18 ms·
The New Mind Control – The internet has spawned subtle forms of influence
- jamesblonde 11y agoAs a adjunct to this great read, you find out more about this field through the historical documentary, "The century of the Self" by Adam Curtis and the BBC. It is the 'red pill' for understanding consumerism. https://vimeo.com/10245146 https://vimeo.com/10245146
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoBeat me to it. Also recommended to read Bernays' works themselves, particularly "Crystallizing Public Opinion" and "Propaganda." Its like reading an engineer's manual for social control.
- jamesblonde 11y agoYeah, Bernays is great. He called it 'propeganda' to begin with - but realized that it needed a better name. So he called it 'public relations'. The best thing about PR is that people who practice PR have PR practiced on them - they don't even know the history of PR. Curtis' documentary is the best source I have come across for the history of PR. But this article is quite something. It helps explain the Trump effect - just get on the news/social-media and you will get more votes. Those who can manipulate the media, there's is the kingdom of power...
- samsolomon 11y agoAs someone with a degree in public relations, this simply not true. Edward Bernays is the first person covered in Introduction to Public Relations classes. Do journalists, corporate communication professionals or others who end up in PR know him? That is up for debate. EDIT: Clarity
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoSpeaking of that trend, it is worth noting the British use of propaganda during WWI, particularly the Bryce Report and the Rape of Belgium. Much of modern propaganda owes to that watershed period. Bernays mentions it in Public Relations. Goebbels himself acknowledged it. [1] [1] http://research.calvin.edu/german-propaganda-archive/goeb27.htm http://research.calvin.edu/german-propaganda-archive/goeb27....
- _han 11y agoThis topic is also addressed in the last season of House of Cards.
- manachar 11y agoThis read like anti-Google FUD. The basic argument is search engine rank determines trustworthiness of a source. This influences people's opinions on politics, what they buy, what they think, etc. This is absolutely true, and the core of their research (it seems). But then it goes into FUD territory when talking about Google backing Hillary. Hillary and Trump have received the lion's share of attention in media, social media, and such. Google searches SHOULD show them prominently. Worse, the article basically finishes up with a "be afraid, be very afraid" approach that rankles me. "The new hidden persuaders are bigger, bolder and badder than anything Vance Packard ever envisioned. If we choose to ignore this, we do so at our peril." No solutions or deeper analysis. No discussions on how a search engine should rank relevancy to search terms. I personally have no doubt that mass-media, marketing, and the internet are shapers of opinions. Bias in the media, search engines, and such is a complex topic. Not something that should boil down to "Google could make it so Hillary wins" therefore you should be afraid.
- jamesblonde 11y agoThe article provides both scientifically acquired evidence and some analysis. That's more than your comment provides, IMO.
- manachar 11y agoIt provides evidence that search engine rankings influence opinion, which I do not doubt. From a business perspective SEO exists for this very reason. It also provides evidence that Google as a company likely supports Hillary to at least some degree. Of this I also have no doubt. But it uses FUD to say you should connect the dots and state that Google is actively manipulating rankings to assist a particular candidate. Of this, they provide no evidence other than "they could". It's that last bit I take issue with. There's no analysis to support this notion. If they did such an analysis I'd be very impressed as it would very much help discuss the deeper issues of Google's power over opinion. Essentially, Google is the portal to information for most people. They are a private company operating for profit that uses an algorithm that must be secret for it to work. I understand the unease with that situation and enjoy reading discussions about it. However, their choice to essentially accuse Google of altering their algorithm to support Hillary is unsupported at this time. By adding it in it hurts their broader argument that gatekeepers of information should be subject to increased scrutiny and potentially to new regulations to ensure their neutrality.
- md224 11y agoI have made this case before, but I will make it again. The Internet is the largest information system in the world, and Google is the primary portal into that information system. Google's "organic" results are accompanied by AdWords results, which are based on a mixture of bid price and relevance. These ads are marked with a small "Ad" label that many people miss, and even those who know they're ads can't really "unsee" those results. So, searching the world's largest information system provides results which have been biased by money. How does anyone consider this ethical? Why are we letting money influence the salience of information? What if your local library (you know, those old things) had a card catalog with "sponsored" results? If this already exists, then maybe we're already lost. But it seems to me that as a basic rule of information ethics, the salience of information in a given information system should not be biased by monetary influence. Full stop, the end, no exceptions. If anyone has a counterargument, I would honestly love to hear it, because this has nagged at me for a long time. I simply can't understand how AdWords is ethical.
- ntumlin 11y agoI don't think it's so bad, and more importantly I don't see the solution. Google does what it does to make money, and ads are how it does that. If there's a more ethical solution it'll only be implemented if it's also more profitable. All that is fine with me; Google doesn't have any obligations to me or you or anyone besides their shareholders.
- TaylorAlexander 11y ago"I don't see any problem with the way the world's most powerful system for freeing the mind has been co-opted by for-profit enterprise. I am ignorant of any possible alternatives. Capitalist businesses sell goods and services in exchange for money. I accept that no effort will be made to find more ethical alternatives unless it can produce even more money. We as a society have no control or influence over what individual actors do, and thus no discussion of possible alternatives is necessary."
- vezzy-fnord 11y ago
- r0m4n0 11y agoThe internet is just a new medium to persuade opinions just as the many before it. Most people don't even know who represents them apart from what's talked about in the news. This study required people to actually browse through this fake search engine. I'm not convinced many people do any research whatsoever (beyond the top of the ballot). Does this "search engine manipulation effect" have an impact on top of the ballot votes? We still don't know. Does it have an impact on everyone else on your ballot? Nope. Disclosure... I am the founder of a company that builds a tool for organizations to blatantly tell people who to vote for...
- guelo 11y agoThis is a really interesting study but it's hard for me to believe in the conspiracy theory that the hundreds of engineers that work on Google Search would be OK implementing a complicated vote manipulation algorithm and keeping it secret. But it's possible, criminal conspiracies involving many people seem to happen regularly in the financial industry.
- mtgx 11y agoI'm not sure it would happen in such an obvious way. It would probably happen in a way that "makes sense" for most of those people, and not from a "let's manipulate the votes" perspective. I'll give an example. The establishment corporate media is already biased. That much has been clear this election (although it's been happening for many years or even decades). The Internet is "pretty free" right now, and people can Google, or go on Twitter and see "news" that doesn't necessarily come from that establishment media. However, that is already starting to change. Google, Facebook, and Twitter can all change that by giving "brand name" media much better ranking results through their algorithms. In some cases, such as with the recent "AMP" project, these companies won't even have to rely on good search ranking. They just benefit from having partnerships with Google and being shown at the top of the page automatically. What this means is that the corporate media's brainwashing continues almost unfettered going into the future. The upside is that people can still look for other sources and views on the Internet, while they can't really do that on TV. So in that way the Internet is still better (as long as it doesn't start implementing "ISIS & others filters" with a new US president. But the portals through which most people get their information are getting tighter and tighter relationships with establishment corporate media, and voter education will suffer for that. Ideally, what I'd like Google to do, unless it actually wants that kind of "bias" on its search pages (whether it comes from the results or otherwise), is for them to use their increasingly more advanced AI to figure out which elections stories are "biased" and fact-free, and which are the closest to the facts and use the least biased language in them. "Journalism" is supposed to be about the facts, and Google search should be promote that kind of stories over the biased hit-jobs. And Google should also verify those facts itself with its AI, so it shouldn't just promote stories with false "facts". It's not going to be easy to do something like that well enough, but I think Google could do it, and I think AI has reached a point where that may be within its grasp within a few years.
- mtgx 11y agoTraditional media entities aren't without their flaws: http://fair.org/home/washington-post-ran-16-negative-stories-on-bernie-sanders-in-16-hours/ http://fair.org/home/washington-post-ran-16-negative-stories... http://www.thenation.com/article/the-discourse-suffers-when-trump-gets-23-times-as-much-coverage-as-sanders/ http://www.thenation.com/article/the-discourse-suffers-when-...
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoMind control in the same way encyclopedias used to favor subjects that start with the letter A? I swear, sometimes I think the world is inhabited by p-zombies, who don't actually think things through, but just mindlessly recombine previously consumed memes into (slightly) novel variants. Was this written by a second grader?
- daveloyall 11y agoRelated: https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/12/personalized-search-for-everyone.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/12/personalized-search-... "Personalized Search for everyone " (2009)
- ashurbanipal 11y agoHold on, so we call it "Mind Control" when Google shifts our preferences toward one of two pre-selected choices? What do we call the state of the world that leaves us with only 2 pre-selected choices who happen to agree on 90%+ of all policies?
- J_Darnley 11y agoInevitable. Do you really think the power brokers let you have a real choice?
- EGreg 11y agoNot power brokers. It's an emergent phenomenon predicted by public choice theory. http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=212 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=212
- nunyabuizness 11y agoAlso, this CGP Grey video explains how a first-past-the-post voting system all-but-guarantees a two party system to emerge over time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo
- J_Darnley 11y agoWould you like to replace it with proportional representation? You thought a few day government shutdown was bad? Try 500 days.
- germanier 11y agoThen how do you explain the missing government shutdowns in all the countries with proportional representation? Even in Belgium, where they had a long time without a new government after an election, government services were provided just fine.
- forgottenpass 11y ago
- hellbanner 11y agoSo on this note, I just want to point out that everytime the horrors of the new technologies is talked about, something else isn't talked about. I've seen a number of newer HN account flooding the site with articles... presumably for eyeballs + ad revenue but hey, maybe they just want another link to lose attention..
- hotcool 11y agoI designed supraliminal posters[1] to counter the covert forms of persuasion like Low Attention Processing marketing[2]. I definitely find them helpful, especially for meditation. [1] http://zenpusher.com http://zenpusher.com [2] http://www.neurosciencemarketing.com/blog/articles/low-attention-branding.htm http://www.neurosciencemarketing.com/blog/articles/low-atten...
- soared 11y agoDo you think [2] is a bad thing, and why?
- Mindless2112 11y agoGoogle doesn't need to use search results to manipulate voting behavior -- they have Google Now. Google Now currently displays cards to remind people to vote on voting day. Maybe it just happens to be more likely to show up for people that have been profiled as likely to vote for Google's favored candidate.
- incarnate 11y agoThey may not even have to target their message. If a platform's users already have a bias (and this seems to be the case[0]), then they can display the "go vote" message globally and have the desired affect. All while waving the public good PR flag. This assumes the platform's wishes aligns with their users, but this may be self-fulfilling. [0] http://www.pewinternet.org/fact-sheets/politics-fact-sheet/ http://www.pewinternet.org/fact-sheets/politics-fact-sheet/
- alanwatts 11y agoI got a card notification the other day about Hillary winning in some state and I thought to myself, why the hell am I seeing this?
- nsxwolf 11y agoSomething like this recently disturbed me. Mitt Romney published a tweet storm a few days ago making his case against Donald Trump. They all showed up in my feed - I don't follow Romney, and the tweets weren't marked as sponsored, but somehow Twitter decided I should be seeing them anyway. I'd hate to think Twitter decided it was for the public good that everyone read what Romney had to say about Trump.
- x5n1 11y agoHow do you think the media mughals made their billions. They made them doing exactly this.
- 13thLetter 11y agoUnfortunately that train has already left the station, and to thunderous applause from the media. Twitter already carefully curates hashtags; it's not hard to imagine they'd take the liberty of promoting a series of tweets that they feel are important.
- ryandetzel 11y agoThis simply is not true. Oh, wait, you're spreading your subtle forms of influence.
- ryandetzel 11y agoIt's a recommendation engine, it's not Twitter decided everyone should read it. Obviously you read, follow, consume content related to this so the algorithm decided you'd probably like Romney's tweets too (because they were super popular)
- erikpukinskis 11y agoGoogle could send people to places that are contrary to the user's interest, but that's essentially deliberately decreasing the quality of one of their products so I'm not that worried about it. If they do it's a (big) market opportunity for someone else. I would go even farther: I'm not particularly worried about individual interests at all, on any subject. The Internet is very good at exposing them. I am much more concerned with bad classes of actors than bad actors. We see many ways in which competition breaks down because entire classes of people benefit from working in synchrony. The classic example is politicians: crooked elections mean longer terms which benefits basically all of them. The other classic example is the capital class. If everyone in the capital class plays by he rules of property then they can exploit the labor class. Once you're in the capital class there are few reasons to compete with private property. Social pressure mostly neuters whatever capital class activists might try to keep working. It's these class barriers that we should be worried about. But new weapons (like search engines) and new villains (like Islam) make much better news stories.
- tdaltonc 11y agoIt's not trivial to ascertain what a users "interests" are. And I think that's the debate here. Google optimization algorithms are an embodiment of a value system, and maybe I don't agree with it. McDonalds also gives people what they want, but only in a very narrow sense of 'want'.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoIt doesn't really matter if it's trivial. It's in Google's interest to do it so it tends to happen. McDonalds isn't really uniquely bad. Burger King, Jack in the Box, et al are basically the same. They are a perfect example of what I described: a class of actors to whom there is benefit to acting in concert against the best interests of consumers.
- EGreg 11y agoThis article is speaking about something that has existed as long as mass media has. Whether it's google or newspapers or TV, the companies running the sources we turn to have control over what information we are exposed to, and can influence our views. Our grandfathers read the newspaper, our parents watched TV. What, google is a monopoly? Ok, so that's the big issue. On the other hand, our susceptibility to having our political system be disproportionately affected by a company or two with a top-down chain of command is a reflection that our system of representative democracy has weak links and can be easily subverted. I wrote about the solution to this a while back: replace voting with polling! Have people cast their voice for POLICIES not REPRESENTATIVES. It is much more costly to fool all the people all the time, than to fool them at election time, and then go on to lobby the representatives they chose. Voting depends on turnout, which skews the results and is susceptible to sybil attacks (remember facebook's vote about the newsfeed that got 3% turnout?) Polling doesn't. It can be refined using better and better statisical techniques. We can gradually replace costly and stupid elections where candidates talk about their penis, with polling of the population on issues like gun control etc. Replace the bickering lawmakers and filibusters with polling and threshholds. http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=212 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=212
- a_imho 11y ago>I wrote about the solution to this a while back: replace voting with polling! That is an implementation detail which might lead to a more fair system. Nevertheless it is not a solution to the real problem, which is creating the incentive to move away from the current status quo. (side: you may be interested in the link in my profile)
- labster 11y agoIt's looking like our only hope left is the recently declassified WMF search engine. I get that people didn't like Lila doing all of that grant in secret, but I find myself not really opposed to to Wikimedia taking on Google. In the long term, someone is going to have to do it.
- justsaysmthng 11y agoI remember the '90s, when the Internet as we know it was just a baby... The enthusiasm we all shared for it. Of a better future. Of true democracy in the world. Of free people, free minds. The Internet will be the cure for all the social ills that humanity has experienced in the past. People will trade and talk with each other and that's how we can have peace on Earth! We will be able to discuss, collaborate, create. We would be able to watch any film, listen to any song. Some people called us "geeks", we liked to call ourselves "hackers". We are not just hacking code, we're hacking a new world. -- A quarter of a century later and most of those things are now reality. But somehow these great things have brought with them some hidden things. Things which we ignored or brushed off easily back in the day.. Like the fact that the Internet is now populated by the same demographic as the real world, not just hackers and dreamers. Now everyone is online. We thought it would free us from oppression, but it is becoming the ultimate tool for oppression. We thought it would give us true democracy, but it is becoming the ultimate moderation system for "foreign" though suppression and group think generator. We though it will serve our needs, but it is becoming the thing that is telling us what to need. We thought it will satisfy our tastes, but our tastes are now being programed into us by it. Of course we're still high from all the positive aspects and it's not in our nature to be scared of things, but that will soon wear off .. And when we wake up what will we find there ? Either way, it is unstoppable and nobody can turn it off. So we only have to wait and see what it will ultimately turn into. What will it be 25 years from now ? Will we still be able to discuss about this freely ?
- api 11y agoThe big error of the 90s digital utopians was over-estimating how much the Internet would change society and under-estimating how much society would change the Internet.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoThere was a fair amount of resistance to society changing the internet from that crowd in the 90s. They've turned out to have been pretty much right, they just lost the fight.
- 11y ago
- joolze 11y agoMonth old news on ZH: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-02-27/hidden-persuaders-how-internet-flips-election-alters-our-thoughts http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-02-27/hidden-persuaders-h...
- Dowwie 11y ago"We now have evidence suggesting that on virtually all issues where people are initially undecided, search rankings are impacting almost every decision that people make." I dug into his CV and found the following related works: - recent publications: http://aibrt.org/index.php/internet-studies http://aibrt.org/index.php/internet-studies - The search engine manipulation effect (SEME) and its possible impact on the outcomes of elections [http://aibrt.org/downloads/EPSTEIN_&_ROBERTSON_2015-The_Search_Engine_Manipulation_Effect-SEME-PNAS-w_SUPPLEMENTS.pdf http://aibrt.org/downloads/EPSTEIN_&_ROBERTSON_2015-The_Sear...] A talk that he gave at Stanford about SEME: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSN6LE06J54&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSN6LE06J54&feature=youtu.be - Democracy At Risk Manipulating Search Rankings Can Shift Voters’ Preferences Substantially Without Their Awareness:[http://aibrt.org/downloads/EPSTEIN_and_Robertson_2013-Democracy_at_Risk-APS-summary-5-13.pdf http://aibrt.org/downloads/EPSTEIN_and_Robertson_2013-Democr...] CV: http://drrobertepstein.com/pdf/vita.pdf?lbisphpreq=1 http://drrobertepstein.com/pdf/vita.pdf?lbisphpreq=1
- scottlocklin 11y agoMegacorporations are bad for the internet for certain, but I don't feel very mind controlled by Google, as I almost always use Duckduckgo or Yandex. They produce fairly similar results, and I have the satisfaction of not shoveling the tiniest bit of money at a company I have likened to fat Vegas era Elvis. I also doubt the results of their research. Nobody is going to vote for Donald Trump because he happens to appear first in a google search; that's just retarded. I think the fact that outsider candidates are locked out of legacy media megaphones and party power structures seems more harmful to democracy, and this has been accepted as "just how it is" for decades.
- Gatsky 11y agoHere is the actual study: http://www.pnas.org/content/112/33/E4512.full.pdf http://www.pnas.org/content/112/33/E4512.full.pdf I can't see how this is valid at all. We know that polls give biased results unless you are very careful with the sampling. Here people are self-selecting for a poll (eg via mechanical turk). Then you apply a highly contrived scenario that they are googling about a candidate. Then you ask them a bunch of questions, immediately, and proceed to draw wide ranging conclusions designed to increase your self-importance as much as possible. I mean, seriously, it's worse than useless. This article is also written as if these findings are earth shattering. After conducting a small, biased, invalid study (Asking people in San Diego about an Australian election? How does that generalize to anything?) and finding a large effect Epstein says 'We did not immediately uncork the Champagne bottle'. Is that how psychology research is conducted? Researchers toasting large implausible effects in small biased samples that have no external validity? Flagged.
- bahjoite 11y agoI had to stop reading the article when it invited the reader to compare two loosely-related percentages as if they were the same measure:- "We predicted that the opinions and voting preferences of 2 or 3 per cent of the people in the two bias groups ... would shift toward that candidate. What we actually found was astonishing. The proportion of people favouring the search engine’s top-ranked candidate increased by 48.4 per cent"
- knaik94 11y agoAs much as I would love to imagine some powerful people intentionally influencing search results on a big scale, Google and Facebook and Twitter have no real way to make money from it. I would argue that it would only drive people away. I am sure that it happens to a certain degree, look at the marketing of Bernie Sanders on reddit, but a much bigger influence is your social circle and your source of new information. Social media mirrors people's attitude. If you see new tweets about an issue you don't particularly care for, there's a good chance that people you follow do care. It's basic psychology that you befriend people who share your views and interests. If all of your friends tweet or like or show interest in something then twitter will assume you do too. Twitter makes money from user engagement and so it's logical to show you things that your friends agree with because chances are you will too. I think a real issue is the lack of a source of unbiased information. Relevant information and information you agree with are very different things.
- whatTheFuckEvr 11y agoOh god. This article is so fucking disappointing. What a quaint boogey man this "Search Engine Manipulation Effect" is. It even has it's own obscure little acronym, SEME, to appear more relevant. I learned about the subtle effects of advertising by the time I was in fourth grade, and certainly understood how to ignore them by middle school. Back when special holographic foil comic book covers and trading cards were new, I had already figured out that all of these "collectibles" were mass-produced, and would never wind up as valuable as, say Action Comics Issue#1, despite so many claims otherwise. This was something you could kind of figure out on your own. If your were easily amused by shiny objects though, you might not arrive at the same conclusion. Meanwhile anyone could figure out that the influence of single frame inserts in movies was as potent and realistic as the subliminal messaging in John Carpenter's Sci-fi movie, THEY LIVE. So too, with Search Engines. Figure if a fourth grader can figure out the shenanigans of opinion and belief influence in advertising, and unravel the bullshit of religion before high school ends, then this other newer form of bullshit is similarly debunked by comparable intellects. If you're so stupid that you buy into bullshit, without multiple channels of factual verification, you're your own worst enemy. Okay, okay, maybe this is good reading material for an elementary school classroom assignment, focused on current events. Sure, why not? I was hoping this would be about technological manifestations of psychic telepathy through malicious use of functional MRI systems. Bah!
- task_queue 11y agoBesides being incredibly masturbatory, this post misses the point. You _are_ susceptible to these manipulations, and if you're barraged with them at every turn, it will be difficult to see each one for what they are. You are susceptible to advertising and other types of influence as well, you just seem to think you aren't. Even if there was a class of ubermensch that can sidestep human psychology, the majority is still heavily influenced by such manipulations and that is a problem for everyone.
- dwaltrip 11y agoIt seems you are saying that there is nothing to worry about, because you specifically have learned to magically rebuff any attempts at mental manipulation. Did I read that correctly? Assuming you have this ability, how does this tell us anything about society at large?
- pcmaffey 11y ago>Power on this scale and with this level of invisibility is unprecedented in human history. I would argue that the influence of media has always been this powerful. And media has always been biased. Another angle to look at would be to apply the work of Stanley Milgram re: obedience to authority figures. Our ability to think for ourselves has some evolving to do...
- Sir_Cmpwn 11y agoWhat I find tragically interesting is that the maintainers of this website (aeon.co) and likely most of the people reading this comment are contributing to the massive dominance the mentioned companies have over the flow of personal information about people online. If I didn't block trackers, it looks like Facebook and Google would both know I read this article, along with Twitter and New Relic.
- andrewclunn 11y agotldr: Use DuckDuckGo.
- ikeboy 11y ago>Keep in mind that we had had only one shot at our participants. What would be the impact of favouring one candidate in searches people are conducting over a period of weeks or months before an election? It would almost certainly be much larger than what we were seeing in our experiments. Reminds me of http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/24/streetlight-psychology/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/24/streetlight-psychology/ >And in 2015, a team of researchers from the University of Maryland and elsewhere showed that Google’s search results routinely favoured Democratic candidates. Are Google’s search rankings really biased? A greater portion of liberals use social media than conservatives (source: http://www.pewinternet.org/2012/03/12/main-findings-10/ http://www.pewinternet.org/2012/03/12/main-findings-10/) Maybe they organically generate more links?
- nunyabuizness 11y agoI once read an article about surveillance with a title along the lines of "A Tale of Two Cities." In it, the author explains that there are two types of surveillance cities that will emerge in the future: one where every park bench is rigged with a mic, every street corner has a camera aimed at it, and where all the data collected is funneled to law enforcement agencies; if you were mugged on some street corner, they'd be able to react to the crime swiftly and with high accuracy. The other city is exactly the same, but all the data is made available to all citizens through an open API; so if you wanted to meet with someone on some street corner, you could decide for yourself if it was safe enough to visit, likely preventing the crime from happening at all. Does anyone know what article I'm talking about?
- butterfinger 11y agoCould be that one: http://www.davidbrin.com/transparentsociety1.html http://www.davidbrin.com/transparentsociety1.html
- nunyabuizness 11y agoThis is it, thank you!!
- jbclements 11y agoI'm really astonished to find only a handful of references to DuckDuckGo in this discussion. I've been using it exclusively for about 2 years now, and had no problems at all. Perhaps I just don't know what I'm missing ... like mind control!
- majewsky 11y agoPeople using Google most likely "had no problems at all" either.
- puranjay 11y agoMost people find this a joke, but I don't kid when I say that 4Chan might be the single most influential political force today. 4Chan's 'meme makers' have an uncanny ability to distill an idea to its simplest form. Ideas that emerge on 4Chan end up on Reddit, from where they are picked up by Buzzfeed and HuffPo. Before you know it, what was a dumb little idea spawned by some anon on /b has become a part of 'internet culture' I've seen firsthand how 4Chan has been able to influence Trump's presidential run. If it weren't for /pol's constant shilling for him, I doubt Trump would've had so much support. 4Chan's memes have changed perceptions of Trump, whether you like it or not
- kiproping 11y agoReddit is very anti-trump, and liberal. Most reputable media companies in the western world are liberal. Do you have an example of a website like huffpo or buzzfeed quoting reddit about how awesome that beautiful pepe gif of trumps train with no brakes is? Any trump content is heavily downvoted on reddit. Just click on controversial posts on reddit, filter for today or the whole week, one subreddit will be most prominent.
- 14113 11y agoReddit has a surprisingly strong/large pro-trump subreddit: /r/TheDonald, which seems to pop up on the front page with alarming regularity.
- anon4 11y agoExcept... the Trump memes were just trolling. Until he took it and posted that image with "Can't stump the Trump". Nobody shills for Trump because they want him to win, it's just a dumb fun thing like holding your hand over an open flame until you get burned. You don't do it because you want to get burned, you do it for the socio-tribal meta-significance of the act.
- andrepd 11y ago>Most people find this a joke, but I don't kid when I say that 4Chan might be the single most influential political force today. I do hope you are kidding, because to say that a fringe Internet forum holds more sway on the masses than TV, newspapers, Super PACs, corporate lobbies, etc, then I think you are seeing things very very wrong. >I've seen firsthand how 4Chan has been able to influence Trump's presidential run. If it weren't for /pol's constant shilling for him, I doubt Trump would've had so much support. 4Chan's memes have changed perceptions of Trump, whether you like it or not Trump is winning states left right and center. Millions of Americans are voting for him. After everything that can be said about Trump, I wonder what makes you think this is attributed to, of all things, 4chan? Isn't this a little too megalomaniac?
- zby 11y agoAnother take on that subject: http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/debatten/the-digital-debate/shoshana-zuboff-secrets-of-surveillance-capitalism-14103616-p2.html?printPagedArticle http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/debatten/the-digital-d...
- kazinator 11y agoThe internet, in fact, provides the best support ever for closing your mind to anything that doesn't align with your world view. You just have to google for pages that confirm your beliefs, finding sites and forums filled with people who think like you do. Then you can deceive yourself into believing that your views actually have a large support. ("Pretty much everyone I know online on every site I go believes it!") The upshot is that "subtle influence" is not going to work on those who are crudely entrenching themselves into some camp or other. For instance, you're not going to "subtly influence" some denier into accepting human-caused global warming. Not as long as he can find plenty of others and keep believing that his social circle is an unbiased sample of the population.