7 ms·
War Is a Racket (1935)
- pmoriarty 11y ago"But the soldier pays the biggest part of the bill" I'm not sure how it was in Butler's time, but I've read that the overwhelming majority of casualties in modern warfare are civilians. It would seem to me that they are the ones who pay "the biggest part of the bill". Not that I would deny that the people doing the mass murder can themselves become the victims of war. But I'd personally have more sympathy for civilians who are not trying to murder others but are themselves murdered.
- sandworm101 11y ago>> born July 30, 1881 So yes, he didn't witness a truly modern war. 19th century conflicts were brutal, but weren't exactly the city-destroying conflict WWII was, nor the guerrilla wars of modern times.
- HillRat 11y agoThough you could argue that the Philippines war had its similarities to modern three-block-war conflicts; see Mark Twain on the Moro Crater Massacre (http://drnissani.net/MNISSANI/cr/moro.htm http://drnissani.net/MNISSANI/cr/moro.htm).
- eru 11y agoDon't forget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Rebellion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiping_Rebellion : "The [Taiping Rebellion] [...] ranks as one of the bloodiest wars in human history, the bloodiest civil war, and the largest conflict of the nineteenth century with estimates of war dead ranging from 20 to 70 million dead, as well as millions more displaced."
- fleshweasel 11y agoHe participated in WW1, which by any reasonable standard was a truly modern war.
- danielvf 11y agoBut his book was not about WWI, rather about the smaller banana conflicts.
- rangibaby 11y agoWWI still didn't have total war or deliberate destruction of entire cities using aircraft. The bombing of Guernica in 1937 was considered shocking at the time.
- cubano 11y agoYou are wrong about that. WWI eventually defined total war, and no doubt its legacy was the primary reason France just surrendered to the Germans in 1941. The entire population had simply had enough. Hell, Sherman was fighting total war in 1864.
- rat87 11y ago> Some 9 to 10 million combatants on both sides are estimated to have died during World War I, along with an estimated 6.6 million civilians.[citation needed] The civilian casualty ratio in World War I is therefore approximately 2:3 or 40%. Most of the civilian fatalities were due to famine or Spanish flu rather than military action. The relatively low ratio of civilian casualties in this war is due to the fact that the front lines on the main battlefront, the Western Front, were static for most of the war, so that civilians were able to avoid the combat zones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_War_I https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_... > According to most sources, World War II was the most lethal war in world history, with some 70 million killed in six years. The civilian to combatant fatality ratio in World War II lies somewhere between 3:2 and 2:1, or from 60% to 67%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio#World_...
- rodgerd 11y agoThe murder, torture, and rape of civilians all out of proportion of any millitary casualties is hardly a modern phenomenon. The US brutalisation of the Phillipines. The Hundred Years' War. The Thirty Years War. Three off the top of my head, and it's easier to find more examples than to find counter-examples.
- Semiapies 11y agoThe military always thinks they have the worst of war. Remember all those stories a couple of years back about drone operators being psychologically traumatized by their job? (In between calling children they'd killed "fun-sized terrorists", of course.)
- deelowe 11y agoCan't both sides have it bad? I have family members who were absolutely traumatized by the vietnam war. The whole concept is absolutely terrible.
- EdHominem 11y agoNot really. The worst a soldier faced was prison for not participating and if they left the country soon enough - no punishment at all. Anyone unwilling to go to some effort to avoid prosecuting an unjust war can't really be said to be a victim like the people they shoot... If we give them a pass we remove all moral requirement to make sure you're fighting for a just cause.
- codyb 11y agoI'm not really sure if, during a national wartime it's always just so easy for millions of potential soldiers to just pack up and move across the border at once. Otherwise, your option is only for those who are economically, and mentally prepared for such an undertaking. Economically of course including things like important connections. And your other option which I think is jail for draft dodgers isn't exactly fulsome and charming. So the soldier either loses his way of life through exodus, forced incaceration, or being sent to fight.
- Semiapies 11y agoAnd yet all of that falls short of what civilians in war zones suffer. Hence, the idea that the military gets the worst part of war is ridiculous.
- prawn 11y agoAnd also don't get paid for their involvement.
- desdiv 11y agohttp://i.imgur.com/DS57Lrk.png http://i.imgur.com/DS57Lrk.png
- ghouse 11y ago"The U.S. wars in Afghanistan and Iraq will cost taxpayers $4 trillion to $6 trillion, taking into account the medical care of wounded veterans and expensive repairs to a force depleted by more than a decade of fighting" - Washington Post, March 28, 2013
- chishaku 11y ago> At the outset of the Iraq war, the Bush administration predicted that it would cost $50 billion to $60 billion to oust Saddam Hussein, restore order and install a new government. > Only one economist, William D. Nordhaus of Yale, seems to have come close. In a paper in December 2002, he offered a worst-case estimate of $1.9 trillion, “if the war drags on, occupation is lengthy, nation-building is costly.” http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/19/washington/19cost.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/19/washington/19cost.html?_r=...
- Pyxl101 11y agoDo we have better accounting and estimation methods now, to advise current commanders-in-chief? The next time a president wants to take the USA to war, or enter any armed conflict, I'd like to see that announcement be accompanied by (or followed shortly thereafter by) a GAO or similar accounting report estimating probable outcomes and costs. The same report should include an appendix that summarizes recent similar reports delivered in past armed conflicts, analyzing their accuracy with known actual costs. (E.g., that appendix should report this fact about the Iraq war and the updated estimate for the new war should take into account the sources of inaccuracy that led to the underestimation). In software engineering, at least part of the job is doing something new every time. If it wasn't new it wouldn't need a human - it would just be a machine doing something repeatedly. I imagine that war is to some extent the same way, in that no opposition force is exactly the same; yet a lot of war must be loosely similar in cost, barring major technological changes. (E.g., cost per square mile of territory held by infantry or cost per civilian population or cost per enemy combatant; cost per square mile of enforced no-fly-zone, etc.) Say, where are all of the data scientists? You'd think that you could draw some interesting conclusions analyzing data about the costs of war, assuming it's publicly available. For example, a histogram of dollars spent month by month per province of occupied territory - is such data public? I don't think I've ever seen much in the way of interesting visualizations, outside of the occasional flashy news article.
- 1632TestAccount 11y agoTest
- 0x99 11y agoWhile it is hard to argue with the points in the article, there is this concept of 'global influence' or influence on global politics, which is hard to put a $ value on. Hasn't this global influence played a huge part in maintaining USA as a global superpower ?
- Zigurd 11y agoGlobal influence, and military power, has its basis in economic power. You can't squander it in such breathtaking ways and maintain your status.
- hsitz 11y agoYou think blunders in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere contribute to U.S. status as global superpower? I'm pretty sure a stronger case could be made that they've detracted from the status and influence the U.S. could have had.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Pyxl101 11y agoIt's hard to know what exact effect our presence in Iraq and Afghanistan has had on the world. I'm sure there are people at military academies and universities getting PhDs on it. Whatever the answer is, I don't think we should let the analysis fall prey to populism. As much as I'd agree that Iraq seems to have been a disaster, and that we haven't managed to accomplish much in Afghanistan, consider the wider implications. The USA has managed to navigate itself to the point where it put significant pressure on Iran through sanctions, has agreed to dismantle its nuclear weapons program, and is beginning to re-enter the global economy amidst a lessening of tensions. Presumably at least partially as a result, the price of oil is down to $40, which is lower than it was in 1985. (Consider where Iran is on the world map relative to Iraq and Afghanistan.) For all we know in the general public, that was the strategic goal the entire time. (Yes, I know, that's probably giving the government too much credit. Then again, consider the skill of sabotage like the Stuxnet virus, and imagine the same skill applied to long-term global strategic thinking.) Perhaps the empire would be much stronger if not for those blunders, or perhaps Iraq would still be a dictatorship and Iran a nuclear threat. As much as ISIS is annoying, it doesn't seem to be an actual strategic threat in the way that nuclear powers with long-range ballistic missiles are. Just to be clear, I don't know what to believe. I'm playing devil's advocate and primarily arguing not to prematurely conclude that things are simpler than they seem. Consider, for example, the layers of subtlety involved in executing Nixon's Madman theory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_theory - given the crazy things that actually have happened in our world and politics, I would not be especially surprised if the government knowingly went to war with Iraq on a pretext, specifically to put pressure on Iran and take geo-political control of the region (perhaps even to destabilize the region), with a "fall guy" planned out ahead of time in the way of "no one really believed there were WMDs". The story that, "We thought they had WMDs and were wrong" is a lot easier for the public and world to accept than, "We are strategically invading Iraq and Afghanistan to put pressure on Iran." Granted, I agree with you that these situations are total clusterfucks. I'm just saying let's look beneath the surface.
- pgnas 11y agoI read this and I think of the courage that it must have taken to write, however, I quickly realize that my thoughts are based on today's mindset where questioning the government gets you labeled a conspiracy nut or traitor. We have been warned by many about the military industrial complex, yet, it doesn't sink in. Our current president was elected on promises of ending these wars and somehow he will go down in history as the champion of military occupation and perpetuating conflicts in places we don't belong. Truth is that peace doesn't make money, it doesn't grease the wheels of industry, the difference is that where is the industry? It used to be that the US would at least benefit from the industry through employment and tax revenue, but what if the production is no longer in the US? Who benefits then? I can tell you with accuracy who doesn't ..
- gbog 11y ago> "peace doesn't make money" Not so sure about it. Peace and stability is the main driver for civilisation booms. Maybe sometime wars can shake the tree but storms do not help growing big fruits -- long sunny days do. Chinese civilisation is remarkable for its long periods of relative peace and steady wealth increase. That's also when culture develops.
- awl130 11y agoevery time china has a prolonged period of peace, the nobility gets corrupt which then opens it up for invasion. culture may be the result of extended peace, but unity is only achieved through conflict. ironically, there is no peace without war. yin and yang.
- gbog 11y agoYes, that's the second order analysis. But the mantra stating that war brings wealth and competition, that war is "sane and natural" from civilisation point of view, is wrong. Peace is the "sane and natural" state for human civilisation, and while some degradation can occur in an extended period with no major conflict, this is a side effect of peace, not the main effect (which is, again, that people can gather wealth and transmis it to their offsprings)
- p4wnc6 11y agoMy understanding of many of the most recent military engagements by the US is that they are basically sandbox experiments for prototyping new warfare tech and tactics, especially to study things like asymmetric urban warfare in which the distinction between combatant and civilian is difficult. We enter the conflicts under whatever pretext is popularized in the media, but the real reason is to fuel warfare R&D efforts, grow surveillance infrastructure, and collect data that reflects situations our military leaders forecast to be important. Large contracting firms profit. Soldiers lose time, often also money, often their mental health and family relationships, and sometimes their lives. Taxpayers lose money. Foreign civilians lose their lives. Few benefits are ever given to soldiers or foreigners, if they are even paid lip service with promises of benefits at all. It's basically a string of smaller scale proxy wars to fuel tech, surveillance, and population control between larger, "actual" wars. I fear we are already past a point where democratic process could stop it. I think by now it would require almost an actual revolt from U.S. citizens on U.S. soil, and that it would be bloody, and that part of the military engineering being studied is exactly how much civilians will tolerate before being pushed to the point of revolt. As long as you can watch Netflix on your iPad and put it out of your mind, then while it might ruffle your feathers, you won't actually take action that could jeopardize your creature comforts. Even things like Occupy Wall Street seem like they are more data collection opportunities than anything else. "OK, so they will protest via X, Y, and Z, but too few of them can be pushed to do A, B, or C for us to care." It's a very depressing feeling. In the meantime, just like everyone else, I have to worry about money, family, life goals, comforts, health, and all my biases push me to ignore the military industrial conflict, because already giving it maybe 1/100th of my overall bandwidth is exceedingly depressing. Something close to 40% of the country believes in young earth creationism. Open up to a highly-visited YouTube video and scroll down to the comments and behold the inanity of how we use our time and what our priorities are. How could enough people possibly coordinate beliefs and actions around humanity-affirming rebukes of the military industrial complex? Of course they won't, so then I guess I'd better put my brain towards how to live in a world where they won't, which is too depressing to think about... and the cycle continues. I'm sure it has been articulated even earlier than the early 1900s. It's just goes on and on.
- siquick 11y ago
- nihonde 11y agoEvery great cause begins as a movement, becomes a business, and eventually degenerates into a racket. — Eric Hoffer (paraphrase)
- Animats 11y agoButler is famous, but not for his US military service. For his military service with the United Fruit Company and duPont.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smedley_Butler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smedley_Butler
- noxToken 11y ago> Butler is famous, but not for his US military service. I can hear the collective shouts of every Marine begging to differ. Two of the most recognized names in Marine Corps history are MajGen Smedley Butler and SgtMaj "Dan" Daly. Among other things, they are 2 of 19 men in US military history and the only two Marines to receive two Medals of Honor.
- Animats 11y agoHe was a great Marine. His complaint was that the the USMC wasn't fighting for the United States, but was being misused on behalf of the United Fruit Company. That's where "banana republics" (not the Gap subsidiary, the Central American countries) came from.
- noxToken 11y agoThis fact isn't so much drilled into heads during bootcamp, but anyone who reads from the Commandant's reading list (or any light research into MajGen Butler for that matter) will have known this. I was specifically addressing your first statement though.
- griffinmahon 11y agoI read an NYT article a while ago that made the argument that the effect of people who did not support the Vietnam War evading the draft was a military that was, twenty or so years later, when the people who did join became senior, very conservative or willing to wage war. Along the lines of the critical theory idea that some of the Left have become ineffective by not involving themselves in actual politics, I think it's important to not be deterred by this idea of war, as the only way the military-industrial complex will change is if people with better values come to make up more of the military. Maybe this will come to be the case as younger people see decreasing future job prospects and turn to the military as a career.
- puppetmaster3 11y agoInteresting that you imply that Left would like less war. It seems to me that the progressives main thing is to tell and enforce how others should live and behave, that is the core of the left, the other ideas are just branches. Evidence is the congress votes in USA by Left to start wars and votes by Taxed Enough Already (TEA) to defund the wars. If you are anti war, I invite you to check out the Right, Libertarian POV.
- thatfrenchguy 11y agoThe left main thing is mostly about making sure there is a "floor", meaning that even if you are poor and on min wage you don't die on the street or bankrupt at the first opportunity. Usually, countries where the right is in power (take the US for example) have a terrible living for their poorest population. And this is not something you want because the guy having the shitty min wage job might tomorrow be you, one of your kids, your best friend, or someone in your family.
- Terr_ 11y ago> "[It's] peace, not war, that makes wealth for a country. War just transfers possession of the residue from the weaker to the stronger. Worse, what is bought with blood is sold for coin, and then stolen back again. [...] It's a wondrous transmutation, where the blood of one man is turned into the money of another. Lead into gold is nothing to it." -- "The Curse of Chalion", by Lois McMaster Bujold
- Cieplak 11y agoReminds me very much of Eisenhower's farewell address from 1961: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eisenhower's_farewell_address
- mxfh 11y agoWhile Butler was quite spot on with his early 1930s post-mortem assessment of WWI, a less isolationist approach might have possibly lessened the scale of WWII. Some aspects of it's stance, like home territory limited military presence and exclusive zones of interest are simply obsolete in an era of ICBMs and satellites. For some context and general description of sentiment in the 30s: https://www.americanhistoryusa.com/power-of-isolationists-before-world-war-ii/ https://www.americanhistoryusa.com/power-of-isolationists-be... https://history.state.gov/milestones/1937-1945/american-isolationism https://history.state.gov/milestones/1937-1945/american-isol... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nye_Committee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nye_Committee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrality_Acts_of_1930s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrality_Acts_of_1930s
- carsongross 11y agoFor those who are interested, a good book on the history of opposition to war is: http://www.amazon.com/We-Who-Dared-Say-War/dp/1568583850 http://www.amazon.com/We-Who-Dared-Say-War/dp/1568583850 It was written by a leftist and libertarian/paleoconservative working together, so you will likely find something you love and something you hate in it, as with all good books. I very much regret my early support for the Iraq war.
- chishaku 11y ago> Yes, they are getting ready for another war. Why shouldn't they? A couple notes on the war drum: The 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force [0] targeting the perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks has been invoked to deploy US armed forces to Afghanistan, the Philippines, Georgia, Yemen, Djibouti, Kenya, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Iraq, Somalia and Syria. [1][2] A new proposed Authorization for Use of Military Force [3] targeting ISIS, "its associated forces," and "any successor organizations" is arguably more open-ended. The author of the proposal, Lindsey Graham (Senior Senator from South Carolina), seeks to grant the next president "the ability to go after ISIS without limitation to geography, time and means." [4] [0]: https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-107sjres23enr/html/BILLS-107sjres23enr.htm https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/BILLS-107sjres23enr/html/BILLS... [1]: https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/aumf-071013.pdf https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/aumf-071013.pdf [2]: https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/R43760.pdf https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/R43760.pdf [3]: https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/sjres26/text https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/114/sjres26/text [4]: http://www.defensenews.com/story/defense/policy-budget/congress/2016/01/22/mcconnell-nudges-grahams-aumf-forward-us-senate/79171192/ http://www.defensenews.com/story/defense/policy-budget/congr...
- ForcesOfOdin 11y agoI love Smedley Butler! Good link. Always wiki - the business plot to see how corporate america tried to get Smedley Butler to lead a military coup of mercenaries against the US government during FDR's presidency.
- 345218435 11y agoi am surprised butler got this far on hn. read this before the next elections. before the next assad. before your friends and relatives go on tours with the troops.
- basicplus2 11y agoWar is always connected to money... here is an example.. http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/allwarsarebankerwars.php#axzz42DJTMMFQ http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/allwarsarebankerwa...
- notahacker 11y ago>it is important to remember that prior to the creation of the Federal Reserve, there was no such thing as a world war. > Although pre-war Germany had a private central bank, it was heavily restricted and inflation kept to reasonable levels... So, in the media of the day, Germany was portrayed as the prime opponent of World War One The invasion of Russia, Belgium and France might have had something to do with it as well. > as early as 1933 they started to organize a global boycott against Germany to strangle this upstart ruler who thought he could break free of private central bankers [poster of "Judea Declares war on Germany" headline] Come on HN, we're better than this sort of nutjobbery.
- yourapostasy 11y agoIf you liked Butler's perspective, then you will probably also like Garet Garrett's [0] oeuvre. He was an outspoken critic of WWI, and of America's entry into WWII until after Pearl Harbor. His position against an imperial America delivers a wider context to Butler's field experience as handmaiden to American power elites' ambitions accomplishing just that outcome. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garet_Garrett https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garet_Garrett
- arca_vorago 11y agoI have read through the comments, and it strikes me that I dont see more combat vets on here. I knew some really smark hackers while I was in the Marine Corps, even though I was just a bullet sponge grunt in OIF/OEF. It also gladens my heart just to see my favorite Marine, Smedley Butler, get some "air time". It does dissapoint me that so many in the comments are making escuses for war as a profit or r&d center, or for war crimes prosecutions of what are essentially pawns on a grander chessboard. In the Marine Corps, a lot of people have a hardon for Chesty Puller, but the phrase I used to use is "If you like Chest more than Smedley you do the country and the Corps a disservice." Why? Because not only did Smedley Butler wake up and realize the true nature of the part he played, but he spoke out against it, and beyond that, something I havent seen mentioned yet but something I think is of the utmost importance is his thwarting of the business plot. His convressional hearing testimony is vital to understanding the modern racket of war, and now we have the unredacted version, (though still not his full testimony, because it was heavily edited before even entering the record). If you havent read the unredacted testimony, I highly suggest it. All that being said, war indeed is a racket, and it continues to be. The WFA (waste fraud and abuse) I saw in Iraq by contractors is barely the icing on the racket cake. There is a reason that something like the richest three counties in the US are in Virginia. The true racket though, is much larger than the contractor world, and primarily involves banking and resource oriented interests. I spent a long time voraciously reading anything I thought could help me understand the bigger geostrategic/political chessboard, and my primary conclusion about the wars were that resource wars are on the horizon, and the wars were destabilizing measures designed to contain China and Russia by prevention of resource pipelines being built to them. Take a look at the maps of resources and their pipelines... The other factor is that the traditional nation state actor threat model is being upended by texhnology, to the point that the military industrial congressional complex isadjusting very quickly. My primary problem with this is how much the people of the US have been lied to and misled. If the United States has some interest in destabilizing an area, I would prefer that this just be said and the case be made outright, instead of sending young dumb warriors like myself to die for causes they dont understand and are lied to about. You want to know where I feel like the primary failure lies at? Every O-5 and above officer who just went along with it and didnt pushback against the Cheney, Bremer, Wolfowitz, Rumsfield bunch of Chicago school Straussian neocons backed by Kissinger and Brezenski. When you cant tell me what my fucking objective is, how can I be expected to accomplish it? In truth, where we are headed currently is a return to the tripolar world, but in this move, I think we will never fully understand the almost complete subversion of our government that has happened at the behest of the globalists. Smedley Butler caught a glimpse of the beast and had the courage to fight against it openly. He will continue to be my favorite Marine until I die. Oh, and for any of you touting the economic benefits of war, I hope you never are on the ground on either side when that benefit is being extracted by blood and corruption...
- kingkawn 11y agoWar allows populations that don't share markets to still develop markets in relationship to each other for weapons, infrastructure repair, etc.