6 ms·
A look at the Technology behind the 4D Game Miegakure [video]
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoWhat the hell is a 4D game? I just hate buzzwords.
- krmkaos 11y agoIt's not a buzzword though, the game is actually 4D.
- corysama 11y agoThe landscape of the game is literally 4-dimensional geometry.
- lifeformed 11y agoWatch the video?
- kordless 11y agoWhat the hell is a video? I couldn't resist.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoA 2D slice of a 3D object.
- 77pt77 11y agoProjection, not slice.
- wolfgke 11y agoAn image of a video is a slice of it for some constant time coordinate. If you instead fix a spatial coordinate you get images as the two left and center images in > http://electronicimaging.spiedigitallibrary.org/data/Journals/ELECTIM/929595/JEI_23_1_013016_f002.png http://electronicimaging.spiedigitallibrary.org/data/Journal...
- 77pt77 11y agoYou changed the assertion because you're including time. The parent said "A 2D slice of a 3D object." And that's wrong, it's a 2D projection of a 3D object. If you include time then it's a slice in the time component, right, but that wasn't being discussed.
- wolfgke 11y agoThe third dimension is time. Videos can also be generated without using projections (though cameras use this method).
- logfromblammo 11y agoTime is a different type of dimension than the spatial dimensions. If you're really going to bring time into it, you need to use a dimensional signature, wherein one number represents dimensions that square to a positive number, another represents dimensions that square to a negative number, and another represents dimensions that square to zero. A video is either {2,1,0}-D or {1,2,0}-D, depending on the mathematical sign convention you chose for your spacelike dimensions. When people use a single number, they invariably mean spacelike dimensions, as null dimensions and multiple timelike dimensions tend to give people the screaming jibblies when they try to visualize them.
- kordless 11y agoI think it's not a slice. If you sliced reality in half you'd see the cross-section of whatever you sliced in half, as opposed to that multi-planer cow standing over there beyond the slice point. Our 2D version of the 3D world we perceive to inhabit is projecting (and mixing) light that falls on the back of our eye. It's a highly dynamic and contextual environment backed by the absolutely best encryption known anywhere. Other simulations, while cost effective, can't compete with our reality's reliability. Call today for your free trial!
- colordrops 11y agoSounds like you didn't watch the video.
- kelvin0 11y agoLike magnets, how do those work? Sorry, had to put that ICP meme, just too easy.
- Analemma_ 11y agoStill sounds wonderful, but when's the damn thing coming out? I first heard about Miegakure in an xkcd from 6 years ago, and was immediately ready to hand over my money. It's been hard to maintain that enthusiasm through one and a half Presidential terms...
- yexponential 11y ago"What you see is a 2D projection of a 3D slice of a 4D object". Poetry.
- wangii 11y agois the avatar in the game 3D or 4D?
- wnkrshm 11y agoif they make the argument that the 3D level geometry is a slice of 4D geometry, then a 3D animation frame of the character is also a slice of 4D geometry (the 4D geometry interpolated from 3D keyframes and timing curves)
- zardo 11y agoA 4d collision boundary would limit the players ability to explore, just taking a few steps would require solving a 4d puzzle.
- marctenbosch 11y agoThe avatar is 3D with some 4D thickness.
- logicrook 11y agoMost of the transcript of the video is on the main page (http://miegakure.com/ http://miegakure.com/), along with illustrative images and gifs. They evoke how their inspiration was flatland, which when I read it I found strikingly unimaginative. To explain, the characters are 2D objects; the book describes some of the problems these beings encounter, but doesn't really solve them, so the described society doesn't really hold up. One instance is that their field of vision is just a line with a dimension for color, so you need to see a form move into space to understand what it is (maybe I'm wrong, but I think the author does not say clearly that points do bear some 'depth' and 'texture' information, otherwise this wouldn't work). But there are creative ways to solve these problems: for example the beings could 'see' using a bat-like interpretations of echoes to get a sense of the space around them (we see in 3D, not in 2D). Life under different constraints ends up having different features than us humans. So in a sense, it is a bit like somebody who would stumble upon a mathematical paradox (say, the barber's one) and would just deduce 'how funny are words and numbers' (well, a bit like Lewis Caroll).
- arijun 11y agoI think the real cleverness of that book is the comparison of 2D creatures to 3D, and use that to guide our otherwise non-existent intuition of what 4D space would look like. I could imagine one thinking of that analogue before reading the book, making it seem less novel. But you have to remember that we've lived in a society that's had that book for nearly 150 years, so it would not be surprising if some of the ideas from the book became a mainstream meme.
- logicrook 11y agoBut Erewhon came in 1872, and contained many ideas that are still very strong (emergent life, creation of the technological system and clash with the ancient order (Church))... It's a bit like the 'Seinfeld is unfunny' trope; even at the time, some people found it unfunny. It does not mean that this effect does not play a role, but you seldom hear "well, Copernicus is such a greaaat guy for discovering that the Earth revolves around the Sun", while it does suffer from it. And I wouldn't be surprised if the Greeks had devised such stories illustrating some mathematical concepts; it's just that more than 150 years ago, the audience for 'geeky stories' was not so big, as well as the potential writers for such stories weren't so numerous (although Gauss seems a bit cheeky on his portrait). HN just wasn't there.
- radarsat1 11y agoBeautiful. Get someone else to narrate the video. But beautiful.
- jasonkostempski 11y agoI don't know if it changed since your comment but there was absolutely nothing wrong with the narration.
- Mithaldu 11y agoAs a non-native english speaker: He absolutely rushes through his explanation at break-neck pace, and he rarely changes the tone of his voice from a droning monotone. For me that makes it incredibly difficult to process and retain anything he talks about.
- elevenfist 11y agoAs a native speaker he was speaking at a fairly normal pace, and his intonation was fine, just more subtle. Voices like his are not uncommon, especially in engineering. That being said, based on his accent it is possible that english is not be his first language.
- raus22 11y agoBut is it fun? The 4d is good and all, but is it playable and enjoyable. Otherwise it is just a gimmick, a cool gimmick but a gimmick.
- lobo_tuerto 11y agoKey sentence: "When you finally get to play Miegakure" When it's going to be released!? Been waiting a long time now...
- bladedtoys 11y agoAs the creator of a 4D game, I can attest how hard it is to make such a thing fun. Even though simpler, I think what I built is only partially successful at this. In the end I think the audience for my toy and Marc's game will only be people excited about new concepts and toying with theoretical math ideas where the bulk of the fun is just from that rather than game play. I believe much of a game's fun comes from matching the users existing abstract ideas about the world. I suspect that 4D manipulation of objects is so deeply counter intuitive that doing this is extremely difficult. But I for one will be thrilled by any from of Miegakure that is ever released whatever it's state or level of fun.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThis is amazing. It matches the description I read in Michio Kaku's Hyperspace as a kid. Except the visuals, although similar, were said to be blobs. I'm not sure. I like that the game creates the ability to move through a 4D space while seeing the effects in 3D. The fundamental is great. Also, how a 4D person might move through walls via the fourth dimension. I think an even more interesting angle might happen if a game tries to break the assumption that 4D movement is wide open: put obstacles in the way where a person must use intuition to navigate it by making a 2D/3D map of that space as well. Maybe the game does that, too.
- malvim 11y agoYeah, amazing work, and so beautiful! What I ended up thinking was how we can always see what's ahead in 2d / 3d (of course, without obstacles), and how we cannot see anything in the fourth dimension in this particular world. Could this ability be somehow recreated for 4D? Looking ahead/behind, being aware of what's happening "nearby" on the fourth axis? Very interesting, look forward to more news about this game!
- marctenbosch 11y agoThanks! Each puzzle is about doing some crazy thing that only a 4D being could do, such as binding two rings without breaking them, or stealing something from a building that is closed from all sides but not in the fourth dimension. We'll show more of that soon.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"such as binding two rings without breaking them" I can't wait to see that.