4 ms·
"If the top 1% of income earners make 27% of all the money, it would be perfectly reasonable for them to pay 27% of all the taxes." Actually, no. What are the
by hga 17y ago
"If the top 1% of income earners make 27% of all the money, it would be perfectly reasonable for them to pay 27% of all the taxes."
Actually, no. What are they getting in return for that?
Past a certain amount, it doesn't in aggregate cost any more for the government to support the needs of any one person. When you tax people beyond that point, you're explicitly engaging in redistribution and that is a debatable point, not something that is "perfectly reasonable".
To take a real world example, a foreigner can go to a canton in Switzerland and do a private tax treaty with it, where he e.g. pays a fixed amount of tax each year. The cantons that do this are stating that it doesn't cost them any more than that sum to cover his costs to them.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoI'm pretty libertarian, but...all economic systems are at their core ethical statements about how limited resources should be distributed. free markets don't escpae from this.
- rauljara 17y agoThey are paying for national defense and the social spending that allows the state to exist in a stable fashion. The wealth of a society can only exist with the aid of rule of law and relatively social stability. Someone has to pay for that stability. Why not tax people based on how much they benefit from it?
- hga 17y agoAs I said, it's a debatable point; my argument is with those who accept redistribution without question. Although you're still not entirely arguing the point. Beyond a certain amount, how much does a rich person benefit from a stable state vs. their own efforts? To recast it, in an unstable state the rich have vastly more options than the less well off. I'd argue that the less well off benefit the most from the rule of law and social stability.
- cschwarm 17y agoYou assume the rich of a stable state to be the same people who are rich in an unstable state. That's unlikely. Example: In an unstable sociaty, many less well off people are likely to spend more of their income for guns and other means for protection. Therefore, they spend less for other goods, such as software. Consequently, people being rich due to selling software own quite a bit of their wealth to social stabiliy.
- Daishiman 17y agoBeyond a certain point the rich rely on their employees and workers to be healthy, educated, easily available (ie. have access to public and private transportation) and reliable. It may be true that the rich have greater options in poorer nations, but the rich in poor nations are substantially less wealthy than those of richer nations with more progressive taxation rates. Let's not even mention the fact that wealthier people can access a range of benefits that facilitates their acquisition of wealth even more, such as paying good salaries to accountants and qualified staff, or that they in fact have much greater influence on the system than the poor through the actions of lobbies and networking. Let's now talk about the fact that for a poor person a significant percentage of income is for subsistence; a minimum-wage or low-income person will devote most of his/her income to rent and food, with little to spare by months's end, and with fewer opportunities and savings to recover from an economic or health crisis. A wealthy person has his basic needs covered, and can afford to spend his money to make more and can take greater risks which give him/her access to overall greater returns on investment. So no, it doesn't seem debatable to me at all. Redistribution is necessary if you want upwards social mobility in society.
- lionhearted 17y ago> Let's now talk about the fact that for a poor person a significant percentage of income is for subsistence; a minimum-wage or low-income person will devote most of his/her income to rent and food, with little to spare by months's end, and with fewer opportunities and savings to recover from an economic or health crisis. The other side of that coin is that the wealthy consume less of a percentage of their income and invest a greater percentage. Redistribution takes money from people who use that money to invest in startups, buy land, build buildings, renovate old buildings, invest in new technologies, sponsor artists and give it to people whose additional spending will be personal/family consumption - some on things like education and medicine, but also a larger apartment, more entertainment, and consumer goods. Poor people invest very little, the vast majority of investment, new technologies, new industries, new innovation that are invested in is by wealthy people. > So no, it doesn't seem debatable to me at all. This kind of thinking is no good. You honestly don't see that there's very real theoretical and real world downsides to involuntary redistribution? None? Not enough that it's worth debating?
- anamax 17y ago> The wealth of a society can only exist with the aid of rule of law and relatively social stability. Do you really think that rich people benefit more than the poor from rule of law and social stability? If so, you're wrong.
- indiejade 17y agoActually, no. What are they getting in return for that? Actually, yes, I think it is reasonable. The top 1% earners typically are CEOs of large corporations, celebrities, or professional athletes. In any event, their brands put more strain on the overall infrastructure than a little janitor who is in the bottom one percent of income earners. The CEO of Wal-Mart has, at any given time, thousands of delivery trucks on the roads, trucks that contribute to traffic congestion, increase the risk of accidents, cause potholes, and spit out harmful emissions into the atmosphere. The negative externalities born by society can be assigned a cost, and (even though it's by far from a perfect system), it does make sense for those who use/abuse the system for personal profit to be taxed more.
- hga 17y agoI'm sorry, but your concrete argument doesn't work unless you're suggesting that the CEO of Wal-Mart gains the entire benefit of its actions, with none benefiting its shareholders, customers, or low rank employees. To take your even more specific example of delivery trucks, someone has got to deliver the food that everyone eats. You can't arbitrarily assign the total resultant negative externalities to whichever companies own and operate them.
- indiejade 17y ago3. Michael T. Duke, President, CEO, and Director, Wal-Mart $12,238,209 total compensation 6. Eduardo Castro-Wright, Vice Chairman; President and CEO, Wal-Mart Stores U.S. Division $9,987,493 total compensation 8. Thomas M. Schoewe, EVP and CFO, Wal-Mart $9,477,584 total compensation 16. C. Douglas McMillon, EVP; President and CEO, Wal-Mart International Division $8,191,857 total compensation Four out of the 20 "Highest Paid Retail Executives" are Wal-Mart executives. Source: http://www.risnews.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=&type=MultiPublishing&mod=PublishingTitles&mid=2E3DABA5396D4649BABC55BEADF2F8FD&tier=4&id=19710C99B6A541E09B4B506CDD05844C http://www.risnews.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=&type=...
- hga 17y agoAnd your point is?
- dantheman 17y agoThe majority of taxes don't actually go to anything a top 1% of income earners need. Take a look at the budget, the majority of the spending is SS, Medicare & Medicaid.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- brazzy 17y ago...which spare the rich the expense of having to hire a private army to prevent the rabble from taking their riches from them.
- viraptor 17y agoI could find one good reason for the top 1% making 18% of money to pay 27% of taxes - military and government contracts. Many of the top earning CEOs and top companies will get a lot of their money from contracts paid via taxes (selling articles to the army, military training, other government projects with debatable gain for the community). Those taxes are paid by everyone. If the top companies' owners get money for those services, they basically get paid using the tax from all other groups. Since more money from taxes == more contracts possible, we might want them to get taxed more - otherwise it's like they're getting a natural tax return via a closed loop in money flow.
- gyardley 17y agoThat's not a good reason for taxing the top 1% more, that's a good reason for taxing those benefiting from military and government contracts more. The two groups don't perfectly overlap.
- hga 17y agoHowever, unless you get the tax rate(s) correct so that the return is negative, the more they get in this loop the more they retain. The traditional response to this problem is to limit the scope of government. The fewer government contracts, the less this is a problem. A lot of people noted the incongruity of Ross Perot's populism, given that so much of his income was from IT contracts with various governments.
- jfoutz 17y agomostly they have more stuff that needs protecting. I have a modest house, the fire department only protects a modest amount of value. I've got a nice computer, and some art on the wall, but nothing worth millions. Does the owner of an NFL team derive more benefit from a tax subsidized stadium than the people who go to watch the game? If you take all the fans together, no. If you compare the owner to any single fan, probably yes (the fan could be the opposing team owner ;) Cheap gas benifits everyone because food gets cheaper, and the distance you can drive to work farther. Expensive gas is tough on me, but it's 100x tougher on someone that employs a hundred people, the cost to employ those same people either goes up, or the pool of talent you choose from goes down. So, does 10 trillion for wars benefit me? ... sure. Does it benefit someone wealth more? sure.
- hga 17y ago"they have more stuff that needs protecting" Yes, but only up to a certain point, especially in a nation where 70% or so of the assets are financial instruments (ones tied to quasi-tangible stuff, plus government bonds which are tied to their power to tax). Beyond that point you're redistributing wealth, not protecting the taxpayer who's so generously providing it.
- jfoutz 17y agoContract enforcement it probably the only thing everybody agrees government does well. I think a percentage of the value of the contract is a reasonable way to pay. If i disagree with a contractor over a $1000 fence, we can go to small claims court and sort it out. If Gigantic Manufacturer X disagrees with Retailer Y over a billion dollar contract, it's a lot more work to sort out. A five dollar lock on billion dollar asset is silly. If you choose to rely on government to protect property rights, it is ridiculous to assert that people with very little property derive the same benefit as people with lots of property. For information on non-government enforcement, watch the wire. it's a fantastic show. I don't think I can accept that those advanced financial instruments can exist without government contract enforcement. However, if you have evidence to the contrary, or even a good story I'll think about it.
- sorbits 17y ago“you're explicitly engaging in redistribution” Even a flat tax is redistribution of wealth as it would need to take into account that most people don’t start to earn money before they reach a certain age (and will likely stop earning money several years before they die).