7 ms·
I don't understand how "each robot has to be custom built for each building" and "takes two years to build". I mean, they don't need Atlas here. They just need
by taneq 11y ago
I don't understand how "each robot has to be custom built for each building" and "takes two years to build".
I mean, they don't need Atlas here. They just need a ruggedized remote control car with a camera and a ton of lead plate on it.
- anon4 11y agoGovernment Bureaucracy.
- leereeves 11y agoJust going by what the article says, it sounds like more than an RC car: robots, which can swim under water and negotiate obstacles in damaged tunnels and piping to search for the melted fuel rods. to find and remove the extremely dangerous blobs of melted fuel rods, weighing hundreds of tonnes
- taneq 11y agoIf it's flooded, just use a commercial underwater ROV. The oil and gas industry has been using them for decades. You don't need a hundred-tonne robot to find a fuel rod, so they can at least get that part sorted. Once they know where they are, build something super rugged (I'm thinking basically a remote controlled shielded fork lift) to do the lifting.
- breischl 11y agoYou seem to be assuming that it's entirely flooded. Seems probable that there are areas that are partially flooded, entirely flooded, or flooded and filled with wreckage. ie, an open water ROV may not be at all appropriate. Certainly if the answer was actually as simple as "buy this off the shelf thing" then all the smart people over there would've figured that out at some point in the last 3 years.
- BillinghamJ 11y agoA friend of mine actually works on these kinds of robots. It's a complex process. They can't risk creating a situation worse than before, and nuclear facilities are pretty sensitive. They usually create 1/4 scale models of the buildings they'll be working with for testing, etc. - it's a big deal.
- hobs 11y agoWow, that sounds really cool, do you/your friend have any further reading?
- emp_zealoth 11y agoseconded, any reading material would be awesome
- BillinghamJ 11y agoHe has posted about it. See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11267526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11267526
- taneq 11y agoAre these robots operating fully autonomously? If so, why?
- RyanMcGreal 11y agoPart of the problem is that the R&D has not been done. Under the Myth of Nuclear Safety, Japan has absolutely neglected to do research into designing and building robots that can handle high levels of radiation (if people are working on robots that can handle hazardous environments inside a reactor, that might inadvertently communicate the idea that nuclear power is dangerous).
- Agustus 11y agoThere is no Myth of Nuclear Safety, all energy production has known pro's and con's and approaches are made to mitigate these risk factors. Nuclear energy's risk factors are the easiest to swallow for the waste output. The Fukushima reactor was built to withstand a huge amount of risk factors, they just all happened at the same time. The risk mitigation concept would be to say that you need to design a house to withstand a 10,000 year storm.
- digitalneal 11y agoDoes the US have these kinda Robots or are "we" also under the myth of Nuclear Safety?
- x0x0 11y agoOf course we don't. If we did, we would have given them to Japan. Also, nuclear power advocates in the US would, imo, really not like Fukushima to be a decades long demonstration of the risks of nuclear power. Which it is going to be.
- TotesAThrowAway 11y agoFriend of BillinghamJ here. We do build mock facilities and we have recently started working on the Fukushima Daiichi inspections, and there is only so much I can actually say but I'll share what I can. I'll explain what caused the failure in this part and then I'll move onto the fun stuff in the next post (robots!). In the past, the mock facilities we have made in the past were a quarter of a full scale reactor, rather than a quarter scale reactor, if that makes any sense at all. Anyway back to Japan. I'm assuming people have a basic understanding of how fission reactors work (Boiling Water Reactors if you are interested in doing further reading). To break the situation down, the cooling failed (believe it or not, diesel generators don't work too well on water!) on reactors 1, 2 and 3, causing a complete meltdown of the fuel rods. When cooling failed, all of the cooling water was turned into steam, which in turn reacted with the released radioactive isotopes creating hydrogen. I'm assuming people know mixing hydrogen with oxygen is basically a recipe for an explosion, and that is important for what happened next. They tried to vent the gases out to the atmosphere to prevent the pressure vessel from exploding, but the hydrogen went the wrong way and caused reactors 1 through to 3 to explode in various places. I can't remember correctly (I think its reactor 3?) but the explosion happened within the pressure vessel which is why there was a large contamination breach. Because of this complete loss of control of the reactors, and the meltdown currently happening, they flooded the whole system with sea water and pumped as much out into storage as they can, but they lose a lot of it out to the sea, hence the Americans whining about the radiation in the Pacific. Now, the reactors are stable (ish) and they are continuing to pump water in to stop them going critical again. I'll move onto the robots when I get home in part two, but right now I need to go have an argument with a lawn mower as my hair is getting unruly. The video linked below explains more about the actual failure of the reactor:- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMaEjEWL6PU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMaEjEWL6PU Brb.
- TotesAThrowAway 11y agoI should probably also mention there's 6 reactors on site, 4, 5 and 6 were relatively unharmed by the tsunami and 5 and 6 could actually be turned back on. However for obvious reasons they have been decommissioned and wont be turned on ever again.
- barkingcat 11y agoI think you're oversimplifying it. The temperatures are unpredictable, with molten nuclear fuel possibly at 2000 degrees celcius (it might not be there because it's since cooled down, maybe there are temperature probes that can tell you what the current situation is) There are gases circulating around, free hydrogen gas, volatile gases that could explode if exposed to a spark - so the robot has to be built to not spark or have inert mechanisms for turning, moving, etc. Parts are submerged, so this robot needs to be water tight to irradiated water and have some mechanism of moving when submerged (buoyancy control). Radiation is the highest danger to electronics, it's said that all the wires degrade, all the parts of the robot steadily break down when trying to get inside. The chips and control circuitry needs to be radiation hardened, and I bet the "wires" the article refers to means servo control wires - which needs to be linked to servos that are on the limbs - so it's harder to shield. (whereas control chips, the cpu, etc can be shielded by lead plates in a central location)