficient enough to put all other food producers out of business, they likely can feed more than just the clothing producer.
- DenisM 17y agoThey could feed everyone but why would they? The rest of the people have nothing to offer in return. The reason why competing food manufacturing would be impossible to start in the era of absolute automation is that you need the machines to do that, in other words you need the capital. Who in their right mind would provide capital to manufacture food for people who have nothing to offer in return? I'm stretching the argument here, but only to illustrate the problem that I see - automation satisfies needs and thus destroys jobs tied to satisfying those needs. I see only two ways out of this - create new needs (which we've been doing successfully so far) or exert the power of the state to take the products from producers (progressively heavier taxation).
- CoryMathews 17y agoThe reason America is jobless is because everyone is in debt. People (talking majority) spend more then they make. They take out 3 year financing on toasters (exaggerated but sadly not much). To be in debt is a way of life. People buy things on credit long before they have the money to pay it off. Thats why America is in a recession and jobs are closing. If people (again majority) had common sense as most on HN seem to have then America would be fine. The second major reason IMO that America is going to be jobless is because the overhead cost of everything is far to high, especially in government. It takes so many people to sign off for anything that it will end up costing way more then it should. Take a look at large government states vs small government states and tell me which is doing better. (ie Cali vs Texas) Cali has to raise taxes to pay for all the overhead which causes business owners to pay more which causes them to not hire more people.. Pretty easy to see what needs to happen.
- sharms 17y agoI would love to disagree with you on this (my opinions on economics stray pretty far from normal). I believe precisely the reason America is so successful is because of debt. A worker who does not work a day never gains that day of work back. Debt allows workers to perform their tasks fully allocated as there is always work available, whether or not work has already been done in return for them. Ie if there was no debt, everyone would have to wait for a task to be finished before they could perform a service in return, causing lost work that can never be made up for. The only time this system falls flat is if everyone decides they need services all at once, which historically is not common.
- petercooper 17y agoTo be in debt is a way of life. People buy things on credit long before they have the money to pay it off. Like, say, houses? Or a college education? The problem isn't debt, per se - it's reaching a level of debt that can't be easily serviced by future earnings. Debt/credit is useful to invest in assets that return benefits to you over the period of paying the debt off. The ability to make these investments are a cornerstone of why the West has been so successful over the past 3-400 years.
- coolnewtoy 17y agoThere's an arugment in favor of elite brand-name degrees, presumeably over state universities, or vocational degrees: "The research of Till Von Wachter, the economist at Columbia University, suggests that not all people graduating into a recession see their life chances dimmed: those with degrees from elite universities catch up fairly quickly to where they otherwise would have been if they’d graduated in better times; it’s the masses beneath them that are left behind. Princeton’s 2009 graduating class found more jobs in financial services than in any other industry. According to Princeton’s career-services director, Beverly Hamilton-Chandler, campus visits and hiring by the big investment banks have been down, but that decline has been partly offset by an uptick in recruiting by hedge funds and boutique financial firms."
- va_coder 17y agoI read the book "New Ideas from Dead Economists" when I was in college. It's a great read. One of the recurring themes is how economists seem to always predict gloom and doom.
- 0wned 17y ago100 years ago they were predicting that the world would starve to death because of the industrial revolution. "All the people are moving off the farms, who will grow food to feed us? We will all starve to death. More and more babies are being born. The sky is falling!!!" They did not count on technology increasing food production and making it more efficient. Today, food is so plentiful and convenient that we're all too fat. To hell with economists and meteorologists too. Both groups attempt to predict the unpredictable. Why believe anything they say... ever?
- ciupicri 17y agoI think that we should also have a look at the quality of food. While the quantity of available food has increased and you can find cheap food, it's quality has decreased dramatically.
- kowen 17y agoIt seems to me that we have the resources and technology to solve a lot of problems for good, but a permanent (or even just "better") solution would get in the way of profit. (I saw the documentary "who killed the electric car" recently, which describes one instance of this.) There was a discussion here on HN a few weeks back about automating and simplifying taxes http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1072955 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1072955 Automating and simplifying certainly seems like the right thing to do - but lots of people would lose jobs. On the other hand, they would be free to do something more productive (in the larger sense, producing value instead of papering over the cracks) and certainly more interesting! Why can't we just automate away the boring stuff, and just work less? I'd be interested to see if it were possible to open source more than software. (Open source organic farming, anyone?) I know, I know, this is utopian and unrealistic and probably plain silly. I'm not trying to suggest that we should all go create a hippie commune and get rid of money, but not solving a problem right because of some legalese or pure profit just seems wrong to me! Another thing that I find perplexing is that the depression doesn't only put people with automatable jobs out of work. My father is an extremely talented craftsman. He builds traditional log cabins, wooden boats, furniture, beautiful houses... Right now he is living in a van, and not-quite eeking out a living picking fruit. He sells a couple hundred lbs of fruit a few days a week. He also shoots deer every once in a while which provides protein. He's this great resource, but hasn't had a job for well over 2 years. If he didn't have to worry about food, he'd work for the sheer pleasure of creating something useful and beautiful. The thing that confuses and frustrates me is that my father would be delighted to work for free provided that his needs were met (seriously! Food, a beautiful view, a sauna, and some poetry. Seems simple enough, right?) He loves to build beautiful things, and certainly there are people who need houses (even small log cabins would be an upgrade for many). I don't know what the solution is (obviously). It just seems strange that legal tender or lack thereof could get in the way of creating real value.
- ippisl 17y agoAnother scenario of the automation vs jobs is, very unstable economy job-wise, for long terms. many many people would experience large periods of unemployment , a constant need to shift jobs and professions , and all the psycho-social negatives that come with this. This might become a basic nature of the economy as automation becomes more rapid. some might even say it's already happening. I think we would need to optimize economies for well being , instead of GDP to solve this.
- fnid2 17y agoI think it's really tragic what is happening to the youth in america. they have no power, no wealth, no experience, no education, no skills, no credit... nothing. People who are older have worked and gathered all the above and still, congress gives them more. More drugs to keep them living longer and sapping the system. Free health care. Social Security, reduced taxes in the form of mortgage credits, dividend and capital gains discounts... It's really pathetic. Until the younger generation combines their voting power (if they'll start voting at all), they will not be listened to and will continue to suffer. With even 10% pooled voting power, they can control the outcome of nearly every election in the nation, local and national. If all people aged 18 to 35 vote for the same person, that person will win. If a person caters to that demographic and listens to them and makes the future of America and the world better for them then it will be better also for the older generation. But the older generation votes and the younger generation does not.
- sabat 17y agoUltimately, innovation is what allows an economy to grow quickly and create new jobs as old ones obsolesce and disappear. Typically, one salutary side effect of recessions is that they eventually spur booms in innovation. Some laid-off employees become entrepreneurs, working on ideas that have been ignored by corporate bureaucracies, while sclerotic firms in declining industries fail, making way for nimbler enterprises. But according to the economist Edmund Phelps, the innovative potential of the U.S. economy looks limited today. He had me until the end, where Edmund Phelps declares innovation in America is "limited". HAH. Watch our smoke, Ed!
- Groxx 17y agoHe's probably pulling from the brain-drain problem we've been having since schools started to go down the creek. Arguably, our environment is also hostile to newcomers many times, due to patently absurd patent laws and higher business taxes than many places (not all, mind you, just many).
- sabat 17y agoBrain drain problem? What, all the entrepreneurs are moving to India and I didn't hear about it? ;-) The US may be "hostile" to newcomers -- you're right, we do have stupid patent laws and some of the business taxes can seem ridiculous -- but then again, most countries have stupid patent laws (see the WIPO) and many many countries tax business at much more aggressive rates. Even more importantly, if we're talking about technology: Silicon Valley has never been replicated full-scale. Yes, there are pockets. But what draws people to Northern California -- aside from the unique culture, natural beauty, and the weather -- is that there has been an innovation pow-wow going on since Hewlett and Packard took to the garage. People want in on that, especially if they're into innovation themselves. There are more startups starting up right now, especially here in CA, than I've seen in years. Not all will innovate, but many will, and at least some of that innovation will stick and maybe even change the world. No innovation? Really? Has this guy seen the frickin' iPod? Oh, and heard of Twitter? (Just to name some easy examples.)
- 17y ago