5 ms·
This article is fairly typical of ones critical of the H1B program: it looks at average programmer wages instead of controlling for experience or skills. As we
by greglindahl 11y ago
This article is fairly typical of ones critical of the H1B program: it looks at average programmer wages instead of controlling for experience or skills. As we all know, wages for programmers vary widely.
- eloisant 11y agoYes, and H1B can only be renewed for 6 years, and anyone staying longer (and making more with more experience) switches to an green card then eventually citizenship. Additionally some the highest paid foreigners are on an O1 visa, so they don't count in the "H1B average" (while the highest paid Americans are in the same bag as the others).
- JPKab 11y agoI think that the non-abusers of the program are truly in need of people with special skills that can't be found. However, the "average programmer" salary is actually very effective when looking at the aggregate. If a programmer has skills that can't be found in a given location, you would expect them to command a very high market value, rather than an average, let alone below average market value. Tata, Infosys, etc have ruined the H1B for what it was supposed to be used for. The government's useless bureaucratic oversight allows companies to claim that a journeyman SQL Server DBA is impossible to find in the US and hire from a body-shop instead. The biggest victims of this are the start-ups who truly need to bring in top-caliber talent and can't get a visa in the lottery.
- learc83 11y agoSo you're saying that if we control for skill and experience H-1B programmers don't make less, but their overall average wage is less. That means that we are hiring H-1B workers who are less skilled than the average US worker. How is that any better?
- nostrebored 11y agoHow is the parent saying that? I'm interpreting this as given two identical employees an h1b would be paid less.
- learc83 11y ago>I'm interpreting this as given two identical employees an h1b would be paid less. That is what the study implies. The parent says, no this is not the case because they didn't control skills and experience, so some other factor must be causing the observation that H-1B workers are paid less. In that case the only other option to explain the results is that the average H-1B worker is less skilled or less experienced.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nostrebored 11y agoHow is the parent saying that? I'm interpreting this as given two identical employees an h1b would be paid less.
- diogenescynic 11y ago>instead of controlling for experience or skills. They lie about this on the H-1B applications and game the prevailing wage system. If you've ever applied for an H-1B then you know how easy it is to abuse the prevailing wages. The process to evaluate the skills of the applicant is simply filling out a form online for their experience level, job title, and location. Give it a test here: http://www.flcdatacenter.com/OesWizardStart.aspx http://www.flcdatacenter.com/OesWizardStart.aspx It's very easy to game their job title and location to lower the salary.