3 ms·
> War can certainly accelerate and mobilize what's already there but I find the argument that it creates unconvincing. The problem with war-driven progress is
by ekianjo 11y ago
> War can certainly accelerate and mobilize what's already there but I find the argument that it creates unconvincing.
The problem with war-driven progress is that it's incidental. In War you are focusing on the War Machine, on destroying as much as you can both in human lives and resources.
Obviously you are bound to make discoveries that will be useful in other fields later on as well.
But to me it sounds very wrong on a ethical basis to justify that what we have today in terms of tech is a direct by-product of war. Innovation/Science also occurs outside of the spectrum of war, and it is very reductive to say that War advances Science as a whole.
On top of that, let's not forget that the scientists and technologists involved in the War Machine could have spent their time and lives doing something else and we will never know what other courses innovation could have taken.
- api 11y agoI wonder if the real origin of war progress isn't Keynesian, and if a basic income, a lot of R&D spending, and a lot of incentive to invest might not achieve the same thing without all the death. War seems like a way to sell stimulus to conservatives.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoModern medical science came to be from Napoleon's conquest. Plenty of wounded and corpses to ... experiment on. So it's like that.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI don't mind downvotes at all, but... http://www.napoleon.org/en/magazine/interviews/lemaire.asp http://www.napoleon.org/en/magazine/interviews/lemaire.asp "In my opinion, the great leap forward in medical knowledge, the birth of modern medicine, occurs somewhere in the period between the beginning of the Revolution and the end of the Empire." I don't if or when this became obscure knowledge, but I don't even remember when I first learned it. To be sure, Koch, the germ theory and understanding of sepcis came later, almost inexplicably.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI think it's also worth looking at how the French aristocracy ruined themselves supporting what became the United States in the American Revolution. In order to even have a theory about why there was a Great Depression in the first place is extremely difficult. IMO, WWII directly was caused by the Depression among other things. This being said, Pershing held that the end of WWI happened in a way that made another war inevitable in a generation, and this prediction was borne out.