3 ms·
>pretty severe unintended consequences to economic activities // Like an end to collusion to fix higher prices for customers? What is not criminal about it? I
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
>pretty severe unintended consequences to economic activities //
Like an end to collusion to fix higher prices for customers?
What is not criminal about it? It's not a wrong against a specific person it's a wrong against everyone else who operates in that market, customers and suppliers alike. It's also a general wrong in perverting the financial systems around that market. Those who instigated such efforts certainly committed a crime in my view.
- gwright 11y agoThe problem I was alluding to is that this would radically change the risk management aspects of a business. There is a certain amount of subjectivity in regulatory frameworks. An honest business decision may trigger a fine due to interpretation of the regulation or even unforeseen complications. There are a variety of tools to manage financial risk (e.g. insurance) that businesses are very familiar with. If you convert these civil violations into criminal violations those risk management techniques don't apply. You can't purchase insurance that sends someone else to jail if you are found in criminal violation of a regulation. So what I was suggesting was that criminalizing regulatory violations would make companies highly risk adverse as well as giving regulators really big sticks to force concessions. Changing the business environment in such an extreme way is going to have lots of unintended consequences.