7 ms·
Was interesting to hear the entire perspective but the "marriage thing?" That wasn't exactly small. Imagine if gave money instead to the KKK... would that have
by azinman2 11y ago
Was interesting to hear the entire perspective but the "marriage thing?" That wasn't exactly small. Imagine if gave money instead to the KKK... would that have been just "a racial heritage thing?"
Backing something that separates families is divisive and not appropriate for an organization that is about openness and diversity, especially given the current tech climate of monoculture.
Engineers can really be the worst offenders when it comes to hate-like views, I think in part because they're likely smarter than the average person so they've completely convinced themselves that they're the rational ones.
I remember back when I was at Google in 2008. A survey on lgbt issues went around company wide. What came back was so completely shocking and insane, especially out of Russia and India. Burn them, kill them, they don't desire to live, etc. And this was a survey you gave back to your employer!!!
Edit: as many people have missed my point let me clarify. The comparison against the KKK was simply to illustrate that who you donate to and support affects your organization, especially when that cause negatively impacts the personal lives of your employees (and goes against your org core values, and reinforces an existing problem of monoculture). I'm not saying prop 8 == KKK, I'm showing that personal beliefs matter when you're a leader.
- kozukumi 11y agoWell it is to be expected from places like Russia and India tbh. I am from the UK and such comments would be seen as shocking but we all know Russia hates gay people it makes sense that employees who grew up and continue to live in Russia are going to have very Russian views. Just because they work for a modern, progressive company such as Google (or Microsoft or Apple ...) isn't going to change their opinions on such things. You would have got the same kind of responses in America if you asked about how blacks should be treated/integrated into the company back in the 1950s.
- binaryapparatus 11y ago> Well it is to be expected from places like Russia and India tbh. Every single person in the world knows that one hundred percent of all the people from the UK know damn well to stay away from generalizations. Oh wait.
- pjscott 11y agoYou've interpreted a statistical claim about population means as a universal claim about all members of a group. That is incorrect, uncharitable, and unhelpful if your goal is discussion rather than browbeating.
- kozukumi 11y agoUgh I knew somebody would bring up generalisations. Yes yes I know not every single person in Russia hates and wants to kill gay people. Ask a gay person if they would go to Russia and be openly gay without worrying about it? I doubt you would find many who would be fine with doing that. I have been to Russia many times, it is an amazing place, but I have seen how anti-gay many places in Russia are so yeah I will generalise and say the majority seem to be against gays.
- azinman2 11y agoIn your example I doubt a giant portion of people would say "burn them alive." I don't think you understand race relations in the US. Regardless, this was 2008, not 1950s. It also wasn't only Russia and India. Americans, Europeans, and others also came back with extremely intolerant views as well TO THEIR EMPLOYER AND COLLEAGUES!!
- kozukumi 11y agoWell you didn't mention that second part in your first post did you ;) Also perhaps not burn alive but they certainly didn't have a problem with lynching them in the South did they?
- kybernetyk 11y agoIf someone has different views than you then you have to respect that. And if you don't want to hear about those views then simply don't ask.
- trynumber9 11y ago>Imagine if gave money instead to the KKK Not a great comparison. I don't think the campaign, that Eich donated to, killed people.
- azinman2 11y agoGays are killed in many countries BY LAW. Believe me, many of those running the prop 8 campaign, Family research counsel, etc would like to see gays either imprisoned, committed, killed, or otherwise removed from society. Regardless, the comparison was not meant to be quite so 1:1. It was to illustrate with a "clearer case" that CEOs that support divisive organizations affect the organization that they lead.
- Zigurd 11y agoRead up on suicides of gay Mormons. It's not a tolerant culture.
- humanrebar 11y ago> I think in part because they're likely smarter than the average person so they've completely convinced themselves that they're the rational ones. The average Californian voted for the proposition Eich donated to. Is it rational to compare the majority of Californian voters to the KKK? Is it rational to call the positions of both Obama and Clinton in 2008 hateful?
- leereeves 11y agoThe KKK was likewise once supported by a majority of voters and many politicians.
- humanrebar 11y agoI need a citation to believe that a majority of (which states?) supported assassination and terrorism. In fact the presidents of both parties (Eisenhower and LBJ) signed legislation (two civil rights acts) in direct opposition of the Klan's goals. I'm not saying people need to agree with Eich, but it's an awful false equivalence to compare him to terrorists.
- leereeves 11y agoThe people didn't support assassination and terrorism, in fact those helped bring down the KKK, but they did support the goal of white Protestant supremacy. At its height in the 1920s, before the KKK's downfall in scandal, "claimed Klan membership exceeded four million and comprised 20% of the adult white male population in many broad geographic regions, and 40% in some areas". (cited on Wikipedia). Klan member Edward L. Jackson was elected governor of Indiana, and "Although the full extent of the Klan's power was unknown at that time, it claimed that its members occupied more than half the seats in the Indiana General Assembly, and a large percentage of the local offices in Indiana." (Wikipedia again, but uncited) Regarding Eich, while I don't think he himself supports violence, it's not such a huge leap to violence from a platform whose roots are in the Biblical verses: "You shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination" (Leviticus 18:22) and "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall be put to death; their blood is upon them" (Leviticus 20:13)
- bobby_9x 11y agoSome folks might think that donating money to an abortion clinic amounts to something just as bad, so it's really all about political beliefs. It's ridiculous to me that a group that is supposed to be against oppression, bigotry, and bullying, practices exactly this when it involves people with differing beliefs. It only makes people like Trump even more popular.
- azinman2 11y agoBecause the differing belief has to do with delegitimizating someone else!!! If the believe was personal like I believe in this god, etc, then it doesn't actually affect someone else. What's not clear?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- oldmanjay 11y agoMany people simply aren't willing to let single-issue hysteria drive our behavior, instead prefering to consider many aspects of a given situation. Perhaps unsurprisingly, this leads to better engineering output, but it is not exclusive to engineers.
- kaonashi 11y agoWhen the single issue is basic human rights, it's hardly hysterical.
- JanneVee 11y ago> ... current tech climate of monoculture.... and then a little later > ... especially out of Russia and India.... So the monoculture is of a diverse "national" cultures but it needs to be replaced with a US centric progressive view monoculture? You have to explain your reasoning here. And I don't understand how the opposition to gay marriage is about separating families and is the equivalent of raging racists that lynch innocent people of colour. Can you explain that also?
- briholt 11y agoThey think diversity of race/gender is more important than diversity of opinion. I support marriage equality, but would not equate the opposition to the KKK - that's the kind of extremist thinking that arises in a monoculture bubble.
- epistasis 11y ago>You have to explain your reasoning here. This isn't exactly a new idea about open societies. See for example Karl Popper in 1945: "Less well known is the paradox of tolerance: Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance But it is much more colloquially known as "live and let live." >And I don't understand how the opposition to gay marriage is about separating families and is the equivalent of raging racists that lynch innocent people of colour. Can you explain that also? Also, somewhat tired ground by now, but the California proposition would separated families and deprived them of the legal rights that families have. Your "lynch" analogy is a strawman, the KKK doesn't really do that these days, but it still does vile things. The KKK of today is quite equivalent in effect and practice to California's prop 8.
- JanneVee 11y ago> Also, somewhat tired ground by now, but the California proposition would separated families and deprived them of the legal rights that families have. Your "lynch" analogy is a strawman, the KKK doesn't really do that these days, but it still does vile things. The KKK of today is quite equivalent in effect and practice to California's prop 8. Well I'm not familiar at that level of US culture, and that illustrates the main point of critique that I tried to convey. The Prop 8 and KKK equivalence is a little unclear to me from a different background. But that is impressive, using the paradox of tolerance to advocate protectionism.
- mrbabbage 11y agoThere's a world of difference between opposing gay marriage and supporting a white supremacist terrorist organization. They're not even remotely comparable. Specifically, it's entirely possible to oppose gay marriage on a number of grounds without being homophobic or bigoted; in my experience even as a young gay man in San Francisco, most of the people in my life who don't support gay marriage are perfectly reasonable, kind individuals who don't hate their gay friends. It's rather shallow to consider one's stance on LGBT issues through a single, limited lens, given that there are dozens of other issues (HIV, youth homelessness, alcoholism, depression) that affect the LGBT community.
- Zigurd 11y ago> There's a world of difference between opposing gay marriage and supporting a white supremacist terrorist organization. Not if you are gay and married. And, wow. You then go on to articulate positions that have, in fact, been used against racial minorities and to support miscegenation laws. Just wow. And you're not seeing that?
- dracht 11y agoHere's a gay man, which I would think gives him some authority, sharing his opinion on the matter of same-sex marriage, and here you are telling him his nuanced views are apartheid-enabling. These kinds of exaggerated reactions, false accusations and radical rhetoric is why I do not want to be associated with the self-proclaimed "progressives". To put it in your own terms: your type of demonizing slander has been used to support [insert horrible event].
- Zigurd 11y agoYour position, and that of the OP, rests on religion having a privileged place: It excuses bigotry. That's not nuanced. That's wrong, and the comparison to miscegenation laws, and the various excuses for those laws, is apt. You can't fit a dime between support of miscegenation laws and support for repeal of gay marriage.
- saganus 11y ago
- dracht 11y agoAre you really equating "being against gay marriage" to "being a KKK supporter"? How are/were families separated due to not being able to get married?
- daeken 11y ago> How are/were families separated due to not being able to get married? Many same-sex partners have been barred from hospital rooms, cut off from estates (in the event of their partner's deaths), and limited from access to their children after breakups. These all rely on the legal framework of marriage to navigate, and this was something that was not available to most of the gay population of the US until last year.
- pfortuny 11y agoHave you read the whole text of the SCOTUS? Because it clearly states that people in the US are entitled to think AND opine differently in this issue...
- akerro 11y ago>I remember back when I was at Google in 2008. A survey on lgbt issues went around company wide. What a stupid survey. I would refuse to answer any question if one of hundreds would be about political views. It's not employers matter what I think. If you mentioned that "boycott Mozilla" thing started by OkCupid, let's don't forget that okcupid CEO did the same as Eich. http://blog.sfgate.com/techchron/2014/04/08/okcupid-ceo-once-donated-to-anti-gay-politician/ http://blog.sfgate.com/techchron/2014/04/08/okcupid-ceo-once...
- daeken 11y agoEvery candidate has supported things I disagree strongly with. That doesn't change that they may have supported many more things that I agree even more strongly with. Donating to a campaign against marriage equality is very different than donating to a candidate who (among other things) is against marriage equality.
- acheron 11y agoIsn't there a thing in the HN guidelines about "don't start predictable flamewars"?
- nitrogen 11y agoWhat happened to Eich was the digital and career equivalent to a lynching. Good views (equality) should not be supported by bad behavior (online lynch mobs). But this is almost certainly not a useful subject to rehash when there are no doubt other interesting things to discuss about Mozilla.
- patio11 11y agoThere's a bit of tension between "divisive is bad" and "we should have a diverse industry", unless "diverse" is redefined to mean "San Francisco liberals of all races, genders, etc." "Divisive" is an interesting word, and one very, very useful if you're on the popular side of a monoculture. Anyone asking to be in your industry who you don't like is being divisive.
- azinman2 11y agoDivisive is a word that happens to look like diverse, but they don't mean the same thing at all. I don't understand your logic.
- lmm 11y ago> Was interesting to hear the entire perspective but the "marriage thing?" That wasn't exactly small. Imagine if gave money instead to the KKK... would that have been just "a racial heritage thing?" As long as they operate within the law then that's not something someone should be fired for. Otherwise, would you fire someone for donating to e.g. the Republican party? If you can't express a legal political position without being fired then you don't have free speech[1] in any meaningful sense. [1] Which does not just mean the first amendment, I don't understand the confusion that leads people to think this.
- Frondo 11y agoAs a point of fact, he wasn't fired, he resigned. Aaaand, resigning of your own free will because your employees don't agree with your politics (and may no longer want to follow your leadership) seems like a consequence you should be ready to accept when you engage politically.
- Spooky23 11y agoIt's a great example how how the old notion of keeping business, politics and religion separate makes a lot of sense. If you cannot respect folks professionally, you need to go. If your religious beliefs call for my <insert attribute here> to be condemned/killed/declared heretic/etc, good for you. But we're not taking the issue up at work.
- humanrebar 11y ago> But we're not taking the issue up at work. I think I mostly agree with you on the particulars, but asking religious people to stay in the closet isn't healthy either. Maybe certain discussions need to happen outside of the normal workday, but you wouldn't support a policy that required someone to leave their race, gender, or sexual orientation at home, would you?
- Spooky23 11y agoUnfortunately, religion is a dragon that difficult to tame. My family is Catholic... My wife once was accosted by some fringe evangelical "Christian" guy warning her of imminent doom due to her idolatry of the pope. Not acceptable. You have the right to live as your conscience and values dictate. But you don't have the right to interfere with the ability of others to do the same.
- badsock 11y agoI think what people are missing most in this debate is that the guy was just hired as CEO. One of the CEO's most important roles is to manage shitstorms. Whatever your position is on gay marriage, right out of the gate Eich got overwhelmed. He was the one in the position to do something about the shitstorm, and yet it grew rather than diminished. If you're going to get paid as much as a CEO does, you should be able to finesse difficult PR situations; he clearly couldn't, so it's reasonable that he got axed. The actual topic of the shitstorm doesn't even need to enter into it.
- josinalvo 11y agoHe followed the internal guidelines and respected the TGBL people inside mozilla. That should have been the end of it. "I fundamentally disagree with you about this very important issue, and we should still find a way to cooperate" is a crucial idea, hard won and, as we are seeing, easily lost. It underpins multi-religious societies, working democracies, and in general, any group of people that need to do something. Unfortunately, right now we have groups of people that say the polar oposite: "It is good and moral to shun people who disagree with X". I totally agree with marriage equality. But I think it can be (and mostly was) won on dialogue, not shunning. And I will always be against the shunners (though I hope not to shun them :P).
- josinalvo 11y agobtw, all I just said applies just as well to klanspeople: Are they harming the employees? No? Are they aligned with the mission? Them keep them. And tell them they are stupid over a beer. Talk the shit out, and fight their stupid ideas in the right places. Do not allow political disagreement, even of the most grievous kind, to cut oportunities for dialogue and cooperation.
- honksillet 11y agoJust a reminder. Prop 8 passed in California in 2008 with 52% of the vote. Individuals who held that view where hardly extremists.
- sangnoir 11y ago> Backing something that separates families is divisive and not appropriate for an organization that is about openness and diversity How about end-users that hold the same divisive values as Mr. Eich? Surely Mozilla shouldn't tolerate these either. I recommend a first-run wizard that quizzes the user's political stance. If the user is on the wrong side of history, Firefox will automatically uninstall itself. Nothing is more important than the projects moral purity, right?