2 ms·
Or fewer men have a choice. With some jobs they're not just unattractive but one is simply incapable of meeting the physical demands. If you need to be stronge
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
Or fewer men have a choice.
With some jobs they're not just unattractive but one is simply incapable of meeting the physical demands. If you need to be stronger than 80% of men to be able to do a job then there's going to be a vanishingly small percentage of women able to do it. Then you need those women to have no better option, or a strong desire to do that particular job, with a lot of jobs.
It's like jobs with lots of manual dexterity needed, if you have bigger hands you can't do it well - this means women (and in some places children) have these jobs.
- jhanschoo 11y agoBut to what extent are physical factors a rationalization? We can mix-and-match the genders and degree of manual labor involved and see exceptions; men working in construction; men working as engineers; men working sedentary office jobs; women in nursing; women in education; men and women in animal husbandry. To me it's not obvious what the dimensions are that are relevant to professions that humans have a gender disposition toward, and what percentage of out current distribution of professions should be explained by cultural ideas rather than such dispositions, and it may never be obvious. Regardless, (and this is a tangent to the current comment thread) I understand the current push for gender diversity in professions to have several purposes that is not contingent on there being no gender disposition in professions. 1) Maximizing individual capabilities. The idea being that proponents of profession diversity wants to increase the number of fulfilling career paths an individual is able to make by removing obstacles, real and perceived, by the individual and by the industry. Obstacles include, for example, pay differences, glass ceilings, stigmata, workplace hours. 2) Increasing manpower, which is related to the previous goal, but from the perspective of government. When people able to perform well at a job but instead work at a job where they provide suboptimal utility due to gender discrimination, that is value lost for a society. When professions and gender are rigid, that is resilience and flexibility compromised. A competitive society thus has an incentive to decouple professions from gender. Thus, whereas a gender disposition may explain present distributions, it nevertheless does not invalidate the reasons behind
- DanBC 11y ago> It's like jobs with lots of manual dexterity needed, if you have bigger hands you can't do it well - this means women (and in some places children) have these jobs. This kind of thing was said in the 60s when factory owners employed women. "Nimble fingers!" The reason they said it was because unions were much weaker at protecting women's rights, and so bosses could pay women considerably less for work of equivalent skill. That's what the Dagenham strikes were about. That was in 1968 so it's really weird to hear it still being said today. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_sewing_machinists_strike_of_1968 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_sewing_machinists_strike_...
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoI get my kids to help with things that require holding small objects, my fingers just can't grip them well. When I'm teaching pottery I find men can manage to work the clay (needs muscle) but women are much better where more dexterity is needed. Perhaps it served the purposes of factory owners to emphasise it but I'd assumed that was why factories globally [seemingly] have more women doing soldering of components and placing of electronics in to casings and such. I spend a good deal of time looking at other people's hands (pottery workshops) and find as a generality that women do have more nimble fingers and less upper body strength (of course it's a distribution that overlaps); nimbleness might be down to other activities rather than being inherent in females but that wouldn't stop more females having roles that favour nimbleness. Using a sewing machine for large items like car upholstery I can't see hand-size being terribly important; I've moderately large hands and never had a problem with using a sewing machine - I can't manage needle and thread too well though. That said your link seems to concern the general idea of paying women less conflated with a specific job being degraded in value rather than the idea of men/womens general body sizes being pertinent to suitability for certain jobs.