4 ms·
But there's no shareholder value in acknowledging externalities, so most professional CEOs appointed by a board won't challenge immoral acts if it would contrad
by EdwardDiego 11y ago
But there's no shareholder value in acknowledging externalities, so most professional CEOs appointed by a board won't challenge immoral acts if it would contradict their mantra to "increase shareholder value".
As a recently arrived member of the "C-suite", I find that the cult of maximising shareholder value leaves me cold. But ultimately, the shareholders pay the piper, so they can call the tune.
- mehrdada 11y agoIt goes even beyond just upsetting some shareholders paying for it. The CEO has the fiduciary duty to ignore such externalities.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat is an oft repeated un-truth.
- mehrdada 11y agoWould love to be corrected with evidence.
- jacquesm 11y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-corporations-obligations-to-shareholders/corporations-dont-have-to-maximize-profits http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-cor... Will that do?
- mehrdada 11y agoSure, "shareholder values" is not the same thing as bottom line profit and it might be subjective depending on a number of factors, but it is also not the same thing as value to the broader society; it can be at odds with it depending on who the shareholder is. The duty might be vague to define in practice, but it still is very much in existence. I don't think that article claims this is untrue, just that the fiduciary duty is broader than the dollar amount in the financial statements.
- jacquesm 11y ago> I don't think that article claims this is untrue "There is a common belief that corporate directors have a legal duty to maximize corporate profits and “shareholder value” — even if this means skirting ethical rules, damaging the environment or harming employees. But this belief is utterly false. To quote the U.S. Supreme Court opinion in the recent Hobby Lobby case: “Modern corporate law does not require for-profit corporations to pursue profit at the expense of everything else, and many do not.”" How much clearer could it be? Note that shareholders can and will sue companies, the board and the executives for whatever reasons they feel will hold water, but suing is not the same as winning that suit, and that the final interpretation of what your required course of action was in a given situation is in the end up to a judge, not up to a shareholder.
- dahart 11y agoJacques, I actually didn't know this. It is a claim that has gone around and is often repeated, I'm pretty sure I've heard it used in "expert" interviews in financial & political documentaries, so I guess I assumed it was true. This might be important enough of a point to include in your post? The actions of a CEO facing difficult decisions might hinge on which of several competing responsibilities they feel most bound or affected by, and removing the belief there's a profit requirement could push Some situations out of gray areas. I'm guessing there also are plenty of other people who also believe that CEOs are bound by law to pursue profits and shareholder values.
- jacquesm 11y agoI will probably do a separate blog post on that one of these days.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Note that shareholders can and will sue companies, the board and the executives for whatever reasons they feel will hold water, but suing is not the same as winning that suit That's not really the cause of the trouble though. It's that when you're the CEO of a publicly-traded company (i.e. a company owned predominantly by mutual funds that want higher profits), your compensation and continued employment will be based on increasing quarterly profits. So even though there are things you can do that are less profitable without violating your fiduciary duty to the shareholders, doing those things will still cause you to lose your bonus or your job. So the people who stand on their ethics are eventually replaced with people who don't, because the people who don't have better numbers and the shareholders only see how much profit was made, not why.
- switch007 11y agoOnus Probandi (incumbit ei qui dicit, non ei qui negat)
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoPerhaps you could start by citing that law that requires CEOs to ignore morality and ethics and prefer profit as the sole guiding principle?
- jacquesm 11y agoNot just prefer, require!
- jfoster 11y agoShareholder value is put at risk whenever a company takes actions that risk negative PR or reducing employee morale.
- Confusion 11y agoThere certainly can be shareholder value in acknowledging externalities. Proof examples: The Body Shop, many cases where a company gambled on something immoral not being illegal (pollution, fraud) and being wrong, cases where the public gaining knowledge of the externalities cost the company its reputation, etc.
- tamana 11y ago"Maximizing shareholder value" is essentially a myth. Management has wide latitude in deciding how to make long term bets for the brand. Management's job is to decide almost all questions, shareholders choose to buy and sell. Shareholders have no liability for crimes and torts, management does.