4 ms·
Is there a reciprocal duty on the part of responsible climate change supporters to admit that data has been destroyed to prevent it from being analyzed by skept
by patio11 17y ago
Is there a reciprocal duty on the part of responsible climate change supporters to admit that data has been destroyed to prevent it from being analyzed by skeptical researchers, and that there has been a explicit, documented campaign to destroy the professional reputations of journals which publish papers critical of what is often called the consensus?
If there is no such reciprocal obligation, I'd be interested in knowing why not, because both of those are documented in the "Climategate" emails and subsequent follow-on investigation. (e.g. The data that Jones threatened to destroy rather than allow to get hit with a Freedom of Information request was indeed requested and is, indeed, beyond recovery.)
- necubi 17y agoYes, there have been mistakes and imperfect scientists working on climate change. But you can find such foibles in nearly every scientific field—and very rarely do they shake the foundations. For example: evolution. I hope we can all agree that evolution and natural selection form a stunningly successful model of the diversity found in the natural world. This is the position of virtually every biologist and is really only opposed by fundamentalist crazies. Despite this, there have been many mistakes in the history of evolution (for example, the Piltdown Man) that have served to weaken its public credible. However, despite these errors there was never anything fundamentally wrong with the underlying theory. Scientists make mistakes, for both good reasons and bad. But to use a few isolated incidents to cast aspersions on an entire field suggests that you have already come to a conclusion and are looking for evidence, however tenuous, to support it. Your criticisms are at their heart intellectually vacuous and are not sufficient to cast down decades of research by thousands of very smart, dedicated people.
- cletus 17y ago"Making mistakes" as you call it is a white wash. Refusing to publish data, actively obstructing efforts to get that data, selective sampling and black-box "massaging" of raw data essentially invalidate any conclusion drawn from that data. The essence of the scientific process is reproducability. Anything that isn't reproducible or at least testable is worthless. Anything built on it is worthless. It's like some physicist somewhere announcing to the world "I've proven the existence of the Higgs Boson" and then refusing to tell you how he did it.
- Adam503 17y agoFail, Cletus. What it's actually like is doing the 10 to the x repeat of Newton seeing and Apple dropping an from a tree, the apple landing on the foot of a research assistant standing under the tree. The scientist says, "Ooops, I should have told my research assistant to get out from under the tree." While Cletus, Sarah Palin, and a few in denial friends go running off to Fox News and announce "I saw Jesus cancel gravity. It's a sign from God."
- cromulent 17y agoIn relation to the physicist analogy, isn't there in this case a lot of other physicists saying that they saw similar things?
- fleitz 17y agoScience is not a democracy. It's a method for deriving knowledge from observation. We need the observations to evaluate the conclusions, not a bunch of hearsay. If other scientists are seeing the same things they should provide the data and methodology so that it can be evaluated independently.
- cromulent 17y agoThat's true - science is a method for deriving knowledge from observation. So, if many scientists are observing, one scientists' secrecy and falsification does not make the other findings "worthless".
- CWuestefeld 17y agoAgree. When you drop the test tube, or accidentally misplace the decimal point, that's "a mistake". But when you intentionally and systematically subvert ethics and the scientific method, that's not "a mistake". That's evil.
- Adam503 17y agoNo. Human beings make mistakes. It's a known quantity in any and all research done by human beings. Does anyone have to open up a lecture about geologic features on Mars with preliminary statement... "At one point during the Mars data gathering process a probe was programmed wrong with incorrect Imperial/Metric conversions, a probe crashed, and therefore none of the measurements we give of anything on the Mars surface can ever be trusted again." No.
- cletus 17y agoThat's a specious argument that does nothing other than demonstrate the obvious agenda that you have.
- Adam503 17y agoScience has no agenda. Science has what's factual and what is not factual. You have an agenda. Your agenda is to attempt to make facts and opinions carry the same weight in a political debate. Never gonna happen, cletus.
- cletus 17y agoWho said anything about science in general? You attempted to make an analogy between the deliberate destruction of raw data and the metric-Imperial mismatch that caused the failure of the Mars Orbiter mission somehow impugning all data on Mars. Not equivalent. Not even close. If you don't get that you're either blinded by zealotry or simply lack the capacity to formulate or evaluate logic.
- Adam503 17y agoFail, Cletus. What it's actually like is doing the 10 to the x repeat of Newton seeing and Apple dropping an from a tree, the apple landing on the foot of a research assistant standing under the tree. The scientist says, "Ooops, I should have told my research assistant to get out from under the tree." While Cletus, Sarah Palin, and a few in denial friends go running off to Fox News and announce "I saw Jesus cancel gravity. It's a sign from God."