7 ms·
131b revenue in 2015. So, at 1.3m, a 0.001% fine, aka half a minute of revenue. Interestingly it doesn't directly fix the problem either (although it wrecks th
by rektide 11y ago
131b revenue in 2015. So, at 1.3m, a 0.001% fine, aka half a minute of revenue.
Interestingly it doesn't directly fix the problem either (although it wrecks the current free-profit model, yay!), "To settle this matter, Verizon Wireless will pay a fine of $1,350,000 and implement a compliance plan that requires it to obtain customer opt-in consent prior to sharing a customer’s UIDH with a third party to deliver targeted advertising"
But lest anyone think this is a UIDH prohibition, the next line goes on to say customers must at least have the ability to opt-out from internal Verizon usage, meaning the UIDH will be there (unless the customer opts out) and that a persistent, unique identifier that follows the user wherever they go is permitted. This ruling is primarily about Verizon sharing the targeting information: Verizon is still permitted a persistent attack on their users, but they are now only permitted to sell customer data on an opt-in basis. Ad-networks will have to do their own tracking themselves for everyone else.
Hopefully Verizon's profits from this schtick are shorn from this shift, to a degree where they give up this disgraceful corpoate panopticon they've been going to the bank on.
- __john 11y agoIs there any reason Verizon wouldn't start up an ad department? They have a nice advantage with the internal opt out...
- spennant 11y agoVerizon now owns Converto (http://www.adweek.com/news/technology/6-major-pieces-verizon-gets-aol-deal-164698 http://www.adweek.com/news/technology/6-major-pieces-verizon...)... Supercookies makes this a big deal.
- fomojola 11y agoThey don't need to start up an ad department: they have AOL.
- anfrany1 11y agoI'm not sure if their Rewards program is part of their ad department or not but part of their reward program is that you have to consent to being tracked.
- tibbon 11y agoCan someone explain why the courts do these type of minimal fines? Having a cup of coffee on the Bart could land me a $250 fine, which is 2x as much proportional of my personal yearly revenue. This seems more harmful than a cup of coffee.
- kbenson 11y agoUnless you are making 12.5 million a year, I think you converted wrong. It's likely 20 or 200 times more the proportional amount of your yearly revenue.
- tibbon 11y agoAh yea, I math'd wrong ;) You made my point even stronger.
- secfirstmd 11y agoTIL that having a cup of coffee on the BART can lead to a $250 fine. Now I know why everyone was staring at me when I was on my way in from the airport...
- harryh 11y agoBecause fines are assessed based on the harm done not the ability of the person/organization to pay.
- dredmorbius 11y agoCitation requested.
- jsjohnst 11y agoSo you're saying a cup of coffee is much more harmful proportionally than invading the privacy of millions? Let's say it was only 1 million, so not even $1.50 each. Cup of coffee for same one person, nearly 200x more.
- deleted 11y ago
- rosser 11y ago> 131b revenue in 2015. So, at 1.3m, a 0.001% fine, aka half a minute of revenue. Came here to say exactly this — except that it's even worse than your numbers suggest: some form of the UIDH has been in play since at least 2012. If you amortize the fine across the lifetime of the program, a mere $1.3m is an obscenely paltry penalty. These "fines" will never deter bad behavior until they have some teeth. When VZW takes in more in the time it takes for me to let a call go to voicemail than they were fined for this crap, I think the take-away has to be that the regulatory bodies are pretty much, "That's nice, son. You run along and play now" over it.
- mirimir 11y agoIt's tiny compared to the $450 million that Apple will be paying. But then, how would one calculate damages for what Verizon did?
- newjersey 11y agoPunitive damages comes to mind.
- mirimir 11y agoRight. Deterrence. Set an example. All that :)
- awinter-py 11y agoAlternatively, just refund every consumer who paid to have their privacy violated. Nobody should pay to be on the receiving end of a tort. That number would be way higher than 1.3m.
- asuffield 11y agoI'm not interested in defending Verizon here, but your math is wrong. Comparing fines (or taxes, the other popular variation of this error) to revenue is meaningless. You need to compare them to profit. The amount of money that they handled but didn't benefit from is irrelevant. Verizon's profits for 2015 were $4.22bn. That makes it a 0.03% fine. But that's still not close enough, because this infraction was in "Verizon Wireless", not the entire company. So to really get a sense of its relevance, you need to figure out what the profit of that arm of the business was. I can't find that number anywhere. Anybody got a hint?
- adventured 11y agoVerizon's net income for fiscal 2015 was $17.8 billion - http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=VZ&annual http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=VZ&annual The best numbers I can locate indicate Verizon Wireless is generating well over $20 billion per year in operating income. Out of their nearly $18b in net income the last four quarters, wireless would pretty much have to be 75%-90% of that. The numbers before the Vodafone / VZ Wireless sale, indicated the wireless division was a huge share of their income.
- marincounty 11y agoI think it's time we tie criminal/civil fines/fees to income. I'll even accept net. All I know is when I'm fined, there's a possibility that it might be the last straw. The last straw to homelessness. When a rich man, or remotely successful corporation is fined it's just someting to talk about. It seems to violate one of those admendments that people seem to forget about--the 8th? It doesn't matter because nothing will change.
- tootie 11y ago$1.3M is less than you'd pay Adobe for hosting innocuous site analytics on a high-volume site for a year.
- username223 11y ago> 131b revenue in 2015. So, at 1.3m, a 0.001% fine, aka half a minute of revenue. It's interesting to look at it in political terms. A modern presidential campaign costs about a billion, i.e. less than one day per election. That's $7.50 for each voter in the last election, or likely more than $750 for each "undecided" voter in a competitive state. And then you learn that lesser politicians provide as much as 40x returns... http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=1667009
- rektide 11y agoAttention, attention please: parent here again. Thank you all for the upvotes. I was, however, wrong! Thank heavens! I got in touch with the media contact, and he reports that the wording indeed means Verizon is no longer allowed to UIDH 3rd party sites. I'm very glad to be wrong here. :) Thank you all for your support, and I'm sorry to have spread misinformation so far; it was not my intent!