6 ms·
Meet the Lab Girl
- jheriko 11y agoblah blah feminism feminism feminism lets not treat women as equals. :/ please stop pretending women are somehow inferior to men and need articles to promote their position as if they are :/
- striking 11y ago> I’m very cynical about efforts to get girls into science. I’m very cynical about efforts that are meant to change women into something better. And, it’s time for them to be the new thing that is good to be. That’s fine for women who feel drawn to science—I’m certainly one of them. But every time we tell girls to be something else, we’re also telling them that whatever they are isn’t enough. You seem to have posted this on the wrong article, because it appears that the interviewee agrees with you.
- newjersey 11y agoThank you for writing this. I am sad to see the grand parent down voted because it seems the down voters themselves have not read the article. Personally, I feel like I am the worst kind of people. I remember being in Texas about nine years back talking to some young women who were passionately anti-choice (or pro-life as they call themselves) and I found myself thinking "but you're a woman". I don't I said anything that revealed my thought process. It feels like it should be easy, right? Just treat individuals as individuals and don't stereotype. Well, easier said than done in my case. Similarly with black people. Just because someone is black and American does not mean they have to be in favor of reparations. Just because someone is a woman does not mean they have to be a feminist. I remind myself of this fact every so often and I realize I am a bad person. However, worse than me are the people who dare tell others they are wrong and don't know what is best for them because of their ideas or choices.
- striking 11y agoDon't be so hard on yourself. It takes a lot of courage to admit something like that. Being open-minded is not something that you accomplish in one step. It takes constant effort to try to see something from different perspectives. Sometimes you end up changing your mind; or, on account of how nice you are and how well you explain your side, you may end up changing theirs. It's good that you're at least trying to improve yourself. That means you're already doing better than many people out there.
- dang 11y agoPlease stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- rustynails 11y agoWhy not say that about the article itself? I found the comment fine. There are plenty of unsubstantive comments here. Why single out this poster?
- Zikes 11y agoThe article clearly has substance, it just doesn't align with your opinion on the topic. dang definitely didn't "single out" the commenter, which a cursory glance at dang's comment history will corroborate - hell if you go back far enough he's told me the exact same thing. If jheriko had phrased their comment more constructively, there would likely be no issue.
- dang 11y agoIf you think I'm singling anyone out, take a look at https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=dang https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=dang. I'm posting these all the time, unfortunately. (Edit: I see that Zikes already pointed this out.) I wouldn't say the article was particularly substantive, but by HN's standards the comment wasn't fine. It was (a) fluff, (b) generic, (c) ideological, (d) inflammatory, and (e) by an account that has done this before.
- sgentle 11y agoI've always thought there's a terrible and subtle kind of sexism in articles that are about women who do very interesting things, but ignore those interesting things to focus exclusively on gender. I don't think that's any less true when the way they bring up gender is positive; it's still reducing women to a single dimension. However, this article isn't that. Out of the 13 questions here, only 1 was about gender and how gender affected her experience as a scientist. Any less and you would be arguing that that her gender wasn't relevant to her life at all, which is a pretty tenuous position to take. I have to ask, did you read the article? It was a pretty good article and worth re-reading if all you got from it was "rah rah women rah rah". I particularly liked the question "Why do you love trees?".
- rustynails 11y agoI would love to see a world where we don't define ourselves by our gender at all. I don't think 1 in 13 questions should be about gender, let alone 1 in 100. There is so much more to life. I greatly respect those that can rise above it. My female friends see themselves as people, not genders. I don't talk to them as women and it's fantastic: the conversations are very transparent. I rarely get along with a woman who defines herself by her gender or a guy who defines himself by his gender. It saddens me that the overwhelming majority of people can not look past their gender. Even HN with extensive open mindedness has many people who are incapable of seeing themselves past their own gender.
- Zikes 11y agoI think it's a perfectly valid topic. We can't pretend men and women are the same, especially in cases where a person's gender is unusual for a given circumstance. In the interviewee's case that certainly applies, so her perspective on that point is relevant and welcome. I do happen to disagree with her on a few key points, but I do think the discussion is important.
- vixen99 11y agoHow do you know that the overwhelming majority of people can not look past their gender? The assumptions in your comment amaze me but that's just me I suppose.
- Zikes 11y ago> I think wherever you look in the world, you see a field or an endeavor that’s not got women in it. You can ask yourself why aren’t there women there? And the answer is always the same: It’s because women aren’t welcome. Does that include coal mining, construction, fishing, farming, forestry/logging, waste disposal, protective services, dishwashing, landscaping/groundskeeping, pest control, stonemasonry, flooring, plumbing, highway maintenance, auto mechanics, HVAC, machining, welding, cabinetry, wastewater treatment, and truck driving? Or is it more likely that jobs that are extremely dangerous, highly stressful, physically demanding, low pay, or any or all of the above just aren't very attractive to women? I mean, they're not all that attractive to a lot of men, either, so that's perfectly fine. I don't really like the thought of spending weeks at a time on a small fishing trawler with a dozen other guys, myself, especially if there's a 1 in 1,000 chance I'd die from it. My aunt used to be a truck driver. She enjoyed it, the pay was decent and got along great with a lot of the drivers she ran into. She also got mugged a few times, often at gunpoint.
- sneak 11y ago> Or is it more likely that jobs that are extremely dangerous, highly stressful, physically demanding, low pay, or any or all of the above just aren't very attractive to women? I mean, they're not all that attractive to a lot of men, either, so that's perfectly fine. And you've hit on the point - jobs that aren't attractive to women aren't attractive to men, either. The result is that women aren't there because they're unwelcome, not because women shy away from "heavy" work.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoOr fewer men have a choice. With some jobs they're not just unattractive but one is simply incapable of meeting the physical demands. If you need to be stronger than 80% of men to be able to do a job then there's going to be a vanishingly small percentage of women able to do it. Then you need those women to have no better option, or a strong desire to do that particular job, with a lot of jobs. It's like jobs with lots of manual dexterity needed, if you have bigger hands you can't do it well - this means women (and in some places children) have these jobs.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoGreat article, interesting questions and engaging answers. I especially liked the way the interviewee brought in conflicting perspectives, such as the enlightenment view of nature vs. the romantic view of nature in the debate around what's best for the environment.