5 ms·
Yes, and I would add this text is naive (in some aspects) Being a CEO you sometimes need to enter agreements you can't honour (at the time). It's condescendin
by raverbashing 11y ago
Yes, and I would add this text is naive (in some aspects)
Being a CEO you sometimes need to enter agreements you can't honour (at the time).
It's condescending
> So, for example, if there is some kind of lucrative short-cut to making a lot of money but it is illegal in your jurisdiction to do so: don’t do it.
Youtube, Uber, Airbnb have been founded on a grey legal area, some other ones have closed because of it (like the one that would stream OTA TV, I forgot the name)
- Ologn 11y agoNowadays people forget that Google was founded on a grey legal area.
- raverbashing 11y agoWhat was that?
- Ologn 11y agoThe areas raised in cases such as Field v. Google.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat was just about google caching stuff and making that cache available again, it has nothing to do with the core of google (search engine / advertising) and was not as far as I can see a founding principle for google.
- Ologn 11y agoThe core of Google is a search engine and that case has everything to do with the founding principles of Google. As I said, this is just one of the cases. There was also Parker v. Google. Or Authors Guild et al vs. Google. Or Viacom v. Google.
- jacquesm 11y agoNo, because they don't actually have to expose the cache to make a working search engine. The Authors Guild had to do with Google books and Viacom vs Google was an outflow of them buying youtube. Really, you are simply not correct about any of this.
- Ologn 11y agoAlso Belgian Association of Newspaper Editors v Google. Also Perfect 10 v Google. These cases mostly revolve around the same issue - they say Google is ripping off their content.
- jacquesm 11y agoYou keep on bringing more and more stuff on that has nothing to do with what google was founded on. Google news linking to newspaper articles has nothing to do with the search engine and so on (it was in fact someone's '20%' project that gained traction long after google was founded). Anyway, I'm done with pointing these out, yes, google got sued a lot, nobody ever - as far as I know - sued them on what they were founded on, let's say pagerank or the fact that they are a search engine at all or anything closely related to their mainstay of income once they found a way to generate it (adsense). And there was absolutely nothing 'legally gray' about it.
- dilemma 11y agoYour dismissal of what the parent brought up is arbitrary. All of these lawsuits are due to Google's business model, which it needs to keep the search engine running.
- jacquesm 11y agoNo, google could run their search engine just fine on just adsense, we know that because they did. All that other stuff came later.
- amelius 11y agoIsn't a search index a kind of cache? I mean, invert it, and you get a pretty good picture of the original data.
- jacquesm 11y agoTypically the index only returns an abstract, not the whole article, yes, you could invert the index on a word-by-word basis and reconstitute some or all of the articles but that is not the interface that is exposed to the outside world and that was definitely not what this lawsuit was about. The statement that 'google was founded on a gray legal area' holds absolutely no water for me.
- jacquesm 11y agoYou can't hold up Youtube, Uber and Airbnb as examples for others to follow, those are extreme outliers that willfully and consciously chose to challenge a very specific aspect of the law. In the case of Youtube the only thing that saved their asses was the fact that they got bought out by a party strong enough that they could stand the heat, the other two had sufficient funding that they could take a chance on the battle not lasting longer than they could afford. There is nothing condescending about this post and if you feel that as a CEO you 'sometimes need to enter into agreements you can't honour (at the time)' then you've misunderstood what this is all about, if you enter into such an agreement you are actively misleading the other party and they may very well have cause to sue you personally if your gamble does not pay off and this will likely stick. If that's ok with you, then be my guest, go sign whatever you feel like and to hell with the consequences but do not complain that you have not been warned.
- raverbashing 11y ago> if you enter into such an agreement you are actively misleading the other party and they may very well have cause to sue you personally if your gamble does not pay off and this will likely stick True, but not necessarily misleading. And of course you may be subjecting yourself to a lawsuit (also depends on the juridical safety of the location you're in) Selling before buying is pretty common.
- jacquesm 11y agoIn that context you are right. But in the context of ordering a large shipment of goods that you have no ability to pay for gambling that you will have the money by the time the invoice is due is going to get you looked at in a different light. Depending on the magnitude of the transgression you could be looking at anything from an honest mistake all the way up to fraud and deception. It's important to know where the distinction lies, and as a general rule you should not contract when you can expect that you will not be able to perform. And by your example your expectation to perform hinges on your suppliers ability to deliver and all things being normal you are actually able to expect this. That's a 'chain' of liability that does not end with you.
- 11y ago
- taude 11y agoAereo is the OTV TV company name you're thinking of.