5 ms·
Maybe the case has merit or not but I am really tired of just imposing fines. We have reached a point where big companies and banks can do whatever they want an
by maxxxxx 11y ago
Maybe the case has merit or not but I am really tired of just imposing fines. We have reached a point where big companies and banks can do whatever they want and the worst thing that can happen is to pay a small portion of their earnings. Basically they are outside the law.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoWhat harm has been demonstrated by this supposed conspiracy to set prices? Do you pay one penny more for your e-books? I don't. The whole thing seems like a technicality, a violation of a 110-year-old law that was never intended to cover this type of complex digital transaction.
- maxxxxx 11y agoIt's a law. A lot of laws are old and don't apply to the present anymore but the little guy still has to obey them. They can lobby for a law change but it's not acceptable that people/entities with lots of money can decide which laws they obey and which not.
- sjwright 11y agoEveryone makes that decision every hour of the day. We're all constantly breaking one obscure law or another.
- RodericDay 11y agoTolerance of this kind of situation is what pushes North America closer and closer to Kafkaesque nightmares though.
- donatj 11y agoTolerance of victimless crimes that hurt no one is a Kafkaesque nightmare?
- RodericDay 11y agoLetting "victimless crimes" exist in the books for whenever a powerful entity wants an excuse to jail someone, or to excuse inequitable enforcement of the law.
- donatj 11y agoAh, I actually agree with that in it's entirety.
- maxxxxx 11y agoIf the law is stupid then congress should cancel (delete?) it. Don't allow big guys avoid them but the little guy with no lawyers on retainer has to follow then.
- scintill76 11y agoRight, and this fine is somewhat like fining an individual $0.10 for jaywalking. They'll probably decide it was worth the risk and keep doing the illegal thing, like Apple in this case or HSBC with lax anti-money-laundering compliance. The point is that these things won't be deterred until the people responsible are at risk of going to prison, or doing something else they're not going to gladly write-off as a cost of business.
- sbov 11y agoActually, you did pay more, at least at the time of the court filing. “The increases at Amazon within roughly two weeks of moving to agency amounted to an average per unit e-book retail price increase of 14.2% for their New Releases, 42.7% for their NYT Bestsellers, and 18.6% across all of the Publisher Defendants’ e-books,” https://www.justice.gov/atr/case-document/file/486691/download https://www.justice.gov/atr/case-document/file/486691/downlo... I'm not sure how prices have adjusted since then though.
- URSpider94 11y agoYou absolutely pay more. Every time you go on Amazon and look up an Ebook priced over $9.99, and it carries a note that says, "this price was set by the publisher," that's a book that Amazon would sell you for less money if the publisher let them. It's hard to find a clearer-cut case of price fixing.
- lmm 11y ago> What harm has been demonstrated by this supposed conspiracy to set prices? Do you pay one penny more for your e-books? I don't. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/07/10/a-judge-says-apple-fixed-e-book-prices-this-chart-shows-how-they-did-it/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/07/10/a-jud...
- dhimes 11y agoI agree. The fine is just another cost of doing business, and this makes breaking the law to put someone else out of business just another tactic. I'm not sure what the fix is, but this was clearly MS's strategy in the '90s. Kill the competition, fight the case, pay the fine if you lost, then make up the money lost because you can charge more.
- rasz_pl 11y agoThis is because US fines are laughable. Try Microsoft paying over Billion dollars for IE bundling in EU. The way things are going they are due for another round or billion dollar fines soon.
- donatj 11y agoI still content that the IE bundling case was a horrible miscarriage of justice. Does ANY for pay OS today not come with a Browser? How the hell else am I supposed to get a Browser without some form of browser? Go to the store and buy one? Yeah, boo IE, hiss Microsoft, but honestly including core functionality like HTML rendering in your operating system is not morally wrong.
- ambrice 11y agoThe problem is not that IE was included, the problem was that the OEM was forbidden from also pre-installing firefox.
- revelation 11y agoYou might try to learn the facts of the case first. The agreement was that Microsoft would simply offer users a choice of browsers on the first launch of IE. They then managed to not ship this selection screen for a year or so on Windows setup disks and ISOs. Hence they got the $1b fine.
- Qwertious 11y agoAt the time, OSes were paid software. Microsoft deliberately gave away their (vendor-locked) web browser at a loss to drive the other web browsers out of business (i.e. dumping), in order to lock web development into Windows. Although to be fair, they cheated the original developers of IE out of their money, too, by promising them a cut of the sales on IE (which they had absolutely no intention of delivering, seeing as they planned to give it away for free), so it wasn't quite "at a loss".
- thaumasiotes 11y ago
- gwright 11y agoIMNAL, but I think you are trying to apply criminal legal theory to a civil situation. In this case the law dictates redress of the infraction through restitution and not punishment. I'm not sure I would want to live in a world where administrative regulations were punishable through imprisonment. I think there would be some pretty severe unintended consequences to economic activities. Helpful definition of criminal vs. civil law: http://www.diffen.com/difference/Civil_Law_vs_Criminal_Law http://www.diffen.com/difference/Civil_Law_vs_Criminal_Law
- maxxxxx 11y agoMy point is that the little guy gets destroyed in the same situation whereas the big guy gets way with it.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoI don't think I'd call a $450 million dollar fine "getting away with it". That's HUGE. Also remember a vast majority of Apple's money is off shore so this is actually "noticeable".
- lmm 11y agoThe little guy usually gets destroyed for doing something unambiguously illegal that was unambiguously illegal at the time. Whereas the big guy gets a (proportionately) small fine for... well, ultimately the court decided they were breaking the law, but it was more a matter of making a judgement call the wrong way. This case may be more clear-cut, but that's generally why you see these differences.
- maxxxxx 11y agoA while ago I did some reading about lawsuits against pharmaceutical companies that promoted unapproved uses of their drugs. There is a very good book about epo. According to that reading the main reason is they get small fines is that the government doesn't have the budget to go after big companies. They simply can't afford it and take what they can get.