14 ms·
I feel like no matter how Google or any other search engine ranked pages, SEO firms would be there to game the system and make a mess of the web. Making Pagera
by jandrese 11y ago
I feel like no matter how Google or any other search engine ranked pages, SEO firms would be there to game the system and make a mess of the web. Making Pagerank visible to people with one particular toolbar does seem like a fairly major misstep on Google's part. The majority of the people who would really care about that are the kind of people you shouldn't be encouraging.
One of the obnoxious things about SEO is that if one person is doing it everybody has to do it. It's not necessarily enough to simply offer a better product at a better price. Luckily Google does try to reduce the effect of SEO. I notice for instance that StackExchange almost always beats out Expert Sex Change links these days.
- hire_charts 11y agoI'm not sure how much of it is that google tries to reduce the effects of SEO, or that they just keep moving the target. Every time they change their algorithm it seems like a bunch of sites who were practicing one strategy disappear, and before long a new strategy is discovered causing new sites to rise to the top. Ultimately Google's ability to quantify both quality and relevance will converge on actual quality and relevance. In other words, the way to "game" the system and practice SEO will be to create a site that is actually relevant with high-quality content. But we're not there yet, and who knows how close we'll actually get.
- snewman 11y agoObligatory: https://xkcd.com/810/ https://xkcd.com/810/
- brosirmandude 11y agoThis is definitely what is happening. I work in SEO and follow the industry closely, but the SEO industry itself is a giant echo-chamber. But essentially what it boils down to is: - make something your audience wants - make content your audience wants to share - "earn" links by creating useful resources & content Essentially, the way to get great rankings in Google is by actually having a website that people want to go to and is relevant to their interests. Trying to game the system is much harder these days, and honestly for the most part isn't worth the effort.
- cookiecaper 11y agoThis is what SEO firms like to say because it gives them cover and makes people think they're just content writers, but I don't think it's accurate. Backlinks are still king, even if your site has scarcely any content on it; not that it's bad to have more high-quality content, but it's not like Google weighs that strongly. A lot more human curation would be needed to determine that. You put "earn" in quotation marks, because these aren't organically earned except in a tiny fraction of cases. Most of them are planted.
- gardano 11y agoAs somebody with no dog in this fight, I cannot help but wonder if there's a correlation between PageRank and the rise of referring to text on a page as "Content", rather than, well, "An Article".
- kolinko 11y agoContent is just a generic term. If you write a post or a Slideshare that has mostly pictures in it, it's still content but not an article.
- the_af 11y agoNot sure if the parent poster referred to this, but it's not absurd to consider that the term "content" may have harmful connotations. See Stallman's opinion on this (I know, an extremist view, but I think he has a point): "Words to avoid (or use with care)": http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/words-to-avoid.en.html#Content http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/words-to-avoid.en.html#Content > If you want to describe a feeling of comfort and satisfaction, by all means say you are “content,” but using the word as a noun to describe publications and works of authorship adopts an attitude you might rather avoid: it treats them as a commodity whose purpose is to fill a box and make money. In effect, it disparages the works themselves. If you don't agree with that attitude, you can call them “works” or “publications.” I think there may be a correlation between this negative phenomenon of gaming pagerank and referring to articles and pictures as "content", as if they were second-class citizens of the web.
- cardine 11y agoI think that by the time that Google is able to quantify quality and relevance, people will be able to use AI to automatically create websites that are relevant and high quality. I'm not sure whether that is a good thing or not, but it would make sense that the sophistication of the AI used to game Google moves at about the same pace of Google's ability to stop people from gaming its algorithms.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoI suspect it's not that hard to get a very rough assessment of quality and relevance - although it would only be useful with a giant multidimensional model of demographics and interests, because "relevant" isn't a scalar. My guess is Google doesn't do it because it costs too many cycles. Counting backlinks, supplemented by some very basic NLP, is very much cheaper and easier. The irony is that I wonder if people would pay for - or at least not mind - guided and prompted personal search if it produced highly relevant results. The sad truth is that the current sneaky lumping of broad demographic guessing with search history with backlink counting and a bit of NLP/timeline voodoo produces mediocre results for many kinds of searches. (I've just spent a very frustrating 15 minutes trying to find out if the raw datasets from KIC 8462852 are available online. Usually my search fu is pretty good, but I couldn't get a definitive answer.) I'm not sure to what extent Google's sales model relies on this. It's much easier to sell advertising if you don't offer an SLA, because it becomes the customer's fault if the service doesn't provide high quality results. A more effective service would increase ad buyer confidence and the price of niche ad sales would increase, but maybe not by enough to compensate for the loss of more generic ad sales overall.
- scriptproof 11y agoThere is no scientific definition of quality, so this can't happens (even if there is a easy ascertainment of garbage). Google is used to confuse quality and popularity, so maybe we will end with the more popular texts, ideas, beliefs, etc. on the top.
- chei0aiV 11y agoPeople will still be able to game that scenario, just copy-paste from elsewhere.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wilshiredetroit 11y agoPageRank wasnt bad. But the 'game-able' mechanism went on way too long.. and it was compounded when Google "went to bed" with SEO firms
- hackuser 11y ago> it was compounded when Google "went to bed" with SEO firms What does this comment refer to?
- wilshiredetroit 11y agoIt just seems like Google was incentivised to have a relationship with SEO firms to make page rank work.
- paulddraper 11y agoI doubt that. Google is Google because it was/is better than others at finding relevant information.
- cookiecaper 11y ago>It's not necessarily enough to simply offer a better product at a better price. It's not nearly enough to offer a better product at a better price. Our company, which was objectively superior to the bad imitators that followed us, was eviscerated by a competitor with a pedigree as a professional spammer -- his product rarely worked and we were constantly getting refugees once they were able to wade through the massive amounts of spam that promoted his solution and find some genuine information. It didn't help that he bought off niche webmasters to delete any mention of our service from their forums and only allow mention of his service. I have accepted it as a reality that "SEO consultants" (read: professional spammers) are a necessity if your site is going to get anywhere. Note we've always been SEO optimized, meaning our site was always search engine friendly and it contained a great deal more relevant content than our competitor's site. But because our competitor enlisted his network of spam websites to manufacture backlinks and actively sought to exclude mention of my product from the internet by paying off webmasters, he performed much better. People don't know and generally don't care if your product is better or worse. If you have a product that looks like it's functioning, that's all the development that needs to be done as long as it half-works 5-10% of the time. The rest of the money needs to go into spa--err, sorry, "internet marketing".
- GauntletWizard 11y agoGoogle is, like any ranking system, subject to Goodhart's law[1]. "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." What has been Google's saving grace has been their skill at updating their target, attempting to turn the chaos and effort from SEO towards improvement in content. They have made an impossible problem into a mostly-solvable control systems[2] problem. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_system
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI see it slightly differently, the issue is money. When page rank was simply an internal relevance metric it was fine, but when page rank was the way to change how much revenue ads on your page brought you, well then it became much more than "relevance." Brad Templeton made the observation way early on that his humor mailing list went to over ten million people. If people sent him a penny if they laughed, and only 1% did, he would make $30,000 a month or $360,000 a year just for curating jokes. Scale + pennies can add up to big dollars on an individual level. PageRank, AdSense, AdWords, all fed this mechanism with a way to turn a small amount of work by an individual into disproportionate returns. It really has been no surprise that the web spam problem became much much worse than the email spam problem. There was a better built in payment mechanism.
- mistermann 11y ago> I notice for instance that StackExchange almost always beats out Expert Sex Change links these days. True, but they very often don't beat out numerous websites that have taken the open StackExchange content (or other similar, more specialized forums) and rehosted it on a new domain. This behavior should be easy to kill, Google should consider this blacklistable behavior and have an easy way to report any site doing it, with the number of StackExchange users out there these sites would be blacklisted within hours of being launched and before long peolple would simply stop doing it. But for some reason it is allowed to continue.
- brongondwana 11y agoConsider this attack: 1) copy paste from from any random site to a StackExchange comment 2) report the original site for scraping StackExchange 3) lulz
- zo1 11y agoAnd you think Google won't be able to compare timestamps of when each piece of content was inserted/updated?
- mistermann 11y agoThe StackExchange content is open, so I don't think the offending sites are doing anything wrong per se, excluding making the internet worse.
- seanp2k2 11y agoAlso Quora. I luckily almost never see Quora results anymore. For a while, maybe a couple of years back, they'd rank on the first page for many technical queries. Clicking through would give you the question and a blocked answer. Really glad that Google decided that those businesses shouldn't win, because it's a really sleazy model.