9 ms·
Eating chocolate is associated with improved brain function
- steve371 11y agoI won't even argue if the study is bias or not. Let's just say chocolate is good for the brain. But is it advisable for people to consume them in certain amount daily? Well, back in the days, there were numeric studies about benefit of tobacco too.
- Gatsky 11y agoSelf-reported chocolate intake? There are so many possible confounders here. It seens quite implausible that chocolate can acutely enhance cognitive ability. Alternative explanations are more likely, although not newsworthy. I also think that nutrition science, which is deficient enough as it is, should not be mixed with epidemiology, which seems designed to detect spurious associations.
- mystikal 11y agoThere's caffeine and sugar in it, seems reasonable, plus the pleasure of it means more endorphins. That's like three direct up-regulators of brain function.
- Gatsky 11y agoWell the researchers say in the article that sugar should impair cognition. Caffeine and feeling good are confounders, as they aren't unique to chocolate. The researchers are proposing that it is some kind of special ingredient in chocolate you can't really get anywhere else easily that enhances cognitive function.
- mystikal 11y agoYeah, I agree that they should control for those things...
- im3w1l 11y agoAlso theobromine
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoAnd theophylline. From wikipedia[1]: Theophylline is naturally found in cocoa beans. Amounts as high as 3.7 mg/g have been reported in Criollo cocoa beans. Medical uses[edit] The main actions of theophylline involve: - relaxing bronchial smooth muscle - increasing heart muscle contractility and efficiency; as a positive inotropic - increasing heart rate: (positive chronotropic)[1] - increasing blood pressure - increasing renal blood flow - anti-inflammatory effects - central nervous system stimulatory effect mainly on the medullary respiratory center. Theophylline is also a metabolite of caffeine[2]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theophylline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theophylline 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caffeine#Pharmacokinetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caffeine#Pharmacokinetics
- leereeves 11y agoWe should consider all research skeptically, but why does it seem particularly implausible that cocoa flavanols can enhance cognitive ability? Other research: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=cocoa+flavanols+cognition https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=cocoa+flavanols+cogniti...
- pps43 11y agoI think the point here is not which prior to use for effect of chocolate, but how to account for the differences between actual and self-reported chocolate consumption, which itself might be correlated with cognitive ability. Maybe people who ate chocolate but did not report it (because "eating too much chocolate is bad for you") tended to have lower cognitive ability - they did not realise that by reporting incorrect intake they introduced bias in the study.
- winter_blue 11y agoJust as an FYI, I found a company recently that makes chocolate with zeor sugar, that's sweetened with Stevia: https://www.cocopolo.com/ https://www.cocopolo.com/ I didn't like their dark chocolate, but their milk chocolate comes pretty close to regular milk chocolate.
- DenisM 11y agoAre you conserved with sugar per se, or the insulin response? Cocoa causes insulin spike even when sugar-free, iirc.
- winter_blue 11y agoYup, I am concerned about the insulin response / glycemic index. Hmm...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DenisM 11y agoFound it on https://www.researchgate.net https://www.researchgate.net "Holt SHA, Brand Miller JC, Petocz P. An insulin index of foods: the insulin demand generated by 1000-kJ portions of common foods. Am J Clin Nutr 66, 1264-1276" I highly recommend it as a source for glycemic response of different foods; some things are entirely counterintuitive. Are you on low sugar/flour/starch diet?
- winter_blue 11y agoI am not on a low sugar/flour/starch diet right now, but I'm trying to switch to one. I have a family history of diabetes. I've mostly cut out sugar. But cutting out flour/starch has been a bit harder.
- wobbleblob 11y agoWhat is this current obsession with stevia? It has a very strong, pretty much unpalatable taste that even strong espresso can't mask.
- kccqzy 11y agoI'm not disparaging the researchers here but really I couldn't help thinking of this: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- rdancer 11y agoIf you're wondering why you're getting downvoted: The figure of speech you're using is colloquially known as "no offence, but you're an arsehole"[0]. [0] http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=no+offense&page=2 http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=no+offense&pa...
- at-fates-hands 11y agoI have to take this with a grain of salt considering the guy who put out the fake research on how eating chocolate can make lose you weight was just revealed to be a huge hoax: http://io9.gizmodo.com/i-fooled-millions-into-thinking-chocolate-helps-weight-1707251800 http://io9.gizmodo.com/i-fooled-millions-into-thinking-choco...
- codeddesign 11y ago"This article is brought to you by Nestle" ;)
- brahmwg 11y agoPrevious thread; https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11155532 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11155532
- nonuby 11y agoThis old chestnut has been published in mainstream media for decades, the Daily Mail in the UK much feature it at least once a year (on the odd day a cancer scare doesn't exist). I remember every exam been given chocolate to take with me, and we're going back to early/mid 90s here.
- songzme 11y agoFrom personal experience, every bite of chocolate provides me a moment of bliss and happiness. I think happiness is the real reason for improved brain function. I find myself most productive and most capable when I am happy.
- toephu2 11y agoThat's called dopamine. The chocolate you eat probably has sugar in it (otherwise it tastes horrible; try raw cacao), and sugar is a drug associated w/ the release of dopamine in the brain.
- ktRolster 11y ago> otherwise it tastes horrible; try raw cacao It's actually delicious, and each bean has its own flavor. If you live near Silicon Valley, head up to Dandelion chocolate and you can try some there (work up to it by getting used to the bitter chocolate first)
- netghost 11y agoIf you live in Seattle, drop by the Theo Chocolate factory in Fremont. Delicious.
- wapapaloobop 11y ago>otherwise it tastes horrible; try raw cacao Every luxury food or drug tastes horrible until you've learnt to enjoy it. Remember your first beer or coffee? My guess is sugar would initially taste somewhat foul ('sickly sweet') if one was brought up without it. EDIT: I'm not recommending that people start snorting or imbibing cocoa powder. However I think that if this were the only form of chocolate then one would quickly learn to enjoy it.
- Riesling 11y agoFrom my personal experience, I have to agree with wapapaloobop. I put a spoon of raw cacao in my morning coffee, because I love the taste. However I drink (and eat no) sugar whatsoever and found the taste disgusting (in the sense of spitting it out) when I accidentally drank from my girlfriends coffee some time ago.
- yxitcti 11y agoI long for the day when these correlation-digging studies with absurd claims will stop. https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- adenadel 11y agoYou should take a look at the journal article. They comment on how they corrected for multiple testing "In addition to MANOVA, the Bonferroni procedure was used to protect against multiple comparisons." The Bonferroni correction is one of the most conservative ways to correct for multiple testing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonferroni_correction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonferroni_correction
- Gatsky 11y agoThe study is still 'correlation-digging'. Bonferroni won't fix the problem that these kinds of studies will throw up statistically significant associations that provide no insight into anything meaningful, due to confounders, biases, poor design etc. There is no equivalent xkcd however.
- adenadel 11y agoI don't think that anyone would take the results of this article as a statement of absolute fact. In the discussion they mentioned some more (better controlled) studies investigating the role of cocoa flavanols in "cognitive tasks". Doing any longitudinal study with humans suffer from confounders, biases, and poor design because we can't do controlled, long-term research on humans. You just have to take these limitations into account when you are interpreting the results and use any findings as areas for possible further investigation.
- Gatsky 11y agoYes, that's fine, I was pointing out that correcting for multiple hypothesis testing does not deal with the issue cited (albeit rather abruptly) by yxitcti.
- horsecaptin 11y agoY'all, we need to have a discussion about this stuff. How did this story make it to the top of Hacker News?
- goblinking 11y agook. are you all a bunch of hippos. i thought this was hacker news, good lord
- obeseman 11y agoare you all a bunch of hippos
- cbd1984 11y ago... says a chocolate maker.
- user1857 11y agoin my personal experience, eating chocolate has pushed me into IBS trouble, which i realized such a disease existed after 15 years. I stopped eating chocolate for the past 5 years. Now i am happy. Brain is a sugar sucker. Eat food which has natural sugar (like fruits) and you still be happy. Chocolate is just one sour junk which sugar added to please your bain (which is the trick). I think eat the chocolate without sugar and see if it sill improves brain function
- colanderman 11y agoBitter, not sour. Lemons are sour.
- user1857 11y agoforgive my english. its not my native.
- goldenkey 11y agoIts kind of cliche to target excess consumption of a rake and claim its terrible since you took the extreme cold turkey. All pleasures are best used moderately. Its an adage as old as good and evil itself.
- a3n 11y agoWhy not eat unsweetened chocolate? Take it like a vitamin.
- carbocation 11y agoThe study is here[1; non-paywalled]. A series of follow-ups might look like this: 1: GWAS to look for genetic association with chocolate consumption. 2: Mendelian randomization to assess whether an inherent predisposition for increased chocolate consumption leads to increased cognitive function. The same approach has been used to assess whether there is a dose-response of alcohol on mortality (the answer appears to be "yes," and there is no U-shaped curve).[2; non-paywalled] This is mostly just to say that I'm not convinced by such tortured data in an association study, but if there is enough interest in the hypothesis, then the path forward to assess causality is clear. 1 = http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195666316300459 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195666316... 2 = http://www.bmj.com/content/349/bmj.g4164 http://www.bmj.com/content/349/bmj.g4164
- kingsley3 11y agoTwo studies found that the main ingredient in chocolate, cocoa, reduced all-cause mortality[1,2]. I tested it's effect on my so called "biological" age. It seemed to make me a little younger. There's a fun new 5 minute video about my experiment called "The Younger Year"[3]. It has before and after clips of yours truly. Thanks, Kingsley References [1] Arch Intern Med. 2006 Feb 27;166(4):411-7. Cocoa intake, blood pressure, and cardiovascular mortality: the Zutphen Elderly Study. Buijsse B, Feskens EJ, Kok FJ, Kromhout D. [2] Bayard V, Chamorro F, Motta J, Hollenberg NK. Does Flavanol Intake Influence Mortality from Nitric Oxide-Dependent Processes? Ischemic Heart Disease, Stroke, Diabetes Mellitus, and Cancer in Panama. Int J Med Sci 2007; 4(1):53-58. doi:10.7150/ijms.4.53. Available [3] "The Younger Year" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r7XcJ2VsLhI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r7XcJ2VsLhI
- _snydly 11y agoIt's better to wait for multiple, large randomized controlled trials to be performed before making claims about improved brain function. But maybe, for now, we can eat more chocolate for another ~proven benefit: "Flavanol-rich chocolate and cocoa products may have a small but statistically significant effect in lowering blood pressure.." http://www.cochrane.org/CD008893/HTN_effect-of-cocoa-on-blood-pressure http://www.cochrane.org/CD008893/HTN_effect-of-cocoa-on-bloo...
- daljeetv 11y agois chocolate a nootropic?
- Synaesthesia 11y agoFood companies distort nutrition science by funding studies. That's why we have very specific titles like "Concord grape juice, cognitive function, and driving performance," or, "Walnut ingestion in adults at risk for diabetes." Usually the results are positive. http://www.vox.com/2016/3/3/11148422/food-science-nutrition-research-bias-conflict-interest http://www.vox.com/2016/3/3/11148422/food-science-nutrition-...
- gjm11 11y agoTrue and important. But this particular study doesn't seem to be an instance of that phenomenon. So far as I can tell, no one involved was funded by the food industry, and what they did was to look broadly for connections between diet and cognitive function and this turned up. Now, there are other problems with that sort of data-mining and determining whether they've successfully avoided them all is highly nontrivial (and I haven't tried). So this might still be bad science. But it doesn't appear to be funded-by-vested-interests bad.
- driverdan 11y agoThat has absolutely nothing to do with this study.
- cbd1984 11y agoIt's the only reason this study exists, or got the results it did.
- SoleSoul 11y ago'L' would approve.
- alexchamberlain 11y agoThere is a radio program in the UK called More or Less, who''s (whom's?) motto is "Correlation is not causation". Admittedly, I have neither read the paper, nor did I fully understand the section on proving the direction of influence, but I can't help but feel this research makes pretty poor use of statistics and logic, however much I wish to believe the result. Is all nutritional research this bad?
- leoedin 11y agoYou haven't read the original paper, don't even understand the methodology they used to reach their conclusions and yet you "can't help but feel this research makes pretty poor use of statistics and logic"? It seems something is bad here, but I don't think it's the nutritional research. If you can't be bothered to actually read the paper, why do you think you're able to critique it?
- wapapaloobop 11y agoCos it doesn't work with an explanation. Science is about explaining things.
- PeterWhittaker 11y agoHmm, yes, that is true. But "science" doesn't pull explanations from the air (that would be religion or superstition, ya know). Science first finds unlikely or unexpected correlations, unlikely or unexpected measurements, and seeks to understand from whence they came. Are they artifacts of the observation process? Tainting of the measurement process? Or spurious correlations, such as the one between height and spelling ability (both of which are strongly correlated with age, up to a certain point)? This particular research announces an unexpected correlation and goes to pains to show that it is real, and not spurious. This is the observation phase, the oh, didn't expect that phase. Explanation will come later, likely after someone designs a more accurate and precise experiment to better correlate chocolate consumption and cognitive ability.
- 11y ago
- kotach 11y agoAll food is healthy. Diets can be unhealthy. It really is interesting that the whole science is concentrating on a single ingredient.
- astrange 11y ago> All food is healthy. Except for the food with cyanide in it.
- lucideer 11y agoLike apples
- chris_wot 11y agoAnd walnuts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kotach 11y agoYeah, that's exactly the food I was thinking of. Cheeseburger + chocolate milk shake. Quinoa with kale. What would you say is more healthy? The comparison is idiotic. If a person suffers anorexia their whole diet is unhealthy and has to become healthy. Their relationship with food is also unhealthy. The former is much more suitable meal for someone having difficulties meeting their caloric needs. If they have it couple of times a day every day, then we know the diet is unhealthy. The latter can be a nice addition to a healthy diet. The amount of downvotes on my first comment means that quite a lot of community here have an unhealthy relationship with food. https://atheismfaq.quora.com/Is-this-food-healthy https://atheismfaq.quora.com/Is-this-food-healthy Checkout the link above. I hope it'll improve your relationship with food.
- noir_lord 11y agoEverything in moderation, I read a report a while back about the people who provide food for post operative care (iirc it was mostly eldery people) where they threw out the normal diet guidelines and went for "stodge", pasta, custard, pies, cake - basically anything that was easy to digest and high in calories as they found that gave the best outcome post surgery. It wouldn't be the diet you'd eat in other circumstances but context matters.
- have_faith 11y agoReminds me very much of this: https://kill-or-cure.herokuapp.com https://kill-or-cure.herokuapp.com A list of what the Daily Mail has reported will kill or cure cancer. I won't spoil chocolates outcome.
- sarreph 11y agoI remember there was a similar headline to this — comparing the high ratio of chocolate-eating to non-chocolate-eating Nobel laureates — in the Fall of 2012. My Quantitive Methods lecturer used it as a perfect example of the correlation/causation fallacy; it was certainly a good way of lightening the mood at a 9am Friday lecture :)
- louwrentius 11y agoSo smart people have a knack for chocolate?
- dagurp 11y agoJust in time for easter
- delinka 11y agoThose with 'improved brain function' generally eat more chocolate. Now I can say with impunity "I prefer chocolate because I have improved brain function." Chocolate improves brain function. Now I can say with impunity "Chocolate is improving my brain function."
- krzyk 11y agoWould be good to make a longer study that takes into account that cocoa contains cadmium, which is quite toxic and probably might increase a chance of cancer.
- Pxtl 11y agoWasn't one of these health-benefits-of-chocolate papers revealed to be a deliberate prank?
- thatusertwo 11y agoSome of the characters who are suppose to be super smart in 'Death Note' are always eating sweets / chocolate.
- cbd1984 11y agoDoes anyone really believe this wasn't paid for by a chocolate maker?